3 ms·
"Don't be anti-Axis-powers. Be pro something else." "Don't be anti-HIV. Be pro something else." "Don't be anti-crime. Be pro something else." "Don't be an
by dredmorbius 5y ago
"Don't be anti-Axis-powers. Be pro something else."
"Don't be anti-HIV. Be pro something else."
"Don't be anti-crime. Be pro something else."
"Don't be anti-(house|city|wild)-fire. Be pro something else."
"Don't be anti-discrimination. Be pro something else."
"Don't be anti-software-defect. Be pro something else."
Cheap and meaningless rhetorical techniques are best exposed by substituting in other terms.
It's useful to note that problem solving has a number of stages. That generally involves identification of a problem, a goal, a path-to-goal, and a mechanism for achieving said path. That said, which you focus on (problem, goal, path, mechanism) is best determined by where focus is most effectively attended. And that varies by the problem. Blanket prescriptions rarely work.
The automobile has created the modern urban landscape and its characteristics. That's the primary focus in reversing or correcting many of those faults.
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2fsr0g/hierarchy_of_failures_in_problem_resolution/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2fsr0g/hierarc...
- dflock 5y ago> "Don't be anti-Axis-powers. Be pro something else." Pro: Allies, peace. > "Don't be anti-HIV. Be pro something else." Pro: Science, research, vaccines, health equality, etc... > "Don't be anti-crime. Be pro something else." Pro: Social security/welfare, Mental Healthcare for all, drug legalization, rehabilitation, etc... > "Don't be anti-(house|city|wild)-fire. Be pro something else." Pro: Ecological Forest Management, Public Services, Firefighers & Funding, etc... > "Don't be anti-discrimination. Be pro something else." Pro: Social Justice, Black Lives Matter, Equality, etc... > "Don't be anti-software-defect. Be pro something else." Pro: Unit Tests, End-to-End Testing, User Testing, Fuzzing, Documentation, etc...
- dredmorbius 5y agoSometimes, if your goal is to hit a specific target, the best advice is "aim for the bullseye", and not "don't aim at everything that isn't the bullseye". Worse yet, an enumerated list of non-bullseyes not to aim at. I get Doreen's point. I can see the political logic in alliance-building. I understand that there are times when full-frontal assaults go poorly. I actually don't have a whole lot of issue with the suggestions. In this one case the advice might even be valid, for messaging purposes. As a general rule, and in terms of devising strategy, it's ... ill-conceived.
- thepangolino 5y agoI think the main issue is the current political discourse going for the “anti” approaches. Constantly calling for less consumption, less personal freedom, etc. All one hears is less less less in the name of illy and broadly defined causes such as “the environment”. This even showed with the global response yo the corona crisis. Les freedom of movement, less outdoor activities, less hospital occupation instead of more. More treatments options, etc.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd agree with much of that.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Cheap and meaningless rhetorical techniques are best exposed by substituting in other terms. You're just making a list of things without any redeeming characteristics. Nobody is pro-HIV. Lots of people are pro-car. But more importantly, it's missing the point. If you try to eliminate cars and replace them with nothing, or replace them with something worse, everybody is going to fight you because you're making their lives worse. If it's 20 miles from your house to your office and there exists no mass transit within walking distance of either one, expecting people to stop driving is a joke. You have to build a viable alternative before you can get rid of cars. And it has to be better than cars or everybody is going to hate it. But if it is better than cars then you don't need to be anti-car, all you need to do is build a better alternative which people will then choose voluntarily because it's actually better. Example: Build more housing near where people work, so they live within walking distance and don't need to commute in a car. It's not anti-car. It's just better, for everybody, than needing a car.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've ... shifted my views a bit over the past hour or so (see follow-up comments). I still stand by some of my critiques, though Doreen's points on messaging over a strongly-held, identity-defining product relationship are well-taken.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAfter more thought, and an offline exchange and apology to Doreen (my comment is a lot harsher than necessary), some additional thoughts. The main objection I and others seem to have is with the title. As Doreen noted offline, titles are hard. They're also highly influential in steering discussion on HN and elsewhere. Given that the post is about communicating effectively, this is all the more ironic --- not a ding at the author but at showing just how difficult the task can be. And part of the problem may be that the title itself does what it cautions against: "don't be anti-automobile" is itself emphasizing the negative rather than positive in messaging. As I noted in an earlier follow-up, many of the points of the post are well-taken. Full-frontal attack is often ineffective in politics. On the other hand, there are cases where nothing else seems to work and the only way to beat down an absolutely ossified and unyielding obstinance is a grinding war of attrition and repetitive messaging. (That's what mass advertising is.) Explaining (but not excusing) my own response: I'm increasingly on the lookout for what I see as cheap rhetorical devices especially where used to undermine effective initiatives. I don't think Doreen's doing this at all (though I'd also not noted the author/submitter initially), but having tackled a few instances earlier today on may have been overly primed-for-battle. The question of how to address urban / land-use issues, cost and availability of housing, and the absolute dependence on the automobile really are core, and thinking of how to wage that battle is time well-spent. My approach tends to involve digging through (far too much) history and background, trying to figure out how we got here, and what tactics were used in that approach. As several people brought up, automobile (and oil and tyre interests) did attack their competition and alternative land-uses directly, though it should also be noted not in their marketing selling the automobile itself, whcih focused largely on its benefits, pleasures, and with time, status and social perks. (The history of automobiles and mass advertising are very strongly coupled.) Automobiles won, in addition to various dirty tricks, because almost anything involving urban travel is easier with a car than without. It's a path of least resistance. With sufficiently low cost, with alternatives removed (dirty tricks), with a land-use policy necessitating their use ... it's an easy, and positive, sell. If I'd suggest a change to the title, it's that in messaging and campaigning about automobile alternatives, emphasizing the benefits and advantages of alternatives should be the principle focus. Even if strategy focuses on eliminating the car, messaging probably shouldn't. Be positive when advocating for behavioural change might be the key. (I'm open to better suggested phrasing. Advertising copyrighting is not my strong suit.) On the other hand, the title used was successful in attracting that fickle beast, attention...