4 ms·
When this hypothesis first came out, I remember looking into it a lot, specifically looking into the rebuttals from Western European researchers that poo-poo'ed
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
When this hypothesis first came out, I remember looking into it a lot, specifically looking into the rebuttals from Western European researchers that poo-poo'ed the Russians' theories. I remember the thing that struck me was how defensive without evidence the rebuttals sounded to me. I mean, the rebuttals kept pointing out how there was all this documentary evidence to show that Jeanne Calment was 122, but of course all of that documentary evidence would still exist if it were actually evidence from her mother. I never found any convincing rebuttals of (a) the sheer outlier-ness of Jeanne's age, nor any of the more suspicious actions like some of the burned documents from her family.
FWIW I think the jury is definitely still out, but I would take the "Jeanne was 2 people" bet 9 ways to Sunday if it could be proven with DNA evidence.
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoThat defensive without evidence thing happens even in physics and mathematics. If they were right, we wouldn't have set theory or elementary particles. Emotions, pride and incentives don't conform to science's venerable image.
- boudin 5y agoThe same way the accusation of fake record do not provide evidence though, it's just theories.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYes. But their probabilistic weight differs. You don't have a conclusive proof either way, but on one side you have an extreme outlier event that puzzles the medical science, and on the other you have a garden variety white-collar crime with obvious motive. I know what I'd bet on.
- lovemenot 5y ago>> you have an extreme outlier event ... It's an outlier sure, but how extreme is unclear. France being a developed nation (say 5 - 10% of global population at the time). Jeanne being upper middle-class (again say 5% of France). How many with the potential to live a much longer life did not do so because they lacked Jeanne's social advantages? Or did actually live long, but were not documented. If we could model these premature deaths and fit them into the curve, how much less extreme would Jeanne appear to be?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoWhat you are proposing is basically exactly what the researchers did in their paper, just comparing the data looking at people who were already supercentenarians, not the whole population at large, and found that Calment was a widely improbable outlier even just among this group.
- gpderetta 5y agoDoubting is ok, but accusing someone of crimes based on outlier data can be very dangerous: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucia_de_Berk#Life_sentence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucia_de_Berk#Life_sentence
- lovemenot 5y agoOverall, I tend to agree with you, but in fairness ... >> I never found any convincing rebuttals of (a) the sheer outlier-ness of Jeanne's age If Jeanne was truly genuine, how could anyone realistically explain such a statistical anomaly, other than by pointing out the documentary evidence?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoDoing a DNA test on the bodies. I'm not saying the new theory is right, I'm saying that, as an uninterested party, my initial reaction was "wow, this is definitely plausible, and certainly could explain some of the more unlikely parts of Calment's case." What struck me was how the Western European researchers immediately went into defensive mode, casting aspersions on the motivations of the Russians, etc., instead of just examining the theory dispassionately.