3 ms·
How did this get to #4 on the homepage with only 6 upvotes at the time? That seems almost impossible without manipulation.
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
How did this get to #4 on the homepage with only 6 upvotes at the time? That seems almost impossible without manipulation.
- seattle_spring 5y agoDo you ask the same questions when the same thing happens with pro-Ivermectin articles?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI'm not talking about the content of the article at all. I'm just talking meta about how that seems impossible. #4 position with 6 upvotes seems impossible, but maybe I'm wrong and somehow it's was just the most disproportionate upvote-rank ratio I've seen yet.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoFor those downvoting, it's not the article. Can one not question the meta aspects about an article's ranking for clarification? I did not mean to imply any foul play.
- akomtu 5y agoI suspect HN has weights for popular words, e.g. "YouTube" gives +5, "anti-vax" gives -15 and so on.
- OJFord 5y agoIt's currently 14 votes and 31 minutes old (and fallen to spot 5). So 6 and call it what, 15±5? Neither is at all unusual. Being quickly voted on is worth more (in terms of the ranking) than the same handful of votes over hours or days.
- caramelcream 5y agoIt's not unusual, HN's front page ranking algorithm is heavily biased towards new submissions.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoMakes sense. It's just that #4 position with 6 upvotes is the most extreme ratio I've seen yet. When I said that it seemed impossible without manipulation (on a post now flagged), I did not mean that manipulation was happening, just that this seemed unusual.
- villasv 5y agoYou didn’t mean it was happening, but saying that it’s “almost impossible” that it isn’t happening doesn’t come across as moderate as you might have intended.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoExactly. That's why I said that it seems almost impossible... but that's not very clear or moderate over text, my bad.
- imjustsaying 5y agoHow new are you? It's extremely unusual. Check the numbers in my other post.
- villasv 5y agoHow new are you? I’ve seen this a bunch. The weird ones just fall into oblivion quickly.
- jimbob45 5y agoDang has a post about front page dynamics…somewhere on here.
- dang 5y agoI've looked at the data; it was perfectly normal. This kind of thing happens all the time. It just stands out more when the topic is eye-catching or indignation-inducing.