2 ms·
You're wrong because they're usually wrong. Again it comes down to the guidelines. If they quoted the guidelines and then explained why it's off-topic, it might
by mattmaroon 18y ago
You're wrong because they're usually wrong. Again it comes down to the guidelines. If they quoted the guidelines and then explained why it's off-topic, it might be useful.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoIf you are asking what the rules to the site should be, then it's a circular argument to expect commenters to use the guidelines as a reason for things to belong or not. The question was: what sorts of things would you like to see? I made the observation that the current customers repeatedly don't like the things they are seeing -- to the point of making comments that they feel the articles are out of place. The question isn't whether they should have made an observation about how the articles meet the guidelines. The question you asked is whether or not topics should be accepted or not as _part_ of the guidelines. In that context, of course we should consider those customers that speak up. Whether they realize it or not, they're basically saying screw the guidelines -- it doesn't look right to me. I look at commenters as customers. Obviously, some significant percentage of customers are going to be unhappy with any sort of system.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI see what you mean. I'd guess the problem is that it accounts for very few votes for #1, but the same people casting the same vote over and over again. I know every time I dig through the comments of someone who says that something is off-topic, I find multiple instances of it. Either way, I'd have less problem if they said "I wish this were off-topic" because then they'd at least be factually accurate.