3 ms·
I am one of the people who is totally for the removal of cars (in cities). I don't even think this is a radical position, cars are not a neutral mode of transpo
by atoav 5y ago
I am one of the people who is totally for the removal of cars (in cities). I don't even think this is a radical position, cars are not a neutral mode of transportation and people with cars get much more of the cake than any other person moving through a city.
Cars were somewhat utopian: everybody can move whereever they want, with a luxurious safe space around them, all while having the world shaped in auch a way it accomodates them and their car. Reality has shown, that this idea has not only serious downsides, but that it is also extremely inefficient and might even be part of the destruction of our planet. The idea that somehow we can build a sustainable world around cars, no matter how fuel efficient and what technology looks (to me) extremely naive, because it is inefficient and even if you made it better, you still won't beat bicycles in terms of efficiency and space usage.
Note: I don't argue there aren't legitimate use cases for cars. I grew up on the countryside in the alps, without a car you would be lost there (yet for some reason I managed to do everything with a bicycle/public transport till I got my driving license). Also: if your work requires you to move stuff around, cars (or trucks) can make a lot of sense. I am not arguing against that, I argue against one person sitting alone in their own 7m² and using that to commute into a city that is filled with cars.
In order to make cycling a real alternative we will have to take space, comfort and money away from cars. Take one lane away from a 4 lane road, paint it red, make it a bicycle lane. Add trains/subways/busses where people can transport their biciclyes, all that stuff.
I also have lived long enough in different european cities to know it works perfectly fine. I mean there are cities without any cars in their center (because of historical reasons) and they don't die.
- bookofsand 5y ago> for some reason I managed to do everything with a bicycle/public transport till I got my driving license Reasons being: no job and no kids. I lived for years in the LA megalopolis without a car. Where going to the toilet is customary done at the wheel (1). We could possibly share stories about that one multi-hour bike ride to the box store and back. All that ended quite abruptly with the first job and especially the first kid. (1) Not really, but I hope it helps getting the the point across.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoYet even an unemployed single parent gets around just fine in Europe. Where I live, public transport is free for young kids and parents with strollers. The buses have separate "getting on/off with stroller" buttons that signals the driver to activate the hydraulics that tilt the whole bus just to make it easier to dis/mount with a baby.
- dzikimarian 5y agoUnless you want to visit parents in other, smaller city. Then half hour drive with car, changes to two hour struggle in a crowded bus.
- atoav 5y agoOr your half an hour bicycle ride changes to one hour on a crowded street. Totally depends.
- mcny 5y agoI support banning cars specifically in certain neighborhoods in Manhattan. Probably not in any other borough or Jersey City but I want a ban on cars in Manhattan for exactly the same reason you are describing - building empathy toward people who need to use the subway with their babies in a stroller or backpack (not sure what the correct terminology is for this). If everyone has to use public transit, maybe we will be nicer to people who have to take their human infants to the doctor in a bus or a subway.
- II2II 5y agoA lot of that has to do with the design of the city. In my neck of the woods (a moderately dense urban area in Canada) I see plenty of parents who either don't own a car or use their car as the exception rather than the rule.