3 ms·
Title is critically incorrect. It should be: > The ROI analysis shows negative ROIs at the margin for more than 80% of brands, implying over-investment in adv
by lupire 5y ago
Title is critically incorrect.
It should be:
> The ROI analysis shows negative ROIs at the margin for more than 80% of brands, implying over-investment in advertising by most firms.
- evancox100 5y agoYou are correct, but if you look at total instead of marginal the picture's not much better. While 80% of brands have negative marginal ROI, 67% (2/3) have negative net ROI, and so would presumably be better off with zero advertising.
- singhrac 5y agoNot necessarily. The thing to measure is the marginal ROI at zero advertising spend. Derivatives are not bounded by their average value across a range.
- mlyle 5y agoThe claim was: "67% (2/3) have negative net ROI, and so would presumably be better off with zero advertising." If they truly have negative net ROI, they would be better off with zero spending than their actual spending. The claim holds. > The thing to measure is the marginal ROI at zero advertising spend. Derivatives are not bounded by their average value across a range. OK, so if we're going to get super pedantic... the derivative could be negative at the current value, and at zero, and there could be a positive ROI for some value of spending (between 0 and the amount spent, or even for some value more than what was spent). But it's not really likely, nor relevant to the point the person above made.
- evancox100 5y agoFurthering the pedantry, even assuming monotonically decreasing ROI as ad spending increases, as long as ROI of the first dollar was positive, there would be some optimum between zero and current levels. But my original statement still holds, zero would be preferable to current levels of spending for those brands.
- rhizome 5y agoI'm not an MBA nor even a math person really, what is the "I" in this equation when the ad spend is zero?
- zeusk 5y agoYou just take the interval (0, inf). So you analyze it as limit spend -> 0+ in that region. My personal opinion however is that ad industry is a big scam.
- dang 5y agoSubmitted title was "Advertisement has a negative return on investment for more than 80% of brands", which broke the site guidelines, which ask: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize.". We've fixed it now. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mbesto 5y agoI can't see the whole article, but if they don't mention advertising for brand recognition then they are missing half the puzzle (i.e. indirect effectiveness, which is almost impossible to measure). Coca Cola doesn't shower 16-25 year males with ads because they think they'll walk out the door and go buy a can of Coke. They do it because when they have discretionary income (age 22+), they recognize the brand. This is impossible to measure precisely.