2 ms·
"If Substack is successful, it will remind news consumers that paying for good journalism is worth it,” wrote the University of Maine’s Michael Socolow " Talki
by rchaud 5y ago
"If Substack is successful, it will remind news consumers that paying for good journalism is worth it,” wrote the University of Maine’s Michael Socolow "
Talking about the news doesn't make one a 'journalist'. What was Andrew Sullivan's last scoop?
Reporting, fact-checking, corroborating source statements...this is slow, invisible work. It is the polar opposite of 'content production', which requires a regular posting schedule. With investigative reporting, it's generally not possible to get in your 2 cents out when the topic is still hot in the news cycle.
Yet with Substack, and any other content promotion business, you not only have to come up with original content, but spend time creating graphics and promotional copy and maintaining a presence and 'personality' for Twitter.
It's absurd to think that you're getting an 'insider's scoop with no editorial filter' for anything related to real news.
- dalbasal 5y agoSo... I think there are two seperate things here, besides ownership of the prestige word "journalism." One is "reporting," which involves fact-checking, corroborating source statements and such. This is, I agree, something that generally needs an organisation. The other is investigative journalism. This can be done independently & can't be scooped, but it is an incredibly inefficient way of putting ink on paper. Investigations take weeks, months or years and not every investigation finds much worth reporting. This is incredibly important, but god only knows hows its supposed to be funded. Where it is done, its subsidized, cross subsidized, snuck in or done unpaid. This is as much an issue at NYT as it is on substack. There's no known general solution to this problem. All that said, most of what most people read, listen to and watch is neither of these things. It's commentary and rhetoric. Those aren't bad, they're just overabundant, everywhere... not just substack. In fact, if you take a glance at politically fringe publications like Breitbart, Jacobin, Democracy Now, etc.... You will find that most of it is such content. News first published elsewhere, with new commentary. Its like this everywhere: left, right, centre, establishment, dissident, corporate, independant. If there's intelligent life on mars, I reckon their papers will be full of it too.