6 ms·
Could, should, might, shouldn’t – A taxonomy of futurists
- dredmorbius 5y agoNick Foster's matrix might be revealed in a mix of principles: Technology is the study of means, as John Stuart Mill put it. (Mill contrasts this with science, the study of causes.) A technology is a verb, a process to obtain a result. We often see the manifestations (tools, mechanisms, products), but those merely support and guide the process. - Any intervention has both intended and unintended effects. - Effects may be manifest or latent, similar to Robert K. Merton's notion of manifest and latent functions. - Effects, whether manifest or latent, may be short-term or long-term. - The overall process may be readily communicated (learned, sold, advocated, adopted), or difficult. - Implementations and interactions may be simple or complex. That's five dimensions rather than two, though there's a strong correlation between most of the last five might be collapsed to a simple/complex or easy/difficult axis. And of course, the distributions aren't binary but continuous, though they're probably not strictly normally distributed. Optimists deal with the intended, manifest, short-term, and readily grasped. Pessimists deal with the unintended, latent, long-term, and that grasped only with difficulty. In discussing latent and manifest functions, Merton makes the observation that: Discovery of latent functions represents significant increments in sociological knowledge .... It is precisely the latent functions of a practice or belief which are not common knowledge, for these are unintended and generally unrecognized social and psychological consequences. Robert K. Merton, "Manifest and Latent Functions", in Wesley Longhofer, Daniel Winchester (eds) Social Theory Re-Wired, Routledge (2016). https://www.worldcat.org/title/social-theory-re-wired-new-connections-to-classical-and-contemporary-perspectives/oclc/1062283702 https://www.worldcat.org/title/social-theory-re-wired-new-co... There are other elements to this, including positivity bias and the power of denial over unpleasant truths. These seem fairly evident in the futurist trade. I read Alvin Toffler's Future Shock for the first time last year, on its 50th anniversary. My overall impression was that the book actually holds up quite well, though its best points are generally those looking at the long-term complications of technology. Individual technology advocates are most likely to be wrong, almost always because they were grossly overoptimistic (again, with a few exceptions). Many of the social predictions seem quaint, but that's almost always because they did in fact come true, and we're living in the world that's resulted from this, such that the view from the other side seems naive. The psychological elements, the ongoing psychological strain of dealing with continuous change, seems highly apropos.
- blueyes 5y agoMerton's ideas seem really useful, thanks for linking to them.
- dredmorbius 5y agoHe's a huge name in sociology. I'd just sort of stumbled across a reference, then kept finding good stuff in his work. His son, Robert C. Merton, is a Nobel laureate economist, FWIW. (Cue the old economics-sociology rivalry.)
- vonnik 5y agoAI tends to accentuate many of the types that Foster describes, and the trends in Merton's rubric above. AI millenarians (Musk, EA, MIRI) combine certainty that superintelligence will come about with concern that it will be bad. They are in Foster's "shouldn't" class. AI boosters, which are most of the people working on AI in big tech and startups, are in the "could" bucket. They still see the rainbows, short term and long term. AI pragmatists (Hinton, LeCun, Ng) minimize what AI can do, focus on near term gains, and on the difficulties in achieving them. These people are also mostly in big tech and startups, but usually closer to the code and the data. They are the "shoulds" and sometimes the "mights". But there are a couple other dimensions to AI that I'm not sure I have the right words for. There's a certain kind of person who is more of an adventurer. They just want to be close to the action, almost regardless of the outcome. They are building AI, sometimes very powerful AI, but the ultimate consequences of that work are less important than the fact that they, as individuals, are at the fulcrum of this historical moment. And there is a large faith-based element to AI, which I suspect applies to other futurist topics to a lesser extent. And that faith-based framework creates tribal arguments about unfalsifiable claims, like the advent of superintelligence. Instead of "should" or "should", they fit into the "will" class, and they provoke skepticism that is just as strong and irrational. Pragmatists sometimes tip over into this group.
- whatshisface 5y ago>Pessimists deal with the unintended, latent, long-term, and that grasped only with difficulty. It's a sign of extreme optimism to think that unintented, latent, long term and difficult to grasp implications can be predicted at all when the subject is as complex as "everything human beings value."
- ozataman 5y agoI think what you want here is a radar chart, not a 2-2 matrix. I suspect most people embody these different types to varying degrees over time, topics and circumstances.
- blazespin 5y agoThis is an awesome start, but needs formalizing! She/He’s really onto something here. Someone skilled here needs to pick this up.
- mistermann 5y agoBig time, the world has (might have?) a severe lack of metacognition, diversity of thinking styles and capabilities (perceived upper bound), self-awareness, curiousity, etc.
- karaterobot 5y agoAnother useful distinction might be between people who make predictions, prescriptions, imaginings, warnings, etc., about things they are already expert in (a scientist making narrow claims about their specific domain, a SF writer unpacking the social ramifications of some technology in their story), and a self-described futurist, who has made it their job to talk about the future in a broader way. That is, people who you would describe as futurists post hoc, and people who have it on their business cards. I am highly skeptical of the latter!
- dredmorbius 5y agoI don't find the distinction is quite so clear. There seem to be two forces coming to bear. One is specific expertise in some domain. Here, there's a challenge in that generalists must of necessity have lesser specific expertise than, well, experts. This a general problem (so to speak) of synoptic or syncretic works. (One such has a wonderful disclaimer in its preface, I'll see if I can dig that up.) The other is self-interest in a specific application area. This is where knowledge becomes secodary to bias, and there are numerous cases of people with deep expertise in specific fields proving poor counsel for considered and complete judgement of them. Edward Midgely (inventor of two of the greatest scourges of the 20th century, leaded petrol and chloroflourocarbon refrigerants) is perhaps the exemplar of this tendency, though he has ample company. As I mentioned earlier in thread, Alvin Toffler, author of Future Shock (1970), does pretty well in giving both the optimistic and pessimistic side of technologies. In my estimation, the book's strengths largely come from critics, its weaknesses largely from specific domain experts. Toffler himself (and his often under-credited wife) are not domain experts themselves. There's a generalist-class which often climbs on the cheerleading wagon, though, and that is those who advocate for numerous technologies, though they might better be seen as specialists in advocacy, public relations, and propaganda. Beware those whose principle interest is in making others look good. (Or bad.) There are also experts who have voiced strong cautions over specific technologies. They're often sidelined for doing so (a general hazard of whistleblowing), though some have seen success. One such case is Paul Baran, a co-inventer of packet-based switched networks, the technology on which the Internet was based. Baran wrote numerous articles whilst at RAND cautioning against risks of computing in the 1960s, many of which read as highly relevant and prescient even today. Those are now freely available to the public at my specific request: https://www.rand.org/pubs/authors/b/baran_paul.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/authors/b/baran_paul.html I've compiled a listing of other early cautions concerning privacy and surveillance around computer technology: https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105074933053020193 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105074933053020193