2 ms·
This is a very simple analysis. Here's the phrase list: [1] It's quite short. It's clear how they get the numbers, but not clear what, if anything, they indicat
by Animats 5y ago
This is a very simple analysis. Here's the phrase list: [1] It's quite short. It's clear how they get the numbers, but not clear what, if anything, they indicate.
A big problem is that they only count one side.
"Fortune-telling: Making predictions, usually negative ones, about the future" - counts the phrases: "I will not, we will not, you will not, they will not, it will not, that will not, he will not, she will not".
One would expect that they'd also count "I will, "we will", etc. and show a ratio. But no.
This is measuring something, but what?
[1] https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2021/07/22/2102061118.DCSupplemental/pnas.2102061118.sapp.pdf https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2021/07/22/210206111...
- rdiddly 5y agoNot to mention that "I will get cancer" is a positive statement under that rubric, and "I will not have any problems" is negative. Shocker, you kind of need the rest of the sentence to extract meaning!
- Pyramus 5y ago> One would expect that they'd also count "I will, "we will", etc. and show a ratio. But no. No - what you want to measure is the absolute number of occurrence, not the ratio, the reason being that "making negative predictions" is not the opposite of "making positive predictions". Similar to the fact that negative and positive affect aren't opposites but distinct factors (that share some correlation though!). 'Common sense' can easily lead you astray here. It's a good example for something that looks simple, but really isn't.