2 ms·
> Most of the other evidence, in particular her occasional slips mixing up father and husband have no real evidentiary value. Confusing relatives with each othe
by jcranmer 5y ago
> Most of the other evidence, in particular her occasional slips mixing up father and husband have no real evidentiary value. Confusing relatives with each other is something that people with incipient memory failure do literally all the time.
My nephew's name starts with the same letter as my own name, and consequently, only he and I can consistently get the two names straight. It's a bit of an extreme case, but anyone with a decent-sized family can probably attest to the inability to get even their immediate relatives correctly identified 100% of the time correctly, and this is far before anyone starts getting senile.
- perl4ever 5y ago>Confusing relatives with each other is something that people with incipient memory failure do literally all the time An aunt of mine who had dementia near the end of her life was quite lucid in the sense that she could talk about family memories coherently, but she would substitute different people, sometimes of different generations and relationships, for the ones she was talking about. This Jeanne Calment thing reminds me a lot of the theories about why Shakespeare wasn't Shakespeare, and Mark Twain's contribution to the field. https://shakespeareoxfordfellowship.org/is-shakespeare-dead/ https://shakespeareoxfordfellowship.org/is-shakespeare-dead/ He was joking though, satirizing the conspiracy theorist's tone, I'm pretty sure.