4 ms·
> The value of his building's keep increasing so he doesn't care. By what metric? According to you, they're in an area where people don't want to be and there
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> The value of his building's keep increasing so he doesn't care.
By what metric? According to you, they're in an area where people don't want to be and there are no renters. If your description is even close to accurate, the value of the buildings is dropping.
- notatoad 5y agothe value of the building might be dropping but the value of the land keeps going up. eventually somebody will buy it to tear down and build condos.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe value of the building drops all the time. The value of the land is also dropping, as described. Loss of foot traffic is a blow to the value of the land, not the building. Who wants a condo in the middle of nowhere? The replace-it-with-condos plan requires the area to be growing, not shrinking.
- notatoad 5y agoWe're not talking about the actual middle of nowhere here. There are plenty of towns or smaller cities in the Midwestern US or the Canadian prairie that are still nice places to live but have downtown commercial districts which have shrunk over the last couple decades, and are now adjacent to functional main streets and held vacant by landlords who think commercial tenants will at some point be willing to pay the same high rents again. Amazon, e-commerce, and remote work mean towns can be growing at the same time as their central business districts are shrinking.
- rasz 5y agoHow would value be dropping if the commercial space has a $100/ft sticker on it and keeps going up. Its the same mechanism putting Tesla and shitcoins valuation on the moon.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoYou can put a sticker on anything you want. You already know the value is less than that because it's not being rented at that price.
- didibus 5y agoBecause the alternatives are going through the same process. It's not like only one neighborhood suffers from this, it's market wide, so as a renter, there is no better elsewhere to move too. The dying once lively neighborhood is still livelier than the dying was never lively neighborhood next to it, etc.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe question is whether it's livelier now than it was last year, or more dead. If it's livelier now, property there is increasing in value. If it's deader now, property there is falling in value.
- didibus 5y agoNot if other neighborhoods have also gone down in liveliness to the same extent. Imagine a liveliness scale, which is the amount of bars, restaurants, independent stores, coffee shops, music venues, theaters, arts/music expos, and other such things available in the neighborhood. If the top neighborhood for liveliness in some city last year scored 84 on that scale, but this year it went down 10 points to 74, because of hiking rents and commercial buildings unwilling to lower their prices even if it prices out all such business from the area, preferring to even keep units vacant instead. Now imagine all other neighborhoods similarly dropped 10 points on that scale. So the next one up last year might have been worth 80, but is now worth 70. That makes it that the same neighborhood is still the most lively, and therefore still the #1 place where renters hope to live, but overall the entire city is getting less lively. And now imagine this is happening in all cities, making every city similarly impacted. That would continue to keep prices distributed the same between neighborhoods, the most desirable neighborhood is still the most desirable one, yet the overall liveliness of everything is going down, while simultaneously having prices rise. I think most people are observing this phenomenon, but the question is why the hell is it happening? Why are landlords choosing to price rentals above market, losing their existing tenants in the process and yet having it vacant as no other business can afford the rent either?
- thaumasiotes 5y ago