4 ms·
How do the tax write-offs factor in? It seems almost impossible that advertising doesn't provide benefit when you consider the money would have otherwise gone t
by giantg2 5y ago
How do the tax write-offs factor in? It seems almost impossible that advertising doesn't provide benefit when you consider the money would have otherwise gone to taxes.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is not an issue because taxes are on profit, not revenue. Needlessly wasting revenue shrinks profit faster than it shrinks tax liability. e.g. You don't burn a dollar to save 20 cents on income tax because you are still loosing 80 cents.
- giantg2 5y agoIf they can't get 80% back, that's pretty bad. I was wondering how these marginal net negative numbers worked. If they're saying it's 95% back, then that's still higher than 80%.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThink of this way: You have $2 profit. You can take it paying 0.4 in taxes, leaving 1.6 after taxes. OR You have $2, reinvest an extra $1 on marketing with 80% return. You now have 1.8 total profit. You pay 0.36 in taxes, leaving 1.46 You will always loose money if the marketing ROI is less than 100%
- malshe 5y agoCan you elaborate your calculation more? Are you using $1 from the $2 profit to reinvest in advertising? Also are you getting an 80% return on that $1 meaning getting back $1.8? ($1 investment in advertising + $0.8 profit)
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIn short, %80 return means that if you spend 1.0, you only get back 0.8. You forever lose the $1 spent, but get more sales and worth $0.8 after costs. Here are more details (repeated for clarity) Assumptions: 20% corporate tax rate (assessed on total profit) 80% Marginal rate of return for advertising (next dollar you can spend) 1) You have $2 profit (before taxes). You can take it and pay $0.4 in taxes, leaving $1.6 after taxes. OR You have $2 profit (before taxes), You spend an extra $1 on marketing with 80% return. The $1 spent on advertising returns you $0.8. You now have 1.8 total profit. You pay 20% ($0.36) in taxes, leaving 1.46 You will always loose money if the marketing ROI is less than 100%
- malshe 5y agoOk, thanks for the explanation. I got confused because of your definition of ROI. Normally, ROI of 80% would mean you invest $1 and get back $1.8 in return. see https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/returnoninvestment.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/returnoninvestment.asp. What you described will mean -20% return and not 80% return. But I get the point you are making and I agree with it.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI see, sorry for the confusion.
- weego 5y agoThat's not how taxes work. It's also kind of damming of the entire industry if that's the fallback excuse for existing.
- giantg2 5y agoI'm wondering if that was a factor in the marginal net negative calculations. That could be enough to switch them positive.
- malshe 5y agoThis is a great point, and the authors don't take it into account. Expensing advertising certainly provides tax shield and it will make a significant difference at the margin. Edit: The taxation become relevant while considering expensing vs capitalizing advertising. I am not an accountant but from what I understand, at least in the US, advertising is commonly expensed.