3 ms·
There's still no background sync or access to APIs that aren't purely cosmetic. That's why native implementations of an app always "feel" better.
by smoldesu 5y ago
There's still no background sync or access to APIs that aren't purely cosmetic. That's why native implementations of an app always "feel" better.
- diebeforei485 5y agoI hope the lack of background sync stays as a #wontfix, because I view it as a feature.
- smoldesu 5y agoThat shouldn't prevent it from being an opt-in toggle for the people (like me) who rely on it.
- diebeforei485 5y agoDisagree. Things that start as "optional opt-in toggles" can eventually become quasi-mandatory, for example if you're a student, employee, or citizen, and your school, workplace, or government creates an app that needs this. In 2020, lots of universities required students to install fairly invasive stuff on their computers for remote learning, but -- thanks in large part to Apple's policies -- their phones remained pretty much untouched.
- smoldesu 5y agoHow do you make an app that enforces notifications? Unless such an app is running in ring 0, it has to follow the same rules as everyone else. In any case, notifications are entirely handled by the operating system, so the onus would fall on Apple to prevent this fairly simple exploit from happening (hell, Android managed to do it right). Furthermore, Proctorio and plenty of other invasive testing software has no trouble running on a Mac. Your last sentance is about as coherent as thanking Google for stopping McGraw-Hill from spying on Android users.
- dwaite 5y agoSimilar to how javascript is a toggle, or how accepting third/first party cookies are toggles? Because the web is mostly useless if any of those are turned off now - even easy cases like static forms commonly break with javascript off rather than degrading to just server-side validation.
- heavyset_go 5y agoFirefox has been blocking third party cookies for quite some time now without problems. It's also quite literally a toggle.
- halostatue 5y agoAnd my phone's battery life appreciates that.
- smoldesu 5y agoI don't notice any hits to battery leaving it on, and I've got 2 or 3 PWAs that ping with notifications throughout the day. YMMV, but I see no reason why Apple couldn't enforce this feature at least as well as a cheap Android smartphone can. As long as it's opt-in, they can please everyone here.
- dwaite 5y agoYou will likely never have Apple support functionality behind a PWA flag other than cosmetic things, because it is still the same overall security model - one of dynamically-updated web content without any third party auditor or enforcement against abuse. Thats not to say they shouldn't support additional web functionality for everyone, just that "Add to Home Screen" is likely never going to unlock additional native hardware capabilities or exclusive background processing modes. This is also why every browser implements web extensions via a store model. The store model allows the browser to serve as a port for auditing and revocation on abuse, because that is what the capabilities of web extensions require.