10 ms·
There is a fundamental misunderstanding (intentional or not) with these types of studies and claims. Limited-time promotions, e.g. a 10% off sale, work on shor
by hammock 5y ago
There is a fundamental misunderstanding (intentional or not) with these types of studies and claims.
Limited-time promotions, e.g. a 10% off sale, work on short timescales that are easily measured. You can easily say what the ROI is of an advertised promotion, and it is often positive. (Side note, these promotions have a more-difficult-to-measure detrimental effect on your long-term profitability, closely related to the point I am about to make below)
Brand advertising, in contrast, works on a spread-out scale of years or decades. When Coca-Cola runs a polar bear ad at Christmastime they don't do it to increase sales of Coke that week, nor should it be measured that way.
The actual effect that a brand advertisement has, is to add PENNIES (not dollars) to their sales every day, for the next 100 YEARS. It's a long-term investment. And for these reasons hard if not impossible to measure or control for confounders - but that doesn't mean it doesn't work!!
And without that brand investment, their brand value is continuously eroding away, at a rate of pennies (or more) per day.
Source: Been on the leading edge of marketing and advertising for over 12 years
- mihaaly 5y agoIf you cannot measure then you are just bluffing that it works! You cannot know yourself for god's sake! "Been on the leading edge of marketing and advertising for over 12 years " Aaaaaah, I see! It is your personal interest to be payed very well for unsubstantiated claims! Fishing in troubled waters. We will consider your !!opinion!! accordingly....
- btilly 5y agoAnd how do you measure the value delivered? If you're not measuring value delivered, how do you know that you're actually delivering value? Remember, you're the person that you can most easily fool. Fields as diverse as active fund management and psychic readings have been filled with practitioners who were wrong about the value that they thought that they were delivering. I have no particular reason to believe that brand management isn't another.
- echelon 5y ago> Source: Been on the leading edge of marketing and advertising for over 12 years Would you say that might be a source of bias? Look at SpaceX and Tesla. They barely advertise and have huge brand recognition. I'd buy Sennheiser over Beats. Krispy Kreme over Dunkin. Costco. My partner loves Zara. I don't have a high opinion of brands that advertise.
- handmodel 5y agoI think its fair to say that the reasons a rocket company does not need to advertise dont apply to companies that people buy weekly/monthly on a grocery store shelf. Besides, the advertising budget of other government contractors/satellite companies is also close to zero. The better question is "If I ran Pepsi today - would I drastically lower the advertising budget". I'm not sure what my move would be but I don't think looking at short term ROI of TV ads would be informative.
- btilly 5y agoAnd yet https://cometcleaner.com/ https://cometcleaner.com/ is an enduring consumer brand that has been around for decades and does basically no advertising. A story that I remember from the 80s is that the brought in a consultant to improve sales. Rather than advertising, they opted to add one more hole to their cans. Sales went up 20%.
- echelon 5y ago> rocket company does not need to advertise dont apply to companies that people buy weekly/monthly on a grocery store shelf. Starlink? That's consumer-facing.
- handmodel 5y agoI think if we get to the point where they are trying to get people to switch their cell phone or internet plans - they will do more traditional tv/online advertising. That being said - I don't think a successful one-time advertising push by a completely new field speaks to the long-term benefits of it once they (presumably) become established.
- sumtechguy 5y agoAlso Tesla does not 'need' to advertise, yet. It is effectively advertised by everyone for Elon for near 0 dollars. Launch a rocket (different company) the article will mention Tesla for them. Talk about saving the environment guess who gets mentioned. Talk about power needs, Tesla comes up as cars are becoming a large consumer of electricity, solar, coal, nuke, etc. His advertising is basically being done for free by companies who do not even really realize it.
- andreilys 5y agoAnd for these reasons hard if not impossible to measure or control for confounders - but that doesn't mean it doesn't work!! One of the ways that advertisers and marketing people stay employed is they say that the output of their effort and money spent is not quantifiable.
- mjburgess 5y agoIndeed. When I walk into the store there are a very limited number of colas on offer: a can of pepsi, a can of coke, etc. What exactly is the advert for? My choice has largely been made.
- hammock 5y agoA lot of marketing money is "paid" (simplifying here, but I can expand if desired) to get that shelf space from the store, as well, in ways that you probably didn't know/haven't thought about.
- bluGill 5y agodepends on the Store. WalMart doesn't sell shelf space the way most others do. Though WalMart is doing their own something that I don't understand.
- handmodel 5y agoI think I have the opposite reaction from the same data. The reason I can't get my own sugar water on a grocery store shelf is because the grocery store doesn't want to give space to something that only sells half as well. And, they are humans too, so I'm sure they are biased by the ads/perception of what they think other people want. I think a lot of the long-term bonus of ads is to simply build a moat that other competitors find difficult to surmount.
- nickff 5y agoI think you're overlooking a couple of grocery-specific issues. Many major retailers will require that new brands invest a certain amount of money in advertising product to their region/market before stocking the product. It's also common to 'lease' shelf space to manufacturers.
- nabla9 5y ago> And for these reasons hard if not impossible to measure or control for confounders Are you saying that you don't know if long term brand advertisement works?
- altdataseller 5y agoAbsolutely not. It’s hard for me to tell how much of an effect exercising will have on my lifespan. Will it add 4.5 years? 10 years? But I know that exercising daily will most likely have a positive effect.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wisemanwillhear 5y ago> Brand advertising, in contrast, works on a spread-out scale of years or decades. When Coca-Cola runs a polar bear ad at Christmastime they don't do it to increase sales of Coke that week, nor should it be measured that way. Curious... A year ago, an older lady gave our daughter a little Coca-cola polar bear stuffed animal. It seems their advertising dollars are still having an "influence".
- slg 5y ago>Brand advertising, in contrast, works on a spread-out scale of years or decades...The actual effect that a brand advertisement has, is to add PENNIES (not dollars) to their sales every day, for the next 100 YEARS. It's a long-term investment. And for these reasons hard if not impossible to measure or control for confounders - but that doesn't mean it doesn't work!! Car brands are the obvious example of brand advertising. They are among the most common TV advertisers but they don't expect people to immediately go out and spend $50k on a new Mercedes-Benz after watching a 30 second commercial. They just want to establish Mercedes-Benz as a brand of luxury, performance, technology, etc. That way the next time you are in the market to buy a car you already have an ingrained positive perception of Mercedes-Benz that might help sway your decision.
- reader_mode 5y agoAnd yet the most valuable car company in the world (for whatever that's worth) spends 0 on advertising and sells everything they can produce.
- r00fus 5y agoMarket cap (ie, stock price) is not a good indicator of present value, but perceived future value. Edit: I also think TSLA isn't a car company. More like a battery company.
- reader_mode 5y agoSomeone here was arguing that advertising can't be measured only through impact on present sales but "good will and long term value". Tesla seemingly has good will beyond any competitors. Also Tesla is buying battery cells, sells cars and expects to have third parties supply batteries long term - how can they be a battery company ?
- r00fus 5y agoSame way Apple is a computer company but Foxconn does most of the building of said computers?
- tlogan 5y agoThis is exactly the problem: it is impossible to measure how much advertising helps. And maybe there are some measurements but they are not known. You might be right or you might be wrong. For example, I do not see Tesla commercials on TV so I wonder if they will sell more cars in next decade if they advertise as other car companies? Is Tesla making a mistake?
- bluGill 5y ago> it is impossible to measure how much advertising helps That is false. It is impossible to measure exactly, but statistics can put a range on it, confidence intervals, and other such things (which I've mostly forgotten since school). We can measure all this to close enough.
- captaincaveman 5y agoIf a competitive alternative cool electric car appears, and they use advertising to steer the opinion of the public of being the best electric cars on the market ... I think Tesla will start advertising!
- ksec 5y agoVery rare high quality comments on Ads. Do you ever find annoying that the current narrative on the internet ( and on HN ) that All advertisement are bad? Approaching to the point of finding people working inside Ads industry as witch hunt?
- floxy 5y agoThoughts on this take about luxury branding? https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2011/11/luxury_branding_the_future_lea.html https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2011/11/luxury_branding_the_...
- avidiax 5y agoOverly long, a bit smarmy. The main points, that the audience for that ad aspires to be old money while at best being nouveau riche, and ads that appear to be for women but are placed in a men's magazine are actually for men both seem accurate to me.
- yKnoTho 5y agoI mean, you pretty much just validated it’s all “manufactured consent”. Spending money to chant a specific message to tune brain chemistry, awareness, and memory, lest they die out.
- ohuf 5y ago... which is pretty convenient for you and guys, because if you look at it that long-term way, nobody can tell that your whole product is a useless scam
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoAnd this is the best argument to bring back old school banner ads that were just an image without any third party js, or tracking. Advertisements don't have to work NOW they have to work eventually. At least it's the best argument from the advertisers side.
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> is to add PENNIES (not dollars) to their sales every day How much growth has Coca-Cola seen on their specific "Coke" line of products? How many people who don't already drink Coke, Coke Zero, or Diet Coke are going to be influenced by a (probably very expensive) TV advertisement reminding them that Coke as a brand of sugary drink exists? I feel like if they ever wanted to save millions and millions of dollars, they could just stop advertising. Something something Sriracha
- cbsks 5y agoYou and I certainly do not need to see any more Coca-Cola advertisements to remember that the brand exists when we are choosing what drink to buy. But there are hundreds of thousands of people born every day. If Coca-Cola stops advertising it may not impact their sales for years, but eventually they could fade away.
- bluGill 5y agoThe ketchup industry stopped advertising, and over the next 50 years their market share went down. Nobody knows for sure how much was stopping advertising, but nobody wants to take a chance.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoThey have to keep up the appearance that they are pretty much the only cola drink you ever want to buy. If they stop all their advertising, people would start seeing other brands (and I don't mean just Pepsi, all the other lesser known local brands as well) as viable options. At least I think that's their logic.
- jmann99999 5y agoI agree with you on large national/international brands; however most of the brands that I see on cable TV in the U.S. aren't similar to Coca Cola. They are a fitness device that I have never heard of. They are a dry good that I didn't know existed. I would love to provide an example, but I can't remember any of those brands. The study cited by the OP has an interesting appendix [0]. It shows the depths they went to in order to conduct the study. The level of ads are also dissected into national, regional, and local ads. If you look at the final table in the study which shows all the categories of brands examined, I would challenge anyone to remember a brand or product they saw on TV related to many of them. Dough products? Eggs? Maybe I have seen an add for a paper product (top category of advertising), but I can't remember who that would be. Bounty... maybe? [0] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/action/downloadSupplement?doi=10.3982%2FECTA17674&file=ecta200319-sup-0001-onlineappendix.pdf https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/action/downloadSupplement?do...
- rangersanger 5y agoOkay, I agree with everything you've said. In a "Data driven" organization, how do you prove that your brand marketing is working in order to protect it? A new leader comes in and says "this isn't adding value, you cant prove it's adding value, I'm cutting it unless you can prove it." What's your response?
- tehjoker 5y agoA data driven organization is too short sighted to value things that aren't easily measured.
- marrone12 5y agoYou can a/b test brand marketing effectiveness. Test and control markets over a long time frame, let's say 6 months to a year. The problem is that the level of investment is quite high and that the total results take a long time to reach significance.
- fukmbas 5y agoBoth are an absolutely useless waste of resources for society
- etempleton 5y agoAnd no one wants to hear this. They want results tomorrow because their job depends on it. All good advertising is long-term advertising, but hardly anyone has the patience for it anymore.
- Clampower 5y agoI fundamentally disagree with your Coca Cola example. This is a prime example of introducing a new use case for a product which is traditionally associated with summer and warmer climates. It’s done directly to increase sales during the winter time and to associate the brand with Christmas.