5 ms·
TV ads. Where you can't measure response rate directly.
by Animats 5y ago
TV ads.
Where you can't measure response rate directly.
- jondwillis 5y agoThe editorialized title here should probably be changed...
- ohazi 5y agoAlso where "modern" "smart" platforms decide it's acceptable to chop up a video into a dozen slices and insert the same. exact. ad. in between each segment, causing half the viewers to swear off that brand for life?
- wyldfire 5y agoI don't know if it's for a lack of bidders, or if the ads are that way by design. Some of what you're paying for is brand identification and repetitive commercials are one way to get that. Despite however annoying it might seem. The pool being advertised to will consider the advertised brand when 'Good/Service Need X' arises, whereas they likely would not without the ads.
- lupire 5y ago50% is tiny. I'd estimate most YouTube product ads only sell to <1% of the population.
- 015a 5y agoHulu is one of the worst at this, and it's astounding to me how seemingly willfully dumb advertisers can be. It makes me think that no one in this industry actually cares. You've got marketing and advertising executives commanding eight figure budgets, inventing whatever metrics they need to showcase success and protect their jobs. They pay YouTube, Hulu, Samsung, etc millions, who provide back whatever engineered metrics they need to keep getting those paychecks. You'd think there'd at least be some evidence in mapping advertising spend back to revenue, but I suspect that the platforms who can actually do this (e.g. Etsy) don't last very long or see worse advertising revenue, because it becomes startlingly obvious how poorly advertising works (especially when automated at scale). It's a house of cards, with so many people deeply invested, spending their entire careers justifying their position, that it probably wont ever change.
- sfblah 5y agoThis is exactly the dynamic we see in my company working on search ads.
- stronglikedan 5y agoSimilarly, the only game I play on my phone is a card game, and ever since I visited my company's website to check on something, our Google ad is shown between hands almost 90% of the time. I never click on it, so you'd think they'd stop showing it after the 500th time (it's been weeks since I visited the website). Is that just a ploy by Google to overcharge us for advertising?
- bluGill 5y ago> Where you can't measure response rate directly. You can never measure response rate directly. There will always be people who see your ad and then respond later (possibly by some other ad on a different platform that they wouldn't have responded to in the first place otherwise). This might or might not matter to you. The large companies who buy ads have statistical departments tracking their ad response. They know how well the ads work to close enough for their purposes. Those departments don't need the direct response rate because there are better measures.
- sfblah 5y agoI work for a company involved in search engine advertising. While it's technically possible to track conversions, very very few customers actually do it. Some don't have a great way to track it (health-care products where there's a privacy issue, brand advertising, informational advertising, services where there's no obvious immediate call to action, etc.) Even among those who do track "conversions," I'd say under 10% of them actually define a conversion as something where money is exchanged immediately, which makes it hard to defraud. More than half of the conversion tracking we see just requires the user to spend a certain amount of time on the website, visit a certain number of pages or to provide an email address. Not surprisingly, we see a massive dropoff in conversion percentage when money needs to change hands. It's more than 90%. Also, not surprisingly, when some action is required for conversion, we see more than half of the visitors taking that exact action and nothing more. Our analysis of the above is that more than half of clickers on search ads, and probably more like 80%+ are just bots (or human "bots" in clickfarms) clicking the ads and then pretending to convert. Their incentive is that they are clicking ads on search pages where they get a share of the revenue. Interestingly, when we alert customers to this dynamic and try to get them to shift their ad spend or conversion tracking to prevent this kind of behavior, they actively do not care and prevent us from doing it. Our analysis there is that marketing managers in general know that what they're doing is largely ineffective, but they don't want to admit that to their bosses because then it puts their jobs at risk. So, what we do is help them maximize where we can, without pushing them too hard on the above: "Humankind cannot bear very much reality."
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoHave you considered that the marketing managers are the ones hiring the bots to meet their goals for a bonus?
- sfblah 5y agoI love this idea, but I sincerely doubt it.
- mateo411 5y agoIt's harder to measure than digital ads, but plenty of companies measure the effectiveness of TV ads.