3 ms·
I'm anti-car (cars as a regular transit method, parking lots, urban sprawl, burning up hydrocarbons, etc), but I love my car. I love working on it, I love drivi
by noduerme 5y ago
I'm anti-car (cars as a regular transit method, parking lots, urban sprawl, burning up hydrocarbons, etc), but I love my car. I love working on it, I love driving it, I love the fact that I can go anywhere with it at any time without consulting a bus or train schedule.
I'm anti-smoking. I'd tell anyone not to smoke. But I love cigarettes.
I'm in favor of gun control. But I own guns.
See where I'm going with this?
I'm happy to have a conversation with anyone about the better alternative ways to live, but about 99% of the responses in this thread rub me the wrong way because they're sanctimonious, pompous and aggrieved, and want to explain the right and wrong way to live from the perspective of a child.
One major thing they fail to take into account is that people have grown accustomed to certain freedoms (like not asking permission to go somewhere, or waiting for a bus), and a naive attempt to start solving the world's problems by curtailing other people's freedoms is a non-starter.
Ultimately, you can convince people why these things are bad for society and why there are better alternatives (or why they should be given up completely), but there are major reasons why society adopted these things in the first place and when you come at it from the angle of "you're wrong, you're terrible and you suck and you need to quit smoking / stop working on your car / give your guns to the government", you're going to hit a huge amount of resistance compared with trying to make incremental changes and presenting a case for better lifestyle alternatives.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jeromenerf 5y agoPeople have difficulties to accept change when innovations go from liberating to considered harmful in a decade. Cars, smartphones … What feels weird is the « reaction »: as environmental concerns progress, cars (and smartphones) are still being manufactured and marketed as more powerful, faster, shinier, brighter, … production costs are still dwarfing the energy saved by new models efficiency, by a lot. I like driving my roadster car. It has a rather humble 1.8l engine, I bought it second hand and I don’t commute with it.
- noduerme 5y agoThis is true. I was always anti-smart phone and anti-social media. As well as being anti buying anything unnecessary. My car is 40 years old. But now my modest positions seem at odds with the holier than thou PC police, who indulge in all of the above and yet somehow feel morally superior enough to 'splain to me why no one should drive a car. This all goes back to not approaching people by telling them what you're against, because it makes even the most righteous person come off as a hypocrite.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYou sound quite upset about these hypothetical people, but it's not clear to me why? Are you angry that they are buying and driving wasteful, inefficient cars and causing pollution and global warming, because that sounds like it would make you the PC police, no? Or are you angry that they correctly and factually think that cars/social media/whatever have negative impacts? You actually seem to agree that they do, which again would seem to place you in the ranks of the PC Police. Are you angry that they do both of these things at the same time? I'm not quite sure how you're measuring this, but again, you seem to be in this same general category, thinking we should spend less money on flashy cars but also owning an old car, so you're not a RMS level refusnik when it comes to cars, you could probably be 'holier' than 80% of the US population on that topic but you're not at the absolute extreme. Are you arguing that you're like 80% of this opinion, and feel it's okay to be say 50-90% of the way along this spectrum but people that are more than 90% along really, really annoy you? More so than people at the opposite side of the 50% mark? I understand that people can be annoying, but it feels logical to separate out annoyance and correctness. But even if you don't, it feels like you are biased towards the status quo in terms of what you find annoying acts even if you yourself are mostly on the right side of the issue. Possibly humans just don't like being reminded that they can do better, as it makes them feel bad about themselves. We should probably reframe it to areas where we can most easily improve at low cost.
- noduerme 5y agoYour last statement, I believe, is the point of the article. > Possibly humans just don't like being reminded that they can do better Humans don't like other humans who go around acting like they're better because they're doing Y and you're doing X.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> One major thing they fail to take into account is that people have grown accustomed to certain freedoms (like not asking permission to go somewhere, or waiting for a bus), and a naive attempt to start solving the world's problems by curtailing other people's freedoms is a non-starter. It's easy, people want flexibility, shorter and more comfortable commute. If you offer that, they'll ditch their cars. I'm not certain bureaucrats can innovate to make it a reality, so instead you'll get endless committee on transportation and ever ballooning pension funds.
- noduerme 5y agoSmarter public transit would be wonderful. When I lived in Europe, I never owned a car. In the US I live in a small city with unusually good public transit that is not representative of the normal American sprawl. I only use my car when I want to get to a far away beach on a Sunday, or go visit friends outside of town. If you present people with options you will certainly find a majority of people who would love to stop making car payments, paying for gas and insurance. So long as the alternative isn't an enormous hardship that outweighs those costs, which unfortunately it is right now in most American cities that were designed for automobiles.