4 ms·
This is really interesting to watch, I hope there are some academics out there charting out the facts of the rise and fall of social networks for the rest of us
by roenxi 5y ago
This is really interesting to watch, I hope there are some academics out there charting out the facts of the rise and fall of social networks for the rest of us to follow along, there are so many interesting things happening in the US big tech world.
I think people overestimate how quickly competition happens and underestimate how powerful it is. There is a massive hole for new competitors to move in to the social media space. I see Brett Weinstein has finally decided YouTube is untenable, for example. This is just another data point in a trend of people with interesting opinions rediscovering the dangers of centralisation.
I single out this quote from early in the article:
> For the past few years, we at Damn Interesting have been hearing from scores of long-time fans who were under the mistaken impression that we had ceased all operations years ago.
What this says to me is it takes people a few years to notice when a social network is no longer providing value. That sits well with my assumption that users actually leaving a platform is a long lagging indicator that the platform is dead. The early sign is that the content producers are being squeezed.
- austincheney 5y agoAccording to HN today social media is a necessity that must be forced on children: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27942843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27942843 Parents that say otherwise are the great evil. It does make me wonder how many of those wonderful individuals (experts) actually are parents.
- cortesoft 5y agoSmashing the shit out of a phone to prove a point is a horrible example to set as a parent.
- austincheney 5y agoDo you have teenage children?
- fsloth 5y agoI do and would agree smashing a phone is terrible example. If anything it shows authority has been lost and the parent is flailing desperately. Sure, you can get compliance just like you can get compliance by pepper spraying someone but it's not how to do good parenting. You can of course remove the phone if it seems it's warranted. Parents are eligible to critical interventions IMO. There are times when parents actually need to intervene. But this intervention should be taken from a position of dignity, authority, respect and minimal violence. The quality of intervention depends on the situation. As a parent of a slightly autistic child for example I've had to restrain the child physically to stop the child for harming themself or the anyone else during a meltdown. I would never smash any of my childs property. Remove - yes, if the situation warrants it.
- austincheney 5y agoI have found, through practice, that temporary removal entices false incentives when the actual problem is substance addiction because it doesn’t remove/repair the problematic behavior. If only it were limited to noncompliance you probably wouldn’t have to go as far as removal.
- fsloth 5y agoActually we had a severe youtube and game problem. Not just being glued to it, but up to a point were the child became a "zombi" just wanting the screen. Removing the phone temporarily, and then saying unless limits were followed the phone would be removed again actually worked. This of course needed to be repeated at every lapse. The most difficult thing as a parent was being thoroughly consistent - no ifs or buts. It would create a terrible scene every time. But after a few bouts things became much better. But kid's are different. It totally varies from person to person what works and not.
- cortesoft 5y agoI have kids, but they are not yet teenagers. I could see taking the phone away, or even selling it… but smashing it is both wasteful and sets a bad example for how we deal with issues.
- seattle_spring 5y agoChrist, talk about taking the comments out of context. They were saying that strictly forbidding your child access would just make them do an end-run around their parents and use it behind their backs. If you think a no-tolerance rule for something as pervasive as social media is going to yield some unspoiled angel of a child, you're in for a rude awakening. Edit: it's also completely unrelated to the comment you responded to, which was talking about one social media giant going out of favor for another. You conflated it with "all social media" just to bring your drama into another post (which it looks like you've done elsewhere too). Sorry if the truth hurts, I'm just, as your profile states, "confronting you with radical honesty."
- austincheney 5y ago> Sorry if the truth hurts, I'm just, as your profile states, "confronting you with radical honesty." Talk about taking things wildly out of context. I have nearly 7000 karma on here. A few downvotes from sensitive people who are most likely teenagers themselves isn’t a bother. If it were a bother for me I would never express anything remotely unpleasant here as some people hang on every word too seriously/literally. It’s the hypocrisy expressed above that’s more frustrating. Watching people be addicted to this stupidity in the real world and vicariously living their lives through that lens is supremely disappointing.
- ekster 5y agoThere are lots of good answers there to the same question that essentially say the same thing as you, but minus telling your kids to fuck off and that you are the boss and smashing the phone. I tend to agree with them, as well as the people who replied to you saying that that’s not a very good parenting style. You’ll likely alienate your children and not teach them anything, except perhaps that they need to respond unquestioningly to authority or they will be met with violence. I suspect that is more why you were downvoted, but not really sure why you want to re-litigate it here in the first place.
- austincheney 5y agoSo you’re saying the language of the comment upset you? That you would have agreed to the general position had it not generated an emotional response for you?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ekster 5y agoNo, I am saying that telling your kids to fuck off, you’re the boss, and smashing their phone is poor parenting. Same as everyone else with whom you are arguing here.
- austincheney 5y agoIt’s my phone to do with as I please. Would it be less upsetting if I just returned to the phone store? Do your children dictate to you the rules of what to do with the things you pay for?
- ekster 5y agoIt would be better parenting if you didn’t smash the phone, tell them you’re the boss, and that they should fuck off. I am sorry but if it’s still confusing to you after repeating the same thing three times, along with everyone else saying similar things, then maybe you can start to understand why so many of your comments are flagged dead now. Nobody really wants to have a multi-day conversation with someone who isn’t listening, cross-posts their drama in multiple posts, puts words in others mouths, and generally behaves like an internet addicted teenager themselves.
- Spooky23 5y agoEnd of the day, these big companies are full of smart people who do dumb things. Facebook has the whole tone deafness and awful governance, Twitter sucks at execution, and of course Google did many things (killing RSS, bungling messaging, etc) that were from any point of view dumb.
- afterburner 5y agoLuckily, RSS is still alive and well. You can use it for damninteresting.com even!
- Noos 5y ago..yeah, that's why we are all talking about Mastodon and Diaspora right now, because there was a massive hole they rushed in to fill. Funny how even on HN people have completely forgotten about the former; I haven't seen it on the feed here in weeks. Youtube is untenable, lol. Hey everyone, the Ipod was untenable! Everyone is moving to Microsoft Zune! Ninja is going to livestream on Mixer, that will teach Twitch! This is like the Death of Wal-mart or something, people constantly proclaim it but it keeps chugging along.
- roenxi 5y agoYoutube will be fine, it is a pretty good platform as long as you aren't looking for political opinions. And Apple has historically been very methodical about closing down opportunities to compete with their products. The only part of the market they leave open is the part that has no money. There was a truly funny span of time when the iPhone accounted for more than 100% of the phone market because other mobile manufacturers were making losses. The Zune never had an obvious market segment that it could target. At the moment, anyone trying to produce right wing content would have to be mad to be comfortable on the major platforms. Even Amazon seems to be unreliable after what looks a lot like a political hit on Parler. There is a large, obvious & dissatisfied group to target here and potentially a valuable advertising market.
- hakfoo 5y agoI recall there was a point in time where my boss had an iPod, my co-worker had a Zune, and I had a Sandisk E250. They had some fairly different niches-- both the iPod and Zune were in the relatively narrow selection of high-capacity, hard-disc based MP3 players. In that environment, tje iPod was the minimalist option-- less complex UI, seamless package, but feature-poor. The Zune offered far more features and customizability. I can recall being aghast that you couldn't get a FM radio feature on an iPod, when the cheapest 'flash drive with dreams of grandeur' MP3 players offered it. (This, of course, being relevant when a 2Gb player wouldn't contain enough music to feel "infinite" and you'd want more variety)