2 ms·
> the team had considered the identity switch theory while Jeanne was still alive because she looked younger than her daughter in photographs, but similar discr
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
> the team had considered the identity switch theory while Jeanne was still alive because she looked younger than her daughter in photographs, but similar discrepancies in the rates of aging are commonly found in families with centenarian members.
That doesn't sound too convincing - what if those similar discrepancies are also caused by fraud? It's one of the rare cases where Occam's razor would support foul play over the "simpler" claim.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoOccam's razor does not support anything over the "simpler" claim, you would instead have to argue that fraud about aging is simpler than families with centenarian members have similar discrepancies in the rates of aging. I suppose for that argument to be simpler you would need to have an overview of how many centenarians have these similar discrepancies, and then compare to how often fraud is generally found with younger groups. If you have fraud in younger groups were children have assumed the identities of their parents at a rate that would match the same thing happening in older groups if we assumed that the older groups were in fact fraudulent in this way then I suppose it would be simpler to assume that those centenarians were frauds rather than assume an unknown property of centenarians that allowed them to be easily confused with their children while in middle age. however if centenarians are not frauds it seems likely they would age slower than others or be in some way more robust, and if so it seems reasonable they might closely resemble their adult children if they had those children at a fairly young age.