3 ms·
While this is true, the expectations of the US have also overshot. The US is an outlier in terms of square footage in new homes, American homes are very large.
by bobthepanda 5y ago
While this is true, the expectations of the US have also overshot. The US is an outlier in terms of square footage in new homes, American homes are very large. And personally I don't want some 2000 sq ft McMansion because that means all the cooling, heating, cleaning, and maintenance of such a large space that I've only ever seen really used to accumulate lots of stuff.
We don't need to go to extremes (a Parisian studio can go as low as 100 square feet!) but house size in the US has mostly crept up as a function of minimum lot sizes in US zoning.
- kube-system 5y agoThose homes aren’t in cities where space is a concern. They’re in sprawling suburbs where land is highly available. The construction costs of those 2000 square foot homes is cheaper than 1000 square foot on the 25th floor of a building. People in the US have a choice between the two, and they’re largely chosen to put up with a commute from the suburbs in exchange for more space. Those lot sizes aren’t just wasted space. Lower density also translates to more green space, lower noise, fewer shared spaces, etc.
- Ericson2314 5y agoPeople are choosing suburbs based on costs. The aver person has little ability to choose based on any other reason. This is why it's incredibly important that we fix this stuff. Rich environmentalists' "sacrifices" achieve nothing. It is also why I am incredibly sad the current infrastructure bill is slated to fund so much stupid suburbanization.
- kube-system 5y agoThey’re choosing suburbs for value, not cost. There are plenty of apartments available in cities at rents lower than the average suburban mortgage payment. If we want revitalized cities where people want to live, we don’t just need low cost housing, we need high value housing. The middle class didn’t leave cities on cost alone and they’re not going to move back to cities on cost alone.
- throwawayboise 5y agoBut there are many many things you cannot do living in an apartment that you can do with your own home/property. It's not simply a calculation of value in a $/sq-ft sense that people are making.
- kube-system 5y agoYes, that’s part of what I mean by value as opposed to cost.
- Ericson2314 5y agoCities have amenities that are supposed to allow for those same things. Fancier apartments sometimes do too.
- Ericson2314 5y agoSure, value not costs. > There are plenty of apartments available in cities at rents lower than the average suburban mortgage payment. But what is the floor area? Saying people don't need McMansions is not the same as saying additional bedrooms for kids isn't nice. > If we want revitalized cities where people want to live, we don’t just need low cost housing, we need high value housing. It's very easy to tear down walls making bigger units. Focusing on the cost of housing is the key part. Value comes after. Also remember that suburbs and driving is massively subsidize, even separately from the externalizes. It's not fair to expect cities to compete completely on costs without that being fixed. Go read https://www.strongtowns.org/ https://www.strongtowns.org/ for urbanism for small-scale romantics if big cities still sound "just bad".
- kube-system 5y agoI agree with everything here except I’m not sure that value will necessarily result from focusing on cost. I think if you focus on cost alone, you’re going to build poor neighborhoods and jump start a cycle of poverty. I think the key is to build diverse neighborhoods. You want poor, rich, and middle income housing all in the same place. The segregation of incomes is how we got into this mess to begin with.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThe costs are out of whack. Environmental externalities are paid for by everybody instead of the person creating them. We need carbon taxes to fix that problem. This is on top how much zoning craziness distorts the market.
- perl4ever 5y agoI think that discussion about "suburbs" tend not to accomplish much because the word isn't really defined. I mean, in common parlance, but also in the US government I believe that things like the census divide everything into urban and rural. I live within city limits, in a multifamily building. But the edge of the city outside of which is presumably "suburban" is literally a few dozen feet away. Also, my neighborhood has a layout and look that I think a lot of people would consider suburban. No businesses, mostly no sidewalks, mostly a cookie cutter development. On the other hand, it's super quick to go from where I live (by car that is) into the middle of the city where I work, which is kind of against the stereotype of suburbs. It's also much cheaper than the "actual" suburbs, probably because it's part of the city school district.
- Ericson2314 5y agoA suburb is where people's work aren't tied to the land (agriculture, logging, etc.) And virtually all transport is done by car. There, did it. Sounds like your place has some nice benefits, but since you drive everywhere (you mentioned work, and stores not being in the neighborhood, so that's a safe assumption, right?), It's suburban.
- perl4ever 5y agoI'm within easy walking distance of a bus stop. However, the bus goes mostly east and west, rather than north to where I work. I could also technically walk to a convenience store or perhaps a supermarket. It doesn't take that long to walk a mile or two. Point is though, it's clearly not rural, and it's within a recognized city, so any time people are talking about "urban" it includes this sort of setting. It doesn't matter if you think it should be classified as urban, the fact that it is, means that's where the statistics show up indirectly. There is a distinct separation in property value between my neighborhood and surrounding suburbs with single-family housing at double or quadruple the price. Furthermore, as a matter of geometry, any city that is more or less a roundish blob, is going to have more space near the edges than the center. So it seems plausible to me that it's more representative of a city lifestyle. The very center in several cities I've been in is almost completely commercial.
- jjav 5y ago> People are choosing suburbs based on costs. The aver person has little ability to choose based on any other reason. That's quite a wide unsubstantiated generalization. Tons of people have no interest in living in a tiny apartment in a tall building and will happily pay extra to move to the suburbs to avoid that.
- bobthepanda 5y agoIn hot housing markets there is nowhere near enough supply to meet demand. The price per square foot is reflective of what the market will pay, first and foremost. The large cost premium in hot cities suggest that the unmet supply of apartment is much larger in percentage terms than the unmet supply of single family housing. In my area rents are already recovered from their COVID slump and still rising.