6 ms·
Those aren't counterfactuals, they're negative statements. "Why are the lights off?" "Because I didn't turn them on." That's not a counterfactual, it's a fac
by Jtsummers 5y ago
Those aren't counterfactuals, they're negative statements.
"Why are the lights off?"
"Because I didn't turn them on."
That's not a counterfactual, it's a fact. Just like the admins not configuring file purging is a (presumed) fact in the scenario under discussion in the article. Negative statements are not counterfactuals. Now, they may not be helpful for a 5 Whys analysis, but that's a separate thing.
Counterfactual: If the admins had turned on file purging, then the volume would not have been full.
Why? Because they didn't turn it on so this is a counterfactual in that it is dealing with facts not in existence in the reality under examination and reaching a conclusion of how things would have been different with those different facts. But nearly all the causes in a 5 Whys can be seen as counterfactuals if phrased correctly:
"Builds did not complete." Why? "Kubernetes could not start the pod, and the operation timed out after 1 hour."
As a counterfactual: If Kurbernetes could have started the pod, then the operation would not have timed out after 1 hour and the builds would have completed.
- np_tedious 5y agoI think those counterfactuals can be the most useful explanation, while not being the direct cause. "why did the disk fill up" would be most directly explained by the most recent write. That's not useful though. It doesn't really matter what the last write was.
- bb88 5y ago"The disk filled up because the website was trying to save a configuration backup to disk." -> Stop backing up configurations.
- cwp 5y ago"I didn't turn them on" is a fact. It's the "because" that's not a fact. The whole point of the article is that you can't get causality from things that didn't happen. There are seven billion other people in the world who also didn't turn on the lights. What makes your inaction special? In order to get the "because" we have to imagine another state of the world where you DID turn on the lights, and further speculate that this would have been effective to illuminate the room. That's counterfactual, because the fact is that it's dark in here.
- drdeca 5y agoAre you saying that "If I had turned on the lights, they would be on" wouldn't be a true statement? It seems like it would be strange to reject as an answer to "why do blind people tend spend less on lighting?" with "Because they don't tend to use the lighting, because the lighting isn't useful to them, so they don't turn the lights on as much (unless someone else who isn't blind is there).". How else would you answer that question? (modulo little wording changes and such)
- GavinMcG 5y agoIt's tautologically true, in that you used the word "on" in both clauses, and "if on, then on" is always true. But no, in a meaningful sense it's not a true statement about the world. It's a good guess, and for a statement that simple, there might be no need to go further. For a statement about why a volume is full with too many files, the point is that a nice-sounding "if only" isn't something you can test or be certain of. Your answer about blind people is a very good guess as well, and the same one I would make, but it's not data.
- Jtsummers 5y agoI actually meant to present that as: Because I didn't flip the switch. A counterfactual requires posing a situation with changed facts. I stand by my statement, saying "X because not Y" is not a counterfactual on its own. "not Y" is still a (potentially) factual statement. And guesses still aren't counterfactuals. "Maybe the lights aren't on because we didn't flip the switch?" That's a hypothesis, and a testable one. Still not a counterfactual. If we know the flip hasn't been switched, then it's just a fact even if the statement is in the form of not X.
- cwp 5y agoThe counterfactual is "if I had flipped the switch, the lights would be on." That is a situation with changed facts, and therefore counterfactual. The tricky bit is the causality. We have to construct an alternate history, with a counterfactual cause and a counterfactual result. And we can't actually know that. Maybe the bulb is burnt out. Maybe there's a power outage just now. Maybe we've blown a fuse. The causality is just conjecture. Now consider the opposite. The lights are off because the bulb burnt out. That's a lot less ambiguous. If you want to doubt the causality you've got to get all mystical.
- coldtea 5y ago>Those aren't counterfactuals, they're negative statements. Wikipedia doesn't seem to agree with you: "The term "Counterfactual" is defined by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary as contrary to the facts.[2] A counterfactual thought occurs when a person modifies a factual prior event and then assesses the consequences of that change.[3] A person may imagine how an outcome could have turned out differently, if the antecedents that led to that event were different. For example, a person may reflect upon how a car accident could have turned out by imagining how some of the factors could have been different, for example, If only I hadn't been speeding...." The forms the article mentions are like those "if" statements. >That's not a counterfactual, it's a fact. That's because there's a one-way casual relationship there. Not the case with TFA examples.
- boxed 5y agoI read the quoted passage to mean exactly what the previous poster said.
- guerrilla 5y agoI agree with you. This author not only doesn't know the basics but is making an absolute fool of themselves by being ignorant of the robust and very popular (within analytic philosophy) research on counterfatual theories of causation. [1] 1. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation-counterfactual/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation-counterfactual/
- nimithryn 5y agoIn the language of do-calculus, counterfactuals have a very specific meaning. Ferenc gives some great examples here: https://www.inference.vc/causal-inference-3-counterfactuals/ https://www.inference.vc/causal-inference-3-counterfactuals/ The main idea: Let Y be the set {y, not y} and X be the set {x, not x}. y denotes timing out, and x denotes “Kubernetes not starting the pod”. We have some distribution P(Y=y|X=x) (in this case, the probability of “timing out” (y) given “Kubernetes not starting the pod” x. The counter factual distribution is NOT the same as P(Y= not y | X= not x) (the “probability of not timing out given Kubernetes starting the pod”). The counterfactual is P(Y’=not y| X=x, Y=y, X’=not x), or “the probability of not timing out given that it did originally time out when Kubernetes did not start the pod, and given that this time it did start the pod”. This aligns roughly with what you are saying above.
- nimithryn 5y agoI will say that while I think this article doesn’t give a good treatment of counterfactuals - the “I can offer infinite counterfactuals so counterfactuals aren’t useful” argument is a kind of intellectual nihilism I don’t really buy - I think at its core this article is really just arguing that we should pose forward facing solutions when we encounter bugs, rather than explanations. That proposition seems fine to me.
- terrib1e 5y agoRegardless of the semantics, I love how this post has lead to a philosophy 101 debate.