5 ms·
I wonder how many more orders of magnitude are required to solve self driving… do we need 10 or 100M more vehicles streaming data, or do we need to use 1000x m
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
I wonder how many more orders of magnitude are required to solve self driving…
do we need 10 or 100M more vehicles streaming data, or do we need to use 1000x more transistors daily for the AI annealing? 10,000x the number of parameters?
Maybe things have to be a billion times better before we get real FSD?
- lowdose 5y agoRecord driving behavior off all cars coupled with their number plates and let the AI decide what to do next.
- nathanaldensr 5y ago"the AI." You know this doesn't exist, right?
- dylan604 5y agoI think there's a whole lot of people that would be upset to find out you don't think they exist. I mean, come on, people have a hard enough time with eternal questions like "who am I?" and you come along and tell them they don't exist? I now understand why Marvin the robot was in the mood he was. Why bother?
- andyxor 5y agoWhat's needed is qualitative not quantitative change, AI needs a fundamental breakthrough to mimic natural cognition to some minimal degree, but it's all pseudo-science at this point unfortunately. The current deep learning approach is a dead end.
- ska 5y ago> Maybe things have to be a billion times better before we get real FSD? One problem with this kind of estimation is that it's not actually clear that we can get there from "here" using current approaches. If it turn we can't, estimation is pretty hopeless if history tells us anything about putting a timeline on breakthroughs...
- jowday 5y agoThe “fleet learning” pipeline Elon described at Autonomy Day doesn’t actually exist in practice. They have some hardcoded heuristic triggers that capture snippets of data to be annotated by human labelers to train perception models off of. The bottleneck is labeling/engineering. Autonomous vehicles by and large aren’t a data problem anyways - it’s a robotics problem conditioned on the output of ML models for perception and prediction. The majority of the work is just implementing all of the bizarre edge cases inside of the robotics stack. The idea of tackling this with an e2e ML model is a pipe dream touted by people that aren’t familiar with the space or trying to hype up their approach. Whenever this approach is attempted teams will very quickly realize how untenable it is and return to implementing individual robotics modules. tl;dr there’s nothing special about Tesla’s approach to AVs or machine learning and you shouldn’t expect them to leapfrog the competition because of some nebulous ML-based advantage. Coming from someone who has seen the interiors of both the FSD beta and the stack at an actual AV company.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y ago>The idea of tackling this with an e2e ML model is a pipe dream touted by people that aren’t familiar with the space or trying to hype up their approach. Whenever this approach is attempted teams will very quickly realize how untenable it is and return to implementing individual robotics modules. Except Andrej Karpathy. Why dumb down if they know it isn't working, now that they have all the financial resources to pivot and overtake the other manufacturers (who have not achieve anything anyway)? It makes no sense, unless Karpathy does not know what he's doing. Edit: the argument that others don't agree is not convincing because Tesla should not have succeeded by others' standards either.
- jowday 5y agoThey’re not tackling it with an end to end model - all of the ML at Tesla is used for perception (and some prediction - I think there’s a cut-in prediction head running), which then feeds into traditional robotics algorithms, like I described in the parent comment. If you listen to any of AK’s talks he only really talks about perception and he’s basically said that right now none of their planning is based on ML models. This is backed up by what reverse engineers have found in their Tesla’s.
- paxys 5y agoWhile I can't say what will happen in the future, on the current course we are on self driving is simply not getting solved. Driver assist will keep improving, sure, and it may be the case that most miles driven are automated, but there will still need to be a steering wheel and trained drivers.