8 ms·
In the Strange Land of Robert Heinlein (1984)
- Uhhrrr 5y agoNice line: "You take a man who has to take his shoes off to do arithmetic, and he's not going to be too happy with ballistics and spaceships."
- pmoriarty 5y ago"...many of his opinions may seem like Cold War relics in the present age. As for the Soviets, "I can't understand those who think there's any good in signing treaties with people who have cheated for 40 years." And he believes the Communist Party probably has infiltrated, or at least influenced, campuses, churches and environmental groups; assumes that there are Russian "sleeper" agents soon to awaken; and regards incidents like Three Mile Island as suspicious "pseudo-emergencies." The growing frequency of such "public panics" may serve to keep Americans distraught and confused: "It is possible that the disinformation boys are doing their jobs." And Ginny, a talk-radio fan, says she has "recognized certain terms that are either clearly communist" or the product of callers who are "very well indoctrinated." Sounds like Heinlein would have felt at home as a Trump supporter or member of the alt-right.
- jaten 5y agoIndeed. Although he would have abhorred their anti-science tactics. And he wrote extensively about the dangers of religious idiocy.
- dragonwriter 5y agoWhile Heinlein was no friend of the contemporary Left, he was very much not of a type with the modern pro-Trump types.
- pyuser583 5y agoHeineken was very much a product of the 1950s: pro-science, pro-military, pro-patriotism, socially conservative (but open to change). He’s very much a produce a very different time, and that’s what makes him so interestin.
- bawolff 5y agoStranger in a strange land is socially conservative?? (and i don't just mean the pro-poly parts - that book was generally very influential to the hippie movement) Like there's a lot i disagree with about the views expressed in his novels, but social conservatism is not something i would accuse him of.
- pyuser583 5y agoI haven’t got around to Stranger in a Strange Land - which is weird because that’s his most populist book. I’m thinking of The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. It had group marriages, but the marriage practices were ordained by custom and tradition. Not 20th century custom and tradition, but custom and tradition none the less.
- bawolff 5y agoI think the moon is a harsh mistress is also the one that has the scene where the female lead wants to help on the farm, but her boobs are too "distracting" to the men folk, so she goes back to the kitchen instead. (Its been a while, i might be misrepresenting it) Which stood out to me as first and foremost being shockingly mysogynistic, but also i guess is pretty strongly pro traditional gender roles. At the same time though, the female lead is a political agitator/rebel, which is quite far removed from what i would consider traditional gender roles. In any case though, i think when people talk about someone being socially conservative, they mean more in the context of contemporary practise. Like moon is harsh mistress may have practises deemed "traditional" in universe to the characters, but as a work, its setup as a commentary on contemporary norms, so its still arguing for change as a work, even if its not doing so explicitly in the text by the characters.
- seniorivn 5y agohow does it feel to live in a one dimensional world?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alentist 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venona_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venona_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Marxism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Marxism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_march_through_the_institutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_march_through_the_institu... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_studies
- GavinMcG 5y agoYou seem to be trying to say something, but you left out whatever you're trying to say.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- imwillofficial 5y agoWow, He was right. I wonder what other things He was right about?
- mr_toad 5y agoIf you read The Moon is a Harsh Mistress his views come across as more libertarian and individualist than conservative. Ditto for Job. I never saw much in the way of social conservatism in his writing (the religious right would probably be horrified by some of his work), but he was clearly opposed to collectivism.
- GeekyBear 5y ago>the religious right would probably be horrified by some of his work You can drop the probably. Stranger in a Strange Land explicitly points out things like the Christian ritual of communion being ritualized cannibalism, for example.
- neartheplain 5y agoHeinlein wrote a book in favor of polyamory ("Stranger in a Strange Land") and was strongly opposed to religion and theology [0]. I doubt he'd be at home with today's evangelical Christians. For what it's worth, Soviet intelligence did infiltrate large parts of American society during the Cold War [1]. This historical fact is often obscured by accounts of McCarthyism and the Red Scare. While McCarthy was a liar and an alcoholic with little to no knowledge of actual Soviet spy networks, the networks did in fact exist. [0] https://www.azquotes.com/author/6509-Robert_A_Heinlein/tag/religion https://www.azquotes.com/author/6509-Robert_A_Heinlein/tag/r... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_espionage_in_the_United_States#Browder_and_Golos_networks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_espionage_in_the_United...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- flyingfences 5y ago> Heinlein wrote a book in favor of polyamory ("Stranger in a Strange Land") See also: The Moon is a Harsh Mistress
- dragonwriter 5y agoAlso Friday. And Time Enough For Love.
- bawolff 5y agoOr like most of his later (non-children) books. Dude was really into poly stuff. Although honestly when reading his books, they never really seemed like equal partnerships. That said, i've only read a few of his more famous novels.
- grogenaut 5y agoRead "To sail beyond the sunset" (iirc) Poly AND Incest mixed with infinite lifetimes, there were some things going on in that book...
- beebmam 5y ago'Others have damned him... for inventing female characters fated only for appalling subservience and motherhood. Says the accused chauvinist: "Even that can't be substantiated statistically. I don't know what they want me to do with the females. Do they want 'em not to have babies? I don't think there's much future in a gal who's thoroughly opposed to having babies. And the men in my stories are also thoroughly in favor of it."' I understand Heinlein is a culturally important figure in Science Fiction, but he should not be one of our heroes.
- loki49152 5y agoOk, then. Where do you think babies come from?
- pavlov 5y agoHeinlein on slavery: “Nor do I feel responsible for the generally low state of the Negro — as one Negro friend pointed out to me; the lucky Negroes were the ones who were enslaved. Having traveled quite a bit in Africa, I know what she means. One thing is clear: Whether one speaks of technology or social institutions, ‘civilization’ was invented by us, not by the Negroes. As races, as cultures, we are five thousand years, about, ahead of them. Except for the culture, both institutions and technology, that they got from us, they would still be in the stone age, along with its slavery, cannibalism, tyranny, and utter lack of the concept we call ‘justice.’” More in the same vein here: https://worldsf.wordpress.com/2012/09/07/heinlein-and-racism/amp/ https://worldsf.wordpress.com/2012/09/07/heinlein-and-racism... Includes such evergreen classics as “neurological differences”, “white people are the ones actually discriminated against”, etc.
- ctoth 5y agoI Highly recommend the book The Pleasant Profession of Robert A. Heinlein to understand him in context of his time. Here's a pretty good review[0]. Quoting from the review: When it comes to more difficult issues, Mendlesohn neatly avoids the simplifications that frequently appear on both sides: “With Heinlein it’s always a case of being a little bit more complicated than it initially seems.” Mendlesohn compares his vocal opposition to bigotry with the limitations of his nonwhite characters – whose racial identities are often reduced to “Easter eggs” in the text – and his lack of sensitivity toward institutional oppression: “Heinlein understands and opposes enslavement and colour prejudice, but he does not really see that racism has a wider infrastructure. He does not understand what we now frame as systemic racism.” Elsewhere, Mendlesohn points out that Heinlein’s most famous aphorism on guns – “An armed society is a polite society” – falls apart in context, while their discussion of Heinlein’s “intensely personal” fascination with gender may inspire many readers to see his portrayal of women in a new light. Writing of his “yearning to get a real feeling for what women think, feel and want,” Mendlesohn concludes: “Heinlein made a conscious effort to think about what women were like, and how they thought about themselves. He tried to create for them a voice that was embodied and aware of being female in a male world. In these stories he also tried to make an argument about the possibilities for shifting that sense of self.” This willingness to view a writer through the lens of the critic’s own time is just what we ought to expect from a serious evaluation of a figure in the main line of American literature, which is precisely how Heinlein is regarded by his fans. The Pleasant Profession of Robert A. Heinlein pays him the compliment of holding him to his own high standards. [0]: https://locusmag.com/2019/05/alec-nevala-lee-reviews-the-pleasant-profession-of-robert-a-heinlein-by-farah-mendlesohn/ https://locusmag.com/2019/05/alec-nevala-lee-reviews-the-ple...
- bawolff 5y agoThe typical Heinlein heroine might seem a bit, i don't even know- let's go with, uncomfortable by modern standards, but i could see how it could be considered a step up from some of the zero-dimensional female characters in older science fiction.
- TMWNN 5y agoThanks for the profile; it's one I hadn't read before. I thought the wording of the discussion of Heinlein's previous marriage was hinting at his actual first marriage, which no one knew about until after long after his death, but it doesn't. I grew up reading Heinlein. I've read it all; the short stories, the juveniles, the late-period novels, the early and late nonfiction essays, the recently published "lost" works. I consider him and Asimov among my formative influences. I disagree with the critics the article cites about the quality of his post-surgery work; Friday is fantastic and Job, the book the profile is putatively about, is also great. They're just different from the Scribner's juveniles. In turn I like the juveniles, but they don't stick with me as much as his short stories, or his late novels like Friday (which did cyberpunk two years earlier and better than Neuromancer did), Job, or (as weird as they are) The Cat Who Walks Through Walls/To Sail Beyond the Sunset. I very much think, however, that Stranger in a Strange Land can only be read with vicarious embarrassment.