5 ms·
> Cheap and meaningless rhetorical techniques are best exposed by substituting in other terms. You're just making a list of things without any redeeming charac
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Cheap and meaningless rhetorical techniques are best exposed by substituting in other terms.
You're just making a list of things without any redeeming characteristics. Nobody is pro-HIV. Lots of people are pro-car.
But more importantly, it's missing the point.
If you try to eliminate cars and replace them with nothing, or replace them with something worse, everybody is going to fight you because you're making their lives worse.
If it's 20 miles from your house to your office and there exists no mass transit within walking distance of either one, expecting people to stop driving is a joke. You have to build a viable alternative before you can get rid of cars.
And it has to be better than cars or everybody is going to hate it. But if it is better than cars then you don't need to be anti-car, all you need to do is build a better alternative which people will then choose voluntarily because it's actually better.
Example: Build more housing near where people work, so they live within walking distance and don't need to commute in a car. It's not anti-car. It's just better, for everybody, than needing a car.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've ... shifted my views a bit over the past hour or so (see follow-up comments). I still stand by some of my critiques, though Doreen's points on messaging over a strongly-held, identity-defining product relationship are well-taken.