6 ms·
California Agricultural Products summary report from 2016 weighs in at about 1000 pages. Farmers, crop-types (and their water districts), use patterns vary dra
by mistrial9 5y ago
California Agricultural Products summary report from 2016 weighs in at about 1000 pages. Farmers, crop-types (and their water districts), use patterns vary dramatically. Depending on conditions and the politics of the time, various sections of the Central Valley and particular landowners get increased scrutiny. Needless to say, any walking human has an opinion on water use, and the opinions are sometimes vocal. Every CA commercial operation has passed some kind of challenge to remain open today, for decades.
The total dollar volumes of some of the crops may surprise the first-time reader. For example, the famous California wine industry is not anywhere near the most valuable total value crop, and yes they use water.
The Pacific Institute is a commonly cited reference center for water issues in the US West
https://pacinst.org https://pacinst.org
the US Global Change research project has some detail about the situation
https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/10/ https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/10/
- throw0101a 5y ago> The total dollar volumes of some of the crops may surprise the first-time reader. Doing a quick search: 1. Dairy (milk and cream) $6.56B 2. Grapes $5.79B 3. Almonds $5.60 4. Cannabis (legal sales) $3.1 5. Strawberries $3.1 6. Cattle and Calves $2.63 7. Lettuce $2.51 8. Walnuts $1.59 9. Tomatoes $1.05 10. Pistachios $1.01 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_California However agriculture in general makes up less than 2% of GDP: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_California#Sectors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_California#Sectors While using 39% of the water: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_in_California#Uses_of_water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_in_California#Uses_of_wa... From a strictly utilitarian perspective, it may not be worth the effort to support agriculture. Or at the very least, if you're going to triage usage, it may have to be the first thing to be cut back on during dry spells.
- Cuuugi 5y agoYour argument doesn't factor in that people need to eat, and they well, are making food.
- mbrumlow 5y agoAnd they can get their food grown in a region that does not have a water issue.
- panny 5y agoAfter referring to them as flyover states, they might be reluctant to send California any food.
- mattnewton 5y agoI don't know much about farming, but I doubt farms that refuse to sell their crops stay farms for very long.
- trav4225 5y agoNot to mention that official state travel to many of these states is banned...
- spfzero 5y agoWith the attendant increase in carbon emissions to transport it though.
- wwweston 5y agoSure. And where food production is the policy concern, part of what you want would be incentives to produce high nutrition with water efficiency.
- kebman 5y agoNot a big problem. Can be imported from non-afflicted areas. Perhaps local shortages of certain products, but I doubt anyone will starve. It's pretty bad for the farmer in question, though, who will undoubtedly lose a lot of money.
- tdeck 5y agoThe big issue here in CA is that farmers are growing water-intensive crops that offer a better return (like almonds), but they're growing them in the desert known as the central valley. That leads to water shortages. As someone living in California I certainly appreciate the huge variety of great produce that's available because of CA agriculture, but even the almond farmers know this isn't going to last forever. They're all in a race to drill deeper wells than their neighbor and make a quick buck before the aquifer runs out. At that point we'll have no reserve at all and the party will grind to a halt. The better idea would be to grow different crops here, not to stop agriculture altogether. That requires some kind of rationing.
- ineedasername 5y agoFrom a strictly utilitarian perspective, it may not be worth the effort to support agriculture. That really depends on the economic impact of the other sources of water use, most of which, 50% of total use, is for "environmental" purposes that do not directly impact GDP in the same way as agriculture. [0] I'm not saying Environmental use is less important: I'm saying that a utilitarian GDP focused policy on water use is probably not the best metric to use: There's simply too little other water-reliant commerce in CA to use GDP as a yardstick here. That just leaves balancing 40% use by agriculture against 50% use for environmental purposes. [0] https://www.ppic.org/publication/water-use-in-california/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/water-use-in-california/
- mlyle 5y agoMore like 80% of the water, because IMO the 50% of water use that is "environmental use" -- AKA not drying out all the rivers entirely-- isn't directly used by humans.
- username90 5y agoSo they make around 1 dollar per 1000 gallons? People rationing their shower time as urged by authorities must be proud that they could save a farmer somewhere a cent or two.
- oceanghost 5y agoThis is what burned during the last drought. I let everything in my yard die because we were only allowed to water 1 day a week. Thousands of dollars worth of landscaping died-- and for what as you say? So a farmer could make a little more money that year?
- simfree 5y agoSounds like the landscaping picked wasn't the right choice for the climate you reside in. Rain patterns and seasonal temperature have changed over the last 20 years, landscaping that made sense when I was a kid no longer works in many areas without daily watering.
- oceanghost 5y agoSo you're correct of course, but, ironically, I lived in a historical area which had strict rules about what could and could not be landscaped. I literally had the plants that were legal for me to have. Please find attached a story about the City of Orange suing its residents for landscaping with drought resistant plants. "Orange officials sue couple who removed their lawn By Amina Khan March 2, 2010 12 AM PT Some Southern California cities fine residents for watering their lawns too much during droughts. But in Orange, officials are locked in a legal battle with a couple accused of violating city ordinances for removing their lawn in an attempt to save water. The dispute began two years ago, when Quan and Angelina Ha tore out the grass in their frontyard. In drought-plagued Southern California, the couple said, the lush grass had been soaking up tens of thousands of gallons of water -- and hundreds of dollars -- each year." https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2010-mar-02-la-me-bad-lawn2-2010mar02-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2010-mar-02-la-me-ba...
- i_am_proteus 5y agoBe careful with this line of "utilitarian" thinking. Food production is not easily replaced. California produces 95% of tomatoes grown in the USA.[0] 18.5% of milk.[1] These volumes can't be readily replaced by other states' production. California is an agriculture powerhouse. Certainly luxury export crops like the oft-vilified almond might not be sorely missed, but staples like tomatoes, lettuces, dairy, and beef would be in shortage at sky-high prices without California's production. [0]https://downloads.usda.library.cornell.edu/usda-esmis/files/02870v86p/0r967m63g/sn00bf58x/vegean20.pdf https://downloads.usda.library.cornell.edu/usda-esmis/files/... [1]https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/DataFiles/48685/milkcowsandprod.xlsx?v=1810.1 https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/DataFiles/48685/milkcowsand...
- throw0101a 5y ago> California produces 95% of tomatoes grown in the USA.[0] 18.5% of milk.[1] The US overproduces milk from what I've read. Reducing some output may actually be a good thing: * https://wisconsinexaminer.com/2019/07/29/milk-too-much-of-a-good-thing/ https://wisconsinexaminer.com/2019/07/29/milk-too-much-of-a-... More generally, perhaps measuring dollar-of-GDP-per-gallon-of-water or some such may be of some use to prioritize which crops should be discouraged may be worth examining.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoThat's an opinion piece you linked there. I'll reiterate that dollars are not a good way to measure the value to society of agricultural products, especially necessary vegetables like tomatoes. How do you measure the second- and third-order effects of the population having access to an affordable nutritious diet?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- YokoZar 5y ago> More generally, perhaps measuring dollar-of-GDP-per-gallon-of-water or some such may be of some use to prioritize which crops should be discouraged may be worth examining. The normal way to "measure" and "discourage" such inefficient things is by prices. However, the price of California water is inordinately cheap so long as you are dumping it on the ground in the desert.
- glennvtx 5y agoDenying large swaths of agriculture just so that you can grow a yard, or take a long shower, is the kind of stupidity that has landed California where it is in the first place.
- dmitriy_ko 5y agoWhy doesn't California use a more market-based approach? It could simply decide how much water can be sustainably consumed and then auction-off rights to that amount of water.
- pstrateman 5y agoBecause water rights in California are extremely complicated, many water rights predate California being a state.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Why doesn't California use a more market-based approach? It could simply decide how much water can be sustainably consumed and then auction-off rights to that amount of water. Because it would have to first seize by eminent domain lots of permanently held rights in order to put them into an auction, and the costs of the initial purchases would be prohibitive. In the US, a State can't just up and decide to conduct, say, an annual auction for use of property that someone already permanently owns, and that's how a lot of water rights are.
- simfree 5y agoThe water in aquifers, streams, rivers and lakes should not be considered something you can hold the right to as private property. These are public resources, and in many other places you can own the land below a lake or river, but you do not have a right to divert or impound said water, and the Department of Natural Resources will serve you notice and take corrective action (eg: blowing up your dam, seizing your pumps and destroying your pipe/trench) if you do not comply.
- candiodari 5y agoBut it was, and then sold, by the government to these farmers. And the real issue is, of course, not that they want it back, but that they want it back without paying for it. And people are mad because their water use for lawns is billed very differently, and rationed, because they never purchased the rights to it. So government did something stupid, not paying for it made the problem get delayed, and grow massively, and now it’s critical. The government, especially now that the problem is so much bigger, definitely doesn’t want to pay. “The initial purchases would be cost prohibitive”.