2 ms·
>You must be able to realise that it is not exactly presented in such manner as to be "unknown". Unknown would simply mean windows doesn't know about it and its
by gruez 5y ago
>You must be able to realise that it is not exactly presented in such manner as to be "unknown". Unknown would simply mean windows doesn't know about it and its upto user's discretion. Microsoft, by virtue of all the telemetry, happen to know that this application is uncommon. Why not say that? Why not let the user decide whether they want to run an uncommon app?
But seems pretty close to what they're doing? I don't feel like downloading random shady programs to get the UI to show up, so I'll base my analysis off the screenshots from this page: http://www.rawinfopages.com/tips/2014/10/unblock-programs-blocked-by-windows-smartscreen/ http://www.rawinfopages.com/tips/2014/10/unblock-programs-bl...
1. the prompt says the app is "unrecognized"
2. the prompt says running the app "might put your PC at risk". I'm presuming that's what you meant by "dangerous", but that's not exactly the same thing.
3. The default option is indeed "don't run", and you do have to click on the non-obvious "more info" link for the "run" to show up, but this seems like a reasonable trade-off. Otherwise users might instinctive click "run" and ignore the warning.
>This, along with Microsoft's position ends up being (in my humble opinion) an abuse of powerful position. And that, again, in my own humble opinion is unacceptable in being defended.
In other words, "I'm so confident that I'm correct and microsoft is so powerful that I think it's unacceptable for people to present arguments to the contrary?