4 ms·
> after everybody is seeing what Germany is doing to Tesla's Gigafactory there Requiring it to follow the rules? As a portion of GDP, manufacturing is a bigger
by rsynnott 5y ago
> after everybody is seeing what Germany is doing to Tesla's Gigafactory there
Requiring it to follow the rules? As a portion of GDP, manufacturing is a bigger part of Germany's economy than nearly any other developed country. It is even higher as a portion of GDP than _China_ (edit not China, see below). Pretty much everyone except Tesla seems to cope, so I'm inclined to assume that this is more a Tesla incompetence problem than a Germany problem.
> There is also far less likelihood of exports being restricted during a possible future crisis by the political whims of failed politicians
"What is Brexit?"
- nbevans 5y agoDial down your tone - it is unwarranted. Rules and red tape was exactly my point. Why would TSMC choose to run that gauntlet willingly and potentially fall foul of the same hurdles that Tesla has encountered? One of the big problems Tesla had was around water supply. Do you have any idea how much water a chip fab uses? My point around export restrictions was in reference to the EU blocking vaccine exports this year because it suited them. There would be heavy incentives for them to do the same for semiconductors in a future supply crisis like there is right now.
- fundatus 5y ago> My point around export restrictions was in reference to the EU blocking vaccine exports this year because it suited them. LMAO The EU blocks ONE vaccine shipment - while the UK and the US had export bans in place for months and now the EU is the bad guy. smh
- detritus 5y agoThe UK did NOT have vaccine export bans in place. Why is this a recurring meme on HN? Or, more pointedly - why are some people so eager to gleefully regurgitate such misinformation?
- fundatus 5y agoIt's not misinformation at all. The UK was just clever enough to hide the export ban in their contracts with AZ (unlike the US which did it more bluntly). The first xx million doses of vaccines manufactured in Oxford/Keele had to be supplied to the UK. Which is an export ban in all but name. But it gave the UK government the opportunity to claim that there was no export ban in place (even though nothing was exported for months).
- detritus 5y agoPlease provide a source for this, then. ed- One thing is organising contracts in a certain way another thing entirely is setting in place an export ban - which, you may recall, is exactly what the EU DID threaten to do when the Dutch-run AZ plants failed to produce what they planned to do, despite the UK funding it to the tune of something like £54M to get production going, which the Dutch government outright refused to do. Again, because this crops up a lot - I am in no way a flag-waving brexiteer - but i am thoroughly fed up with the shit-eating grinning from people with axes to grind. The UK has a lot to feel ashamed for over recent years, but this is not one of them.
- fundatus 5y ago@detritus To quote Matt Hancock directly: "I wasn't going to settle for a contract that allowed the Oxford vaccine to be delivered to others around the world before us. I was insisting we could keep all of the British public safe as my primary responsibility as the Health Secretary."
- rsynnott 5y ago> One of the big problems Tesla had was around water supply. Sure, but this was a completely predictable problem, and one that should have been assessed before they decided on a site. I would assume that TSMC would do the research before deciding on a site. It feels like another manifestation of Tesla's reluctance to ask outside experts, tbh. Other chip manufacturers seem to manage in European countries which are fussy about water; notably, GlobalFoundries in Germany and Intel in Ireland both have large facilities. > My point around export restrictions was in reference to the EU blocking vaccine exports this year because it suited them. This should actually probably be viewed as a positive. There was a big fuss about the EU blocking, I believe, two or three shipments precisely because it had not previously blocked any; at the time this became an issue the EU and India were the only large producers with no controls on export of finished product (strictly speaking the UK didn't have controls in the conventional sense, but its contracts with its only manufacturer effectively didn't allow export). Both ultimately introduced controls, though in Europe's case they were very limited. If you've had a Pfizer/Biontec vaccine and you live outside the US, it was almost certainly made in the EU unless you had it in the last month or so (the US has started allowing exports). For all the fuss about that incident, Europe was _less_ inclined to control export than the other large economies.
- tpush 5y ago> As a portion of GDP, manufacturing is a bigger part of Germany's economy than nearly any other developed country. It is even higher as a portion of GDP than _China_. What are your sources? That doesn't seem to be true according to both [0] and [1]. Both put Germany at 18-19 and China at ~26. [0] https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/Share_of_manufacturing/ https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/Share_of_manufactu... [1] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.IND.MANF.ZS?most_recent_value_desc=true https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.IND.MANF.ZS?most_rec...
- rsynnott 5y agoOops, yep, you're correct. China is higher. I was thinking of broader industry figures, which also include construction and a few other bits and pieces.