3 ms·
I'm fairly sure this is the exact strategy used by basically everyone, yet everyone in this thread seems to think this is some new innovation and those damn hip
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I'm fairly sure this is the exact strategy used by basically everyone, yet everyone in this thread seems to think this is some new innovation and those damn hippies are finally doing something sensible.
Obama's Clean Power plan for example, just says "we want you to come up with a plan to reduce Carbon, do whatever is easiest for you".
Paris agreement, basically the same.
Carbon prices, fees, taxes or caps? Same thing.
Possibly this is even less sensible than those approaches as it seems to be talking about "powerplants" which naturally biases against large, efficient plants.
If you had 10 small but inefficient coal plants it may make sense to shut them all and use one highly efficient plant.
I believe the coal plants in China are generally of the super-critical variety and so much better in terms of carbon per MWh than your average American plant.
In fact the more I think of it the more this stat seems custom designed to make China the bad guy for some reason.
The focus on moving to gas and carbon capture in the abstract is also ringing alarm bells for me.
Yep, I assumed they couldn't be so stupid because they were being vague about it but they specifically target powerplants rather than carbon intensity:
> Figure 1 displays the locations of the world’s operative fossil-fueled power plants, their
primary fuels, and the tons of carbon dioxide they released in 2018. Some past studies have
defined super polluting power plants using intensity metrics (pollutants per unit of output or
capacity) (e.g., Tong et al. 2018a).
Further, their explanation of why they do this makes absolutely no sense:
> Although this provides a straightforward way to compare the
performance of operators of different sizes, we focus instead on total emissions because to
contain global warming there must be severe cuts in emission levels
So to be clear they have applied machine learning to someone else's database of powerplants and instead of recommending to close the ones that pollute most per KWh, that are nearing the end of their life, that would need expensive upgrades, that can easily be replaced by renewables, the ones that the local population don't like, the most expensive to run or any other sensible approach for getting the most bang per buck, they have concluded _Close the ones that are biggest and are run the most as they produce more carbon than old inefficient plants that only run occasionally_
I don't know if it possible to be that stupid without malicious intent, even by the standards of sociologists funded by the US Government.
They seem to make some attempt to argue that it's easier to demonize a single big plant as a "bad guy", but surely that's a bad idea even if it actually worked in principle?
- shakezula 5y agoThere's simply no way we'll make a meaningful dent in GHG levels without targeting the top 1% of producers like this type of analysis suggests doing. > I believe the coal plants in China are generally of the super-critical variety and so much better in terms of carbon per MWh than your average American plant. Doesn't matter how efficient those Chinese plants are if they're still dumping out CO2 while we're actively trying to sequester it. > They seem to make some attempt to argue that it's easier to demonize a single big plant as a "bad guy", but surely that's a bad idea even if it actually worked in principle? If it works but it's stupid, it's not stupid.