3 ms·
Some depressing reasons why I can't get excited about this: 1) Speed of light, that inconvenient fact. Somehow in sci-fi stories, that's supposedly "overcome"
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Some depressing reasons why I can't get excited about this:
1) Speed of light, that inconvenient fact. Somehow in sci-fi stories, that's supposedly "overcome" someday? What if it never is?
2) Intelligent life on Earth is indeed "unlikely" given all the things that could have extinguished it by now. However, given billions of galaxies, it must have existed in many, many places, maybe even in our own galaxy, and some of them are maybe even still around.
3) Given (1), they will never contact us, nor will we contact them.
4) Even if you don't accept (1) through (3), what could anyone usefully do about it?
- everdrive 5y agoEven if intelligent life existed in a nearby galaxy, our civilization might be gone by the time a communication manages to go round trip. More realistically, what are the odds that civilizations in the universe occur near to each other in both space AND time? ie, perhaps an ancient civilization 1,000 light years away came and went 20,000 years ago? Or longer? There's no chance we'd sync up.
- simiones 5y ago> 2) Intelligent life on Earth is indeed "unlikely" given all the things that could have extinguished it by now. However, given billions of galaxies, it must have existed in many, many places, maybe even in our own galaxy, and some of them are maybe even still around. "Must" is an extremely strong word to use for something with entirely unknown probability. There is absolutely no basis to calculate a probability of life existing at all (except to say that it is >0, since we exist), and intelligence is many more steps above that. The full extent of what we can say with any kind of certainty at all about intelligent life is that the probability of it existing outside Earth is non-0. Basically anything else is wild speculation. I'll also add that discussing time across the entire universe is meaningless, as we know from special relativity. An event in another galaxy that is outside our light hyper-cone has no time-like relation to our own history. A civilization in a galaxy that's 1M light years away from us can be seen as concurrent with us by some observers, can be seen as existing in our distant past by other observers (up to 1M years ago), or in our distant future by yet others (up to 1M years in our future).
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou're right; "must" is the wrong word. How about "seems possible?"
- ryandrake 5y agoThe speed of light isn't as much of a bummer as our inability to approach it. According to Wikipedia, there are at least 10 terrestrial exoplanets in the habitable zone, within 40 light years of Earth. Thanks to time dilation, if we could figure out how to travel there at say 95% of the speed of light, it would only take about 15 years or so from the traveler's point of view to get there. You don't even need a sci-fi "generation" ship. You could send a team of healthy 20-30 year olds, and those same people could start colonizing well before old age hits. If you could achieve 99% the speed of light, you could go 3X that distance comfortably within the travelers' healthy age range. Hell, if we could go 99.999999% of c, a traveler could visit anywhere in the galaxy, only aging 15 years.
- sbierwagen 5y ago>Somehow in sci-fi stories, that's supposedly "overcome" someday It's always overcome in stories about humans, conducted at biological timescales. There are many ways to construct a functional interstellar civilization that just aren't very interesting to read about, much like how nearly all people living today have lives that wouldn't make a good novel. Nonsentient mesoscale replicators riding solar sails that take thousands of years of years to visit stars would be cheap, reliable, scalable, and fantastically boring as the subject of a fiction novel; given the lack of any human characters or human conflict.