5 ms·
I wonder if they have the equivalent the engineers who bemoan the fact that some React developers make functioning websites without “knowing anything about how
by renewiltord 5y ago
I wonder if they have the equivalent the engineers who bemoan the fact that some React developers make functioning websites without “knowing anything about how CPUs or memory models work”.
Bourbaki was a thing so probably. And we know the joke about Bourbaki and Lang. Though the reference is diminished by the latter’s relationship with the former.
- laichzeit0 5y agoIt’s higher than that. People build software calling .search() and .sort() after a 4 month nanodegree and don’t know how to implement either. I’d say they are even using http requests without knowing what a TCP socket connection is, maybe even what an http request header is. The barrier to entry in the dev world is extremely low. To relate it to maths: It would be equivalent to someone doing math research without knowing how to do proof by induction (in analogy to not knowing how to implement .sort())
- Isinlor 5y agoLack of gatekeeping and general accessibility of software development is the beauty of this profession.
- laichzeit0 5y agoSorry, let me rephrase. I didn't mean it in a negative way. The last time I needed to actually implement a sort method was when I was doing very low level embedded work and there wasn't one available on that platform (at least not one with the memory/compute trade offs I needed). I'm sympathising with mathematicians who have to build stuff on black-box stuff they don't full understand. Things are too complex to know it down to the CPU level, even so complex that modern devs don't even know how search and sort is implemented, but still get shit done.
- lyaa 5y agoThese devs don't need to. As long as they get work done, create `value', their skills are sufficient. Admittedly, there are times when people who know better are needed for specific tasks and that's why we are paid better. Proof by induction is more akin to for-loop than optimized sort algorithms. It's often taught in the first mathematics course that includes proofs which can be Calculus II or even Linear Algebra. I would be surprised if a Math student did not learn it by their first Analysis course.
- regularfry 5y agoIt's funny, I'd say that the reason these devs don't need to understand the lower layers is because the layering abstraction was built well enough. That's a good thing!
- hnfong 5y agoI'm not a mathematician, but in the rare occasion I have to use the Pythagoras theorem, I use it without knowing how to prove it. And that's OK. (Mathematicians are probably too polite to moan about amateur plebs like me who didn't even learn primary school mathematics properly)
- wbl 5y agoBehold! http://www.geom.uiuc.edu/~demo5337/Group3/Bhaskara.html http://www.geom.uiuc.edu/~demo5337/Group3/Bhaskara.html It's so pretty everyone should know it.
- achenet 5y agoI'm afraid I don't know the joke about Bourbaki and Lang, could you please share it? I do have a possibly relevant joke: A math student asks his professor how to visualize a result in 7-dimensional space. The professor responds: "It's easy. I visualize the result in n-dimensional space, then simply take n = 7."
- mathieubordere 5y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/j569y/can_someone_explain_this_joke_to_me/ https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/j569y/can_someone_exp...
- z77dj3kl 5y agoI've heard of mathematicians being frustrated by physicists who use fancy stuff without full understanding of the underlying principles, and sometimes they just manipulate the notation without fully justifying what that manipulation means (e.g. you may have an integral operator on some space, and you might just swap an infinite sum and that integral operator, but that requires a justification that you might omit).