10 ms·
Tesla will not offer a regular steering wheel on new Model S/X
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI have yet to see a positive review of the yoke steering wheel from reviewers or owners. One magazine put a professional racing driver and car reviewer in a Tesla with a yoke steering wheel Tesla. Even on the race track, he hated it and wanted a standard steering wheel back in. From what I've seen, even the Tesla die-hard fans are scratching their heads over this decision. This feels like the perfect example of a company's design team trying to tell customers' that their experiences and preferences are wrong, despite all evidence to the contrary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Osiris 5y agoIn a slow tight turn, I suspect most people do a hand over hand turn on the sterling wheel. Not having a complete circle will mean people have to relearn years of muscle memory when a turn of the sterling wheel of more than 45° is required.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI wonder how they'll do, having muscle-learned the yoke, to go back to a traditional car steering wheel.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe wheel can gripped at a 360 degrees. As it rotates, it's entire surface remains grippable. The yolk can only be gripped in some locations. So there's no muscle memory needed to switch to a wheel.
- mannykannot 5y agoEven so, where the rim is in relation to your hands is a function of the angle at which it is rotated. So too is the torque and displacement of the hands needed to get a given response.
- dangrossman 5y agoThe car can be "self-driving" on Autopilot/FSD, spinning that half-wheel all around on its own, and you must be able to take over at a second's notice if the car gets into a situation it can't handle. You may easily grab air depending on how far the car rotates the yoke before demanding you grasp it in an emergency situation. I don't know that even re-learning muscle memory can make that safe.
- mannykannot 5y agoA very good point. Also, as Tesla says: "Autopilot and Full Self-Driving Capability are intended for use with a fully attentive driver, who has their hands on the wheel and is prepared to take over at any moment. While these features are designed to become more capable over time, the currently enabled features do not make the vehicle autonomous." [1] How do they suppose that is going to work now that you cannot let the wheel slip through your fingers? Occasions when the vehicle is making a tight turn seem to be among those events when intervention may be needed. - Unless, of course, they don't actually expect anyone to do what they insist is necessary for safety, and this is just cynical CYA nonsense. [1] https://www.tesla.com/support/autopilot#active-safety-features https://www.tesla.com/support/autopilot#active-safety-featur...
- LinAGKar 5y agoAnd then let the wheel slip as the car straightens out. With this you'll end up dropping the wheel.
- aaronmdjones 5y agoThis feels like the perfect example of a company's design team trying to tell customers' that their experiences and preferences are wrong, despite all evidence to the contrary. Clearly they're just turning it wrong.
- nabilhat 5y ago> One magazine put a professional racing driver and car reviewer in a Tesla with a yoke steering wheel Tesla. Even on the race track, he hated it and wanted a standard steering wheel back in. That makes sense. Steering technique is taken seriously as a safety practice in racing. Honestly, steering technique should be taken more seriously in normal driving; for example the person in the lead photo in this article would be in a world of hurt if the airbag deployed with their arms crossed up like that. Gimmicky yoke wheels have repeatedly failed to catch on for most of a century, outside of goofy kit cars, dead end concepts, and a handful of out-there exotics. Even Saab gave up on trying to come up with a not-a-round-wheel steering gimmick that wasn't awful, after decades of trying.
- lokedhs 5y agoI seem to recall having attachments to steering wheels being illegal in Sweden. This makes me wonder if this wheel won't be illegal in a lot of places.
- akmarinov 5y agoGo on r/Tesla and you’ll see tons
- tristanj 5y agoThey're taking a card from Apple's playbook: intentionally creating controversy. Remove some basic functionality and refuse to give it back claiming it's better this way, causing an internet debate between diehard fans and critics, resulting in free promotion and advertising. Now everyone knows about their latest product. Just like what happened when Apple removed the headphone jack, power brick, butterfly keyboard (looks nice but terrible to use), etc.
- chana_masala 5y agoWell you put it much better than I could have. I had come to say the same
- agloeregrets 5y agoThat's not really the Apple playbook. Apple's moves tend to have a background of reason: The Headphone jack removal allowed for the Taptic Engine on the 7. It was a halo item for reviews when they added it. The Brick removal was an E-Waste concern that all other brands are following. (This does not ignore the upside to Apple with the Airpods and Wall adaptors, just that there is grey here) Then there were the prior items: Removing Apple Serial (iMac) was super controversial, it led to USB being mainstream. Removing the CD Drive on the MacBook air directly led to 10 hour battery life laptops. Removing full size ports on laptops led to a more versatile port and charging situation (if not less convenient) Apple's moves have advantages. This wheel is just Sci-Fi theater that doesn't do anything better. Elon doesn't play 4D chess. Hell, he disbanded Tesla's entire PR department.
- grishka 5y ago> The Headphone jack removal allowed for the Taptic Engine on the 7 Most of the space that would be taken by the headphone jack in the iPhone 7 is instead taken by the utterly useless piece of plastic called "barometric vent". And it's not like Apple engineers couldn't have figured out how to combine water resistance with a headphone jack — Samsung did that somehow. Oh, and there's plenty of space inside an iPad, but newer models also come without a headphone jack. It has to be a political decision, not a practical one. As well as their insistence on keeping Lightning a thing. This whole situation is so ridiculous at this point — the lack of a headphone jack is now considered a flagship feature. If you have a lot of money to spend on a phone, you can't not want the unreliable mess that is bluetooth, right? And before you say it: bluetooth is not a replacement for a wired connection. And, for that matter, neither is wifi a replacement for ethernet.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoI love my Tesla Model 3 and recognize that many non-standard Musk brainfarts worked out ok(ish) in the past (gullwing doors, weird door handles, touchscreen instead of dashboard.) But one of my biggest fears is that Musk’s ideas will eventually blow up the company. This would be bad for me as a vehicle owner who wants parts and service, and more generally it would be terrible for EV competition during this stage where “traditional manufacturers” are just utterly blowing it. There is no way I would drive a car with a wheel like this. It completely rules out the S/X if there’s no option. Between this, the awful Cybertruck, and the decision to go vision-only and remove the radar in new Teslas, I’m not confident at all that Tesla is safe from destroying their market with a few opinionated screwups.
- blehn 5y agoWhat's awful about the Cybertruck?
- vb6sp6 5y agoThe design is polarizing
- blehn 5y agoSo was the design of the iPhone, and Yeezy sneakers. How is that "awful"?
- Symbiote 5y agoThe Cybertruck wouldn't be street-legal in Europe, since it can't meet pedestrian/cyclist collision safety requirements. Take whatever fashionable discomfort you like, but let's not increase the danger to others. "According to EU auto standards expert Stefan Teller the Cybertruc would have to undergo 'major modifications to the basic structure' because the Cybertruck 'contradicts the European security philosophy'" https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2019/12/16/tesla-cybertruck-not-street-legal-in-eu/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2019/12/16/tesla-cy...
- 5y ago
- jdhn 5y agoI routinely put one hand at the 12 o'clock position on my steering wheel to make a turn, and I'm willing to bet money that I'm not exactly an outlier. The product designer within me says that this is a classic case of UI taking precedence over UX.
- hinkley 5y agoIf you learned driving stick then you steer a bit differently anyway because you can’t rely on having both hands the entire time. I tend to cross over going both directions now. For a turn the right hand goes to 10:30 or the left hand to 1:30. Depending on power steering, I may complete the turn with the butt of my hand, in which case the yolk is probably just short enough so that if my hand slips at all I would lose contact. There’s just not enough buffer to be comfortable. More importantly, as I accelerate out of a turn I tend to let the wheel slip through my fingers, driven by centripetal force. It’s a smoother line with better lateral G forces for my passengers, and better tire grip. I’ll be really interested to see if their drive by wire system breaks that, too.
- blehn 5y agoUI != aesthetics
- DamnYuppie 5y agoLol it looks like Elon is just trying to live out his childhood fantasy of driving KIT from KnightRider!
- bengale 5y agoLuckily the Taycan has a nice steering wheel.
- mandeepj 5y agoI don’t have latest update on Tesla’s right-to-repair in the aftermarket case, the yoke steering wheel replacement with the practical one - makes perfect business idea to pursue
- akmarinov 5y agoTesla churns out S/X in the very low thousands, so not a lot of potential customers.
- the__alchemist 5y agoThe visibility of gauges issue is a real concern - I've been fluxxomed by this for all cars I've driven in recent history, where I can't see various gauges due to the top of the wheel blocking them.
- MrRiddle 5y agoReal concern?
- slumpt_ 5y agoSteering wheels are adjustable…
- ferongr 5y agoDo you then adjust the wheel for comfort of visibility of the instrument display?
- aaronmdjones 5y agoThe displays are more important. Besides, you can also adjust the seat to make the wheel position comfortable regardless of where the wheel is.
- the__alchemist 5y agoWhen I adjust it so the wheel's at a comfortable height, it blocks instruments.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoI’m 6’7” and I’ve never thought about visibility of the gauges. During a turn what do you need to see the gauge cluster for? Your eyes should be on the road.
- nitrogen 5y agoAt some heights, in some cars, the wheel blocks the speedometer all the time, so you have to duck and bob to know if you're going too slow or too fast if there's no traffic to blend with.
- MrRiddle 5y agoBlinkers and horn being button s and removal of the top grab area is the stupidest thing I’ve ever seen changed in a car.
- trident5000 5y agoWould be great if the horns could be disabled in cities from cab and uber drivers remotely. Like you get 3 horns per day and then were shutting you down. None of them own teslas yet but one day maybe.
- burnt_toast 5y agoThey could offer a subscription plan for unlimited honks for a small monthly fee
- ddingus 5y agoGeofencing. You are entering a horn free community...
- nitrogen 5y agoHorns are already a button in some cars, presumably to make way for an airbag. You don't want your palm on the center of the wheel when that airbag goes off.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- derefr 5y agoCurious whether they could take this even further. I've always wanted to try driving where turning uses absolute position rather than relative motion on the steering column to determine wheel rotation, like an analog stick in a driving game: rotate fully to the right and the gear box will push the wheels continuously to the right; let go and the yoke would snap back to neutral, and the gear box would then work with sensors to bring the wheels to a straight-forward neutral position. The absolute yaw of the yoke at any moment should be reflected in the absolute yaw of the wheels. I'd also be curious, given a flight yoke, to try controlling acceleration (not velocity!) using the Z dimension of the yoke, like actual planes do — maybe not with actual travel, but just with strain gauges on the shaft of the yoke to detect how hard you're pushing/pulling on it. Push to accelerate; pull to decelerate; relax to cruise.
- systemvoltage 5y agoThat sounds tiring and painful. Heel of your foot helps to stabilize the throttle actuation. Your hands would be hanging in the air. Also there is this - accelerate accidentally while also turning. There is absolutely zero need to reinvent the car UI/UX. Don’t try to fix what’s not broken.
- nitrogen 5y agoThere is absolutely zero need to reinvent the car UI/UX. Don’t try to fix what’s not broken. While nobody has yet improved significantly on the traditional control layout of gas/brake/[clutch]/wheel, I still think as a matter of principle that it's really unlikely we are at the global optimum. Thus, experimentation should always be on the table, as long as it's optional.
- systemvoltage 5y agoEven if we're not at global optimum, we've got some billions of users that are used to the current UX/UI.
- derefr 5y agoWe were talking about "driving", but who said anything about cars? ;) "Giving strategic-level input to the AI that drives around the self-driving vehicle that you have final responsibility over" doesn't necessarily have much to do with "driving a car." "Being the remote operator who steps in to remote-drive a self-driving vehicle when the AI can't figure out what to do" has even less to do with "driving a car." (Presuming they don't give each remote operator a full 360° driving simulator, it's only going to be about as immersive as a video game, anyway.) IMHO, it's only natural to begin re-thinking "car" UI/UX for those cases. Especially for the future generations who will be born into an era where they may "learn to drive" and then "drive" all their lives, never using any car other than self-driving ones. It's only during this transitional era, where autonomous driver AI isn't very good and needs constant manual input — and where the majority of people who own self-driving cars have also owned "hand-driven" cars — that it would seem to be a good idea to give input to a driving AI using hand-driven car inputs.
- tyingq 5y agoThere were apparently some hidden photos on Tesla's site of the car with a normal steering wheel... https://www.thedrive.com/tech/38976/tesla-site-code-shows-that-refreshed-model-s-x-might-not-get-the-yoke-steering-wheel https://www.thedrive.com/tech/38976/tesla-site-code-shows-th... The trick was to replace $STOY with $ST03 in this url, but it appears Tesla blocked that: https://static-assets.tesla.com/configurator/compositor?&options=$PBSB,$IBC00,$ST0Y&view=INTERIOR&model=ms&size=1920
- akmarinov 5y agoThey also had a Plaid prototype with a normal wheel - https://imgur.com/a/AToY8rb https://imgur.com/a/AToY8rb
- nyrikki 5y agoFunny enough I just recently went to training that demonstrated how hand-over-hand steering is a requirement for effective skid recovery. I never thought I would abandon thoughts of owning a car based solely on the steering wheel, but as I live in a place where it snows....I was wrong.
- nitrogen 5y agoIf the steering ratio is smaller, so something like 90 degrees is full lock, you could maybe get away without hand-over-hand.
- nyrikki 5y agoThe steering ratio is 14.0:1 or 2.3 lock to lock so no-go. Consumers complain about faster steering ratios being darty so I doubt anyone but the Italians will go with faster ratios.
- tyingq 5y agoThe ratio is 14.0:1, with 2.3 turns lock to lock[1,2] [1] https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2022-tesla-model-s-plaid-steering-yoke-wheel-review/ https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2022-tesla-model-s-plaid-... [2] https://electrek.co/2021/07/23/elon-musk-confirms-tesla-not-offer-regular-steering-wheel-model-s-x/ https://electrek.co/2021/07/23/elon-musk-confirms-tesla-not-...
- tehnub 5y agoAirbag safety seems to be worse with a yoke compared to a wheel. The yoke essentially forces you to cross over your arms for some turns, putting your forearm in the way of the airbag, and you don’t want the airbag smashing your arm into your face. Of course, with a wheel you can slide your hands on each side of the wheel, never crossing them over unless you choose to.
- fourthark 5y agoModel S/X really?!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ddingus 5y agoFlat out, the steering device shown is unsafe. We will read about this decision sometime in the near future.
- nabilhat 5y agoYoke steering wheels have been done to death. Almost always, they're a gimmick intended to highlight the edgy design of a kit car or exotic outlier. Less often, they're a workaround for bad cockpit design that fails to account for a standard steering wheel [0] [1]. Rarest of all, a yoke steering wheel ends up being used in a production car, without a trace of irony, failure, or gimmickery [2]. Tesla is recycling a feature that first went into mass automotive production in 1955. The 1980's did it better though [3] [4]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_Allegro#Reputation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_Allegro#Reputation [1] <ahem> https://electrek.co/2021/07/23/elon-musk-confirms-tesla-not-offer-regular-steering-wheel-model-s-x/ https://electrek.co/2021/07/23/elon-musk-confirms-tesla-not-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_KR200 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_KR200 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KITT#/media/File:KITT_Interior_at_Toronto_Auto_Show_2011.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KITT#/media/File:KITT_Interior... [4] https://www.thedrive.com/news/33416/the-1986-oldsmobile-incas-had-the-wildest-dashboard-youve-never-seen https://www.thedrive.com/news/33416/the-1986-oldsmobile-inca...
- MR4D 5y agoMy bet is this will change when accidents start happening at a higher rate. A class action lawsuit combined with NHTSA investigation would be brutally effective.
- sys_64738 5y agoThe Knight Rider auto had one of these. K.A.R.R. But it wasn't a friendly car.
- lamontcg 5y ago> Musk insists that the yoke steering wheel is worth it for offering better visibility of the instrument cluster and its driving visualizations. optimizing for internal distractions over steering the vehicle...