3 ms·
> It's a bit like asking people not to use the Gregorian calendar in places that are not predominantly Christian. I think it is different in that numbering yea
by skissane 5y ago
> It's a bit like asking people not to use the Gregorian calendar in places that are not predominantly Christian.
I think it is different in that numbering years is useful, and we need to have an agreed starting point, and by historical accident we've all adopted an estimated (likely slightly incorrect) birth year for the founder of one of the world's major religions. It is hard to pick a culturally-neutral starting point – astronomers sometimes use the Julian period starting at 4713 BCE, but while that is more religiously neutral it still isn't culturally neutral. (It is based partially on astronomy, but also partly on the taxation cycle of the ancient Roman Empire, and that's still Western-centric.)
By contrast, applying names to periods of time is far less useful and far less portable across cultures. The 1800s looked very different in different parts of the world, but it was the same 100 year span everywhere. And we only do this for a handful of historical periods anyway (most seem to be named after British monarchs – Victorian, Georgian, Edwardian, etc). Applying those period names to places outside the British Empire is a bit like applying Japanese era names to European history. The whole thing of historical era names seems to be somewhat dying anyway – references to decades (the 1990s, the 1920s, etc) seems more popular in discussing more recent history – the Elizabethan era was in the 16th and very early 17th century, not in the 20th and early 21st.
> We have to adapt our language to the person we are communicating with, and if they are familiar with the time frame associated with Queen Victoria, I can see how it makes sense to use it. We could refer to the period of Isabella II of Spain, but they wouldn't understand us, so it would be rather pointless.
"mid-to-late 19th century" covers roughly the same timeframe, and everyone knows what that is.
- philwelch 5y agoIt’s still a political decision though. The Romans would elect new consuls each year so instead of numbering their years, they just designated them by whoever were the two consuls that year. Later scholars numbered the years since the supposed founding of Rome. The French Revolutionaries created a calendar where Year 1 was the founding of the First Republic, but it didn’t catch on.
- nescioquid 5y agoWell, the Romans also kept track of the years since the founding of Rome -- ab urbe condita (AUC). Writers in antiquity used the years AUC; that wasn't a modern invention.
- skissane 5y agoIt is true that writers in antiquity used AUC. However, it was only used infrequently – primarily when celebrations were held to mark the city of Rome's anniversary, as part of imperial propaganda, and also in historical writings. In everyday use, naming years by consuls was more common (especially in the West), and by the regnal years of the emperors (especially in the East and in later periods). After the reign of Diocletian, use of his regnal numbers were continued–in part because he introduced a system of having four emperors simultaneously (two senior and two junior). Even though that system only lasted 30 years (at the end of which Constantine became the sole emperor), the use of year numbering from Diocletian's reign stuck in the East – anno Diocletiani, or as Christians came to call it, anno martyrum (since Diocletian started the last major Roman campaign of persecution of Christianity). The Diocletian era was most popular in the East; in the West it was known, but less used. The monk Dionysius Exiguus proposed anno Domini as a replacement for anno Diocletiani. It became the standard in the West, but less so in the East. The Coptic Orthodox Church continues to use the Diocletian era to this day. Greeks (and also, through Greek influence, many Slavs) preferred to number years from the estimated creation date of the world (similar in principle to how contemporary Judaism does it), but using two different estimated dates of creation – hence the Alexandrian era and the Byzantine era. It is only in recent centuries that Greeks and Slavs have standardised on anno Domini. Use of AUC was actually far more popular in the West in the Renaissance than it ever was in antiquity. It helped produce a false impression that it was more significant in Roman history than it ever was.
- philwelch 5y agoI neurotically checked the Wikipedia article on AUC and I got the impression that at least the term "AUC" was mostly a Renaissance invention, so I tried to hedge against that. Apparently classicists would actually add "AUC" to Roman manuscripts as they transcribed them.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> By contrast, applying names to periods of time is far less useful and far less portable across cultures. The 1800s looked very different in different parts of the world, but it was the same 100 year span everywhere. And we only do this for a handful of historical periods anyway (mostly seem to be named after British monarchs – Victorian, Georgian, Edwardian, etc). Applying those period names to places outside the British Empire is a bit like applying Japanese era names to European history. Sure, but a lot more of the world was part of the British Empire during those periods than has ever been part of the Japanese (and there's a lot of second-order uses for cultural/artistic trends that originated in the British world of those times but are found elsewhere, e.g., “Victorian architecture”.)
- skissane 5y ago> and there's a lot of second-order uses for cultural/artistic trends that originated in the British world of those times but are found elsewhere, e.g., “Victorian architecture” I don't think there is an issue with speaking of "Victorian X" where X culturally originated in the British Empire. People talk about "Second Empire style" in the history of US and Canadian architecture, but neither was ever part of the Second French Empire. The problem is when people start talking about "Victorian X" when they aren't talking about the British Empire or its cultural exports, they are talking about things that happened outside it and not under its particular influence or involvement, but merely at the same time.
- Macha 5y agoI wonder if that's because more recent periods are considered in more detail - both for granularity and as a complex period. Whereas the further back you go, the more they get grouped together and simplified into stories. "The 80s" (1 decade) is considered in more detail than "the interwar period" (20ish years), which is considered in more detail than "The victorian era" (70 years) which is considered in more detail than the Renaissance (200 years) which is considered in more detail than "Late antiquity" (500 years). I suspect in 2100, not very many people will be talking about the 1980s in great detail, and if the term 20s is used will refer to the current decade
- wcoenen 5y ago> we need to have an agreed starting point, and by historical accident we've all adopted an estimated (likely slightly incorrect) birth year for the founder of one of the world's major religions. It is hard to pick a culturally-neutral starting point There are some astronomical cycles that could be used as a neutral reference. For example, due to the precession of the Earth's axis, the star which is the North Star changes over a 41000 year period. So we could pick the time when the axis was pointing most closely at the star Vega, 11000 years ago, as the epoch.
- skissane 5y ago> For example, due to the precession of the Earth's axis, the star which is the North Star changes over a 41000 year period. That's a great idea you have there. I like it. I am going to quibble with some of the finer details though: 41,000? I thought the best estimate for the Platonic year, the time for the precession of the equinoxes to complete one revoution, was 25,772 years? The Gregorian calendar has a 400 cycle. If we are sticking with the Gregorian calendar, any new epoch needs to be aligned with the 400 year Gregorian cycle, or else leap year calculations will suddenly get more complicated. So that suggests using something like -23600 CE (23601 BCE) as the starting point. That's 64 Gregorian cycles before 2000 CE, which is the closest possible whole number of Gregorian cycles to 1 Platonic year prior to 2000 CE (a Platonic year is 64.43 Gregorian cycles). The Gregorian cycle is of course based on the AD/CE chronology, modulo 400, so it is still an indirect link to Christianity. But I think it is as practically close to culturally neutral as we could get, without also changing the calendar. (Which isn't really Christian in origin anyway – it was developed in pagan ancient Rome, and the 7 day week is pre-Christian in origin as well, through Judaism, and possibly some ancient Babylonian influence as well – the only Christian to touch it was Pope Gregory XIII, and his aim was only to make its leap year rule more astronomically accurate, albeit he ended up linking it more tightly to the AD/CE year numbering in the process.)
- wcoenen 5y ago> 41,000? I thought the best estimate for the Platonic year, the time for the precession of the equinoxes to complete one revoution, was 25,772 years? Yes, I mixed up the precession cycle with the obliquity cycle.