2 ms·
> For example: while you may see advocacy for protected lanes or traffic calming, almost no one is arguing that cars should be removed from the roads. But thos
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> For example: while you may see advocacy for protected lanes or traffic calming, almost no one is arguing that cars should be removed from the roads.
But those things are anti-car. They come at the cost of travel speed or congestion as a result of fewer lanes. They're thereby something you have to fight the masses in order to get, instead of finding a Pareto-optimal solution that can thereby actually be implemented.
Or at least figure out who it is you want to fight. For example, a lot of towns have a main drag that goes through the area with all the shops. One of the best ways to make that street more accessible to pedestrians is to build a limited access highway parallel to it to carry all the vehicle traffic which is only passing through.
The shop owners are going to fight you on that. They want those cars driving past their shops. But it puts the pedestrians and the drivers on the same side, because the drivers don't want to be stuck on a road full of crosswalks and stoplights when they could be driving around it at 70 MPH.
- Someone 5y ago“congestion as a result of fewer lanes” Removing a car lane for a bicycle lane doesn’t decrease the number of lanes (may even increase it if a car lane is replaced by two bicycle lanes). If the bicycle lane gets used by former car drivers, car density may even go down, and congestion with it (but that likely will induce demand) “The shop owners are going to fight you on that. They want those cars driving past their shops” I don’t think they get paid for ad impressions. Shop owners want people to enter their shop and buy things, not drive past it.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Removing a car lane for a bicycle lane doesn’t decrease the number of lanes (may even increase it if a car lane is replaced by two bicycle lanes). It reduces the number of lanes for cars which increases congestion for drivers. > If the bicycle lane gets used by former car drivers, car density may even go down, and congestion with it This is wishful thinking. Everywhere you see a bus lane or a bike lane, it's underutilized. And that's true even when it's carrying all of the existing bicycle traffic that would have been there regardless. Because the reason people don't ride bicycles isn't a lack of bike lanes. It's because they're traveling a longer distance than can covered in a reasonable amount of time on a bicycle. > (but that likely will induce demand) Induced demand is a farce. Congestion suppresses demand. If you relieve congestion in some way, the demand is no longer suppressed. But if we take as a given that we want to relieve congestion in some way, that's the amount of demand we have to deal with regardless of how we relieve the congestion. > I don’t think they get paid for ad impressions. Shop owners want people to enter their shop and buy things, not drive past it. If you're stuck at a stoplight at an intersection with a gas station, a pizzeria and a toy store and you need gas, food and a birthday gift for your nephew, you stop and buy those things. If you drive past that street on the new highway, you buy gas at a different gas station, order pizza from a different pizzeria and buy the toy on Amazon. They're not the seller of advertising, they're the advertiser not wanting to lose the impressions they're currently getting without paying for them.
- Someone 5y ago“Everywhere you see a bus lane or a bike lane, it's underutilized.” Those can easily be underutilized and yet take more traffic than a lane filled with cars would take. “If you're stuck at a stoplight at an intersection with a gas station, a pizzeria and a toy store and you need gas, food and a birthday gift for your nephew, you stop and buy those things.” I don’t drive a car, but I doubt that because I don’t see how that would happen. It would take you minutes to find a spot to park your car and go shopping. The people I know purposefully decide to go into the town to do such shopping. And who’s talking about a new highway? If car drivers become part-time cyclists, there’s no need for building new roads. Also, it’s not a given that ease of access by car is good for shop owners. Some data points: https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2020/03/18/going-back-to-the-utrecht-mariaplaats/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2020/03/18/going-back-to-...: “When the council proposed to take away some of the car parking spaces the local entrepreneurs stunned the council by demanding all the parking to be removed. That was novel at the time (and to be honest it still is exceptional) but could be explained because the pedestrianised area is so close to this location. The merchants simply saw that business is booming literally around the corner at locations without moving and parked cars.” https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/jul/29/how-groningen-invented-a-cycling-template-for-cities-all-over-the-world https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/jul/29/how-groningen...: “there was also fierce opposition, especially from businessmen and shopkeepers who were convinced it would mean the end of their business if cars could no longer cross the centre. We tried to explain that we wanted to create a pleasant urban environment that eventually would attract more people to the centre and to their shops. But they were convinced they would go bankrupt if customers would not be able reach their shop by car,” says Van den Berg. “In the end, it turned out they were wrong.”
- II2II 5y ago> But those things are anti-car. They come at the cost of travel speed or congestion as a result of fewer lanes. They're thereby something you have to fight the masses in order to get, instead of finding a Pareto-optimal solution that can thereby actually be implemented. At the cost of parking, possibly. At the cost of travel speed, possibly. At the cost of congestion, unlikely. All of the proposals for bike lanes that I have seen have typically involved the removal of parking or the narrowing of lanes. The former typically happens where there is not enough space to use parked vehicles as a barrier between lanes for motor vehicles and bicycles. The latter is typically intentional, since narrow lanes are a mechanism for traffic calming. Neither should be classified as anti-car. Bike lanes typically run along roads that are mixed use. They aren't found on side streets since they don't address the safety issues found on side streets. (Side streets may be designated a bike route, but I have never seen a separation of traffic.) They are rarely found on roads since roads are intended to serve high speed traffic travelling long distances. There are usually better solutions for cyclists in that case. The end result is that bike lanes are usually placed along business corridors (e.g. those main drags), where traffic calming benefits all users. Parking is often less of an issue in those cases since those businesses couldn't be sustained by the limited parking available to start with. Cyclists are not out there battling against cars. It simply doesn't make sense. Many of the places that cars go are undesirable to cyclists. Many of the places that cyclists want to go are better served when accommodations are made for multiple modes of transportation. If you choose to interpret that as anti-car, well, there isn't much I can do about that aside from pointing out that it is not the intent and rarely the outcome.