2 ms·
No, it depends on the intent. If the intent is to prevent the transmission of ideas, then yes it's censorship. If the intent is to protect from harm -- totall
by crazygringo 5y ago
No, it depends on the intent.
If the intent is to prevent the transmission of ideas, then yes it's censorship.
If the intent is to protect from harm -- totally unconnected to ideas -- then no it's not censorship.
The reason Defender deletes keygens is that they're statistically associated with malware and viruses, as any Google search will terrifyingly immediately reveal. It clearly is falling under the "protect from harm" category as it's designed to do.
But so to answer your question clearly: deleting "Animal Farm.txt" because of the ideas inside is censorship (prevents it being transmitted). The video game would similarly be censorship if based on its content. But if it's deleting all keygens, regardless of content of their associated video games, then clearly not censorship.
- jacobr1 5y agoIsn't the stated intent of most censorship to protect from harm?
- crazygringo 5y agoI think the distinction is pretty clear. But if it needs to be clearer: in censorship the harm is in the ideas themselves, the perspectives they spread. In prohibitions that are non-censorship, it doesn't have anything to do with ideas. You aren't locking your door to prevent the idea of burglars entering your house.
- apostacy 5y agoBut nearly every instance of censorship is framed as non-political and purely to protect people from harm.
- httpsterio 5y agoStated intent maybe yes, but that's only optics. Censorship is just meant to preserve the powers in control, be they good or bad.