4 ms·
That's the hard part for all of this: if you are building an unlock mechanism the first question you need to ask is how you build a UI which clearly communicate
by acdha 5y ago
That's the hard part for all of this: if you are building an unlock mechanism the first question you need to ask is how you build a UI which clearly communicates to a user that they are likely giving control of all of their data, location/camera/microphone, etc. to whatever they're installing.
The scammers who push malware under the guise of tech support, free porn/games, etc. are effective enough to compromise millions of people and that's before you get to the question of what it'd look like if a government started pushing access for monitoring. How many people might consider installing something which this guy they met in a coffeeshop says will protect their messages from government surveillance? Now consider how many people might have malware installed by an abusive domestic partner, and where control of the device would extend to hiding the existence of spyware.
This is not to say that Apple is acting without self-interest here, only that I think there's really a pretty nasty market failure making it quite difficult to reconcile someone being able to make choices about their device with a fairly high risk of compromise with potentially significant consequences.
- cmg 5y ago> if you are building an unlock mechanism the first question you need to ask is how you build a UI which clearly communicates to a user that they are likely giving control of all of their data, location/camera/microphone, etc. to whatever they're installing. Facebook puts a large "Stop!" warning in the browser console when you try to open developer tools with a link to https://www.facebook.com/selfxss https://www.facebook.com/selfxss. I'd be really curious to see if that's helped to stop such attacks on their side. Full text: "This is a browser feature intended for developers. If someone told you to copy-paste something here to enable a Facebook feature or "hack" someone's account, it is a scam and will give them access to your Facebook account."
- acdha 5y agoThat’s an interesting question: I’d love to know how effective that’s been.
- snowwrestler 5y agoFacebook themselves convinced teenagers to side-load an iOS app that used Facebook’s enterprise cert to circumvent Apple’s privacy protections. They got caught and Apple revoked the cert, which broke all their internal iOS apps. If Facebook is willing to fool kids into giving up their privacy via side-loading, you can imagine why Apple is nervous about how things would go if anyone could easily do so.
- alisonkisk 5y agoApple lets Facebook run on iOS.
- eecc 5y agoIn a sandbox, and gradually stripping it of its privacy-invading features, while alerting users of the amount of tracking information it collects.
- pnexk 5y agoDiscord does the same when you open the electron inspect element panel with F12. Wonder how much that's helped as well
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe solution is to not make people have to root their device for that to begin with. Allow people to install apps within the sandbox with minimal static scanning and perhaps a DB of hashes for security notifications later, and let that be it. You'll crush the market for easily accessible Jb tools too
- acdha 5y agoI think that’s the right direction, too. It doesn’t help the people who have an ideological position that they should be able to do anything with the device but it seems more practical.
- fuckyouriotshit 5y ago> ideological position that they should be able to do anything with the device While there are people who make this argument purely on ideological grounds (similar to arguments you hear about individual freedoms vs collective rights), it's essential to recognize that _completely_ removing the ability of independent developers to write and run software if the manufacturer has decided they don't like that developer will slowly destroy the competition, creativity and freedom that created most of the technologies that are used today. It's reasonable to make the argument that the manufacturer needs to secure the devices that they sell, even for users with low technical literacy. Advocating for the manufacturers to be given total control over everything that every user can do with their device won't guarantee increased security, but it certainly would result in manufacturers being able to disable any software they chose to, regardless of legitimacy, without reason or recourse. That's a prospect that is (IMO) far more terrifying than what it could prevent (some users falling for certain types of phishing attacks that install spyware).
- realusername 5y ago> It's reasonable to make the argument that the manufacturer needs to secure the devices that they sell, even for users with low technical literacy. We've been in this argument before and the most secure platform today is still the web, an open platform where the code is designed to run on demand. There's a reason everybody asks to install their native app, there's much more data to gather there than in the web.
- deeblering4 5y ago> That's the hard part for all of this: if you are building an unlock mechanism the first question you need to ask is how you build a UI which clearly communicates to a user that they are likely giving control of all of their data, location/camera/microphone, etc. to whatever they're installing. Nah, thats a win2k era cop-out. The hard part is balancing secure by default and granting privs only when absolutely necessary (and authenticated)
- acdha 5y agoIt’s recognizing that giving up control of the trusted base means giving up control of the device. If that option is available, people will be tricked or coerced into using it, or it will be done without their knowledge – as evidenced by all of that being done not uncommonly on desktops. I think a better angle is pushing for relaxing software distribution: keep the trust chain but let people run apps in the normal sandbox even if those haven’t gone through the current process. Exploits are still possible, of course, but the normal controls allowing user awareness of the device’s status would be intact.