4 ms·
I don't think Signal has many devs[0] and if you look at the contributors[1] you can see that Grayson is pretty much the only dev for the Android app. So seeing
by godelski 5y ago
I don't think Signal has many devs[0] and if you look at the contributors[1] you can see that Grayson is pretty much the only dev for the Android app. So seeing a second dev get involved is probably them freaking out.
[0] Personally I believe this is a big bump in the road for Signal and is why a lot of people are frustrated. About promises about things like usernames (it is no longer early 2021), channels, and everything else. A few devs can only do so much. A dozen (maybe 2 dozen?) devs can still only do so much. How do you compete with other platforms like Telegram that has hundreds of employees or WhatsApp with far more than that?
[1] https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/graphs/contributors https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/graphs/contribut...
- woxko 5y agoBug report is eight months old now. I don't think they're freaking out much.
- godelski 5y agoBut the issue is fixed. Forgetting to close a bug report is different than not fixing the bug
- jeroenhd 5y agoTrue, but the issue was fixed in 5.17, which was released only 10 days ago [1]. For an issue opened December last year, that's still quite a lot of time before a fix could be found. [1] https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/commit/a47448b6c6c26a0d7f7156ce54eeaf2a6a34ed5d https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/commit/a47448b6c...
- croes 5y agoTry fixing a rare bug quicker without constant user metrics.
- Arnt 5y agoYes, indeed. This kind of bug is an argument for having metrics.
- godelski 5y agoI'm not convinced. The bug is rare and requires a specific set of circumstances that not many people are going to perform. That is not an argument to collect metrics, or in other words, change the entire paradigm of Signal (no collection of Metadata). It does propose an argument for more audits, more eyes, and more care. But we do not expect Signal to be perfect, as no software is. Systematic failure, on the other hand, creates worry about Signal. But not individual.
- rvz 5y ago> I'm not convinced. The bug is rare and requires a specific set of circumstances that not many people are going to perform. I don't think you would say the exact same thing if this happened to closed-source apps like WhatsApp or Discord and open-source apps like Telegram or Element. All of these apps have funding behind them and lots of resources to urgently address security issues when reported or discovered. The same goes for Signal and they knew about this issue and left this open and unfixed for months. They have $60M in funding, fully open-source, full time engineers working on it and the priority was a secret cryptocurrency project over a critical security issue. No matter how 'rare' the bug was is pointless. There is no excuse for not prioritising for critical security issues and leaving them unfixed for months as these issues risk ruining their main selling point on privacy and security. > It does propose an argument for more audits, more eyes, and more care. Yet despite having a string of audits, it seems the priority for Signal was 'cryptocurrencies' last year and creating a new coin to be listed on an exchange for that purpose, instead of fixing this 7 month old critical issue that they knew about.
- godelski 5y ago> I don't think you would say the exact same thing if this happened to closed-source apps like WhatsApp or Discord You're right. Because I judge a project backed by a company worth hundreds of billions of dollars and with hundreds of developers differently than I judge a company with a few tens of millions and only a dozen developers. I'm not sure why any sane person would judge these with the same metric. 15 devs just can't do what 1500 can. I'm not sure why you think differently.
- dunefox 5y agoI mean, they invested a year into covert development of a crypto wallet inside Signal. Maybe that time could have been spent better.
- godelski 5y agoFrom the commits I only really saw Moxie adding this and he hasn't been doing as much dev work in the last few years. So I don't feel that this took much away. It's hard to tell if it is a good move or not since Telegram and WA are both adding payments to their platforms and there is a need for feature parity. But regardless, MOB probably wasn't a good fit and we've seen no update since. My complaint is more than Signal moves far too slow. I'm not saying to move fast and break things, that's far from what I want. But I am saying maybe add a few more devs.
- dunefox 5y ago> But I am saying maybe add a few more devs. Absolutely, then such an important issue probably wouldn't stay open for this long.
- aadjklskljads 5y agoNo, Signal does not get to play the limited resources card when they so firmly discourage 3rd parties from working on their project.
- LurkersWillLurk 5y agoCould you explain what Signal is doing to discourage contributions?
- afroboy 5y agoBy not allowing 3rd parties apps to coexist with official signal app. (Using same servers)
- growse 5y agoSignal placing restrictions on who can use their service has nothing to do with whether or not people can contribute to the codebase.
- hjek 5y agoIt does. There is less incentive to work on a Signal client fork if it can't be used to interoperate with the Signal service.
- growse 5y agoThat's a bit like saying there's less incentive to work on (for example) Elasticsearch, because you can't deploy your fork on Elastic Co's official managed service. It's nonsense.
- hjek 5y agoThere's a difference here between Elasticsearch and Signal, namely that that network effect is a very important factor with messaging apps.
- ergocoder 5y agoIf this is the case, then we should just say: Signal is not secure because they have limited resource and cannot invest in an area with Security adequately.
- askvictor 5y agoOr perhaps we drop the pretence of anything being absolute ('secure' vs 'not secure') and have a more honest discussion about the different threats and where different products do better or worse? I'm sure Whatsapp is much better in being able to resource their security measures, yet being owned by Facebook, and being closed-source diminishes their security in other ways.
- baby 5y agoI personally trust whatsapp, great product