3 ms·
What if that person's “decision” was being tricked by a scammer? Or being in an abusive relationship? Or living in a surveillance state? I want people to have
by acdha 5y ago
What if that person's “decision” was being tricked by a scammer? Or being in an abusive relationship? Or living in a surveillance state?
I want people to have more control over devices but there are some non-trivial threats which millions of people face which are currently defanged by things like the OS not allowing malware installs, or hiding the use of various sensors or data access, etc.
- Ajedi32 5y agoSo people might make bad decisions, therefore they should not be allowed to make decisions at all? Sure, do everything you can to educate the user on what they're doing and make things as hard as possible for scammers, but ultimately it must be their choice who controls their device, not yours.
- acdha 5y agoWe don't have absolute freedom in many areas because the law recognizes that the general public either is not capable of making informed decisions when that requires high-levels of skill or when there is a high likelihood of bad outcomes due to malicious actors. For example, if you buy a car there are safety features you cannot turn off without major modifications. Dangerous tools often have safety guards built-in to the design — for example, my blender doesn't say it's my choice whether to keep the spinning blade covered. My bank doesn't say it's my choice whether or not to identify myself when making a withdrawal. For most people, iOS limiting the damage when they get compromised is a huge plus. Removing that entirely in the absolute position is bringing people back a couple of decades ago only now the malware will have access to their most private moments and data 24x7 rather than just their Geocities browsing history. Now, consider what that means for something like unlocking the bootloader. Allowing that means undetectable malware, potentially irrecoverable. There's not really a good way around that and even if you try to inform people at the time they enable it that doesn't help if it's done when the device is out of their control (abusive partner, boss, police, etc.), and every on-screen indicator can be faked by the malware vendor. That leaves options like a physical switch in a prominent location which most people aren't going to want to pay for or see, and are more likely to be used by accident than intentionally.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> For example, if you buy a car there are safety features you cannot turn off without major modifications. To use a direct analogy with Apple's restrictions on users, you're free to modify and flash your car's ECU firmware. In fact, it's quite common.
- dev_tty01 5y ago>In fact, it's quite common. Really? How have you defined common? Where is that data from? I can't imagine anything more than a tiny fraction of car owners are doing this. Most people are not hacking their cars, building Raspberry Pi controllers for their toilets, or have any desire whatsoever to side load an app on their iPhone. The HN community is not representative of the overall population.
- Nextgrid 5y agoIt's common enough that there's a legitimate industry around that and a lot of auto-tuning shops will do it on request. In most cases though it's just editing the built-in data tables rather than completely replacing the firmware, and it's often done for engine performance reasons rather than bypassing safety features.
- eecc 5y agoAnd possibly blowing the cars’ mileage and emissions limits which were defined by regulation and would make the car illegal to drive if measured…
- heavyset_go 5y agoMechanics do it often, as do people who work on their cars. It isn't the Hacker News segment that is doing it, but the people who work on cars for a living or for fun.
- mason55 5y agoAnd you’re free to jailbreak your phone. It’s not illegal. No ones going to arrest you. But no one says the car manufacturers are required to make a car where you can flash the ECU. There’s just no reason for them to block it. If someone came up with a way to steal your car by tricking your into running an app that flashed your ECU then you can bet Ford would disable it pretty quickly.
- mehlmao 5y agoIf you live in a surveillance state, Apple is happy to hand over the keys (so long as the market is big enough).