3 ms·
It's easy to criticize 'blah blah blah'. But the style of the article is personal testimonial plus character study. It's going to include discursive storytellin
by gojomo 18y ago
It's easy to criticize 'blah blah blah'. But the style of the article is personal testimonial plus character study. It's going to include discursive storytelling, and it's not trying to boil down a diet/lifestyle/person to the fewest possible words. The cheapest form of criticism is to skewer a work for not meeting some ideal it wasn't even aiming for.
DeVany is a very interesting and credible guy with a different spin on eating and training than you'll usually find.
Check out especially his warnings about marathon/endurance running [1] compared to the typical media celebration of marathon running as some ideal of fitness [2].
[1] "Top Ten Reasons Not To Run Marathons", http://www.arthurdevany.com/2005/08/top_ten_reasons.html http://www.arthurdevany.com/2005/08/top_ten_reasons.html
[2] "The Perfect Human", http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/15.01/ultraman.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/15.01/ultraman.html
- ars 18y agoExcept why do I care that the reporter was early to the interview? Why would anyone care? It's not a diary, it's an article about a new diet. Tell me about the diet. You want to add a supplement about the author fine. But I don't need 3 pages of useless text about the author without once mentioning what the diet actually is. Sorry, but there is too much garbage in the world to spend 15 minutes reading all about some dude, and only then discover that the diet is no good for you. First tell me about the diet. Then, if I'm interested tell me about the dude.
- gojomo 18y agoExcept why do I care that the reporter was early to the interview? Why would anyone care? It's personalizing color, and it also lets the author explain how he's seen DeVany "half-naked". You must really hate novels. Not everything is written for an audience with ADD, nor should it be.
- ars 18y agoI love novels - except I wasn't reading a novel. At least I thought I wasn't - this was billed as "The diet that really works". And that's what I was here to read, and then I didn't. You want to write "personal insights about the man who made the diet that really works" no problem. I might even like to read it - but that's not what I was expecting. You say you are writing about a diet, then do so, or change the title.
- DougBTX 18y agoAs eugenejen mentions below, this is an article from the Sunday Times in the Life & Style, Women's section. Perhaps instead of saying "this isn't what I expected, it is crap," you could be a little more aware of the context of the article. It was a fine piece of writing, I enjoyed the short read.
- gojomo 18y agoHeadlines are the last thing written, typically by someone other than the article author. Headlines are space-constrained and compete for attention by pushing a 'hook', rather than providing a perfect summary of what follows. So if you feel misled by an attention-stealing headline, blame the headline, not the article.
- eugenejen 18y agoDon't forget the article was published under "women" category. I think they may actually write like that because women tends to like to learn things with context. (No gender discrimination here. But I really feel there are gender difference in perception and communication) If it is a scientific publication. Your point is right. But take it easy when same material is published on newspaper for general female readers. It is not to their taste. I remembered most of time when I wanted to argue some points with all my girlfriends that I've dated, they remember much better when I said some stories around the point. They usually responded worser when I just tried to cut the crap and strike the point.
- streety 18y agoI've got to give the guy respect for giving references with his arguments but I don't think his sources are sufficient to suggest that marathon running is bad for you. It's a shame he loses much of that respect as we near reason #1 and they get increasingly 'silly'. Let's take #2: "At least four particiants of the Boston Marathon have died of brain cancer in the past 10 years. Purely anecdotal, but consistent with the elevated S100beta counts and TKN-alpha measures. Perhaps also connected to the microthrombi of the endothelium found in marathoners." I'm researching this with google but, "In the United States, the annual incidence of brain cancer generally is 15-20 cases per 100,000 people." http://www.oncologychannel.com/braincancer/index.shtml http://www.oncologychannel.com/braincancer/index.shtml "In 2007 more than 20000 runners completed the race." http://www.bostonmarathon.org/ http://www.bostonmarathon.org/ I can't quickly find numbers for the preceding years, nor how many each year had run it previously, so lets assume the numbers increased linearly over the preceding 10 years to give a total number of runners as 100,000. That, rather conveniently, suggests 15 - 20 incidents of brain cancer should result. Shock result - marathon running prevents brain cancer! #1 is the first runner of the marathon, Phidippides, died. Hopefully I don't need to explain why this one is silly. Some of his other points would be worth further study but I can't find a single point without weaknesses.
- streety 18y agoI've just noticed I'm comparing cases with deaths. Clearly some people will survive brain cancer. The death rate would appear to be 5.6 per 100,000 according to this source neuro-oncology.dukejournals.org/cgi/reprint/6/3/179.pdf It is worth noting that this is the annual rate suggesting that 5 runners of the Boston marathon should have died from brain cancer in the last year alone.
- cujo 18y agoThe obvious problem wiht your retort is, of course, you're assuming that every year, the runners in the BM are new to the race. This isn't true. I'm not saying his reasoning is sound, but your rebuttle isn't either.
- streety 18y ago
- sutro 18y agoI have no problem believing that marathons may be harmful to the human body. The reason I run marathons isn't primarily for the races themselves but rather for the motivation the races provide to get in shape. You can't easily wing it or cram for a marathon (Lord knows I've tried), so the races' looming deadlines provide an escalating urgency to one's workouts. The resulting workouts are fairly short (amateurs rarely run full marathons in training, and only hit high distances near the end), intense, and irregular (ie, increasing over time with rest days interspersed as opposed to the same routine every day) -- qualities which match DeVany's own recommendations for how to exercise as related in the TimesOnline article. For a guy who preaches that one should consider the whole of complex systems, his dismissal of marathons considers only the tip of the iceberg. I believe that the health benefits associated with my training will more than make up for whatever health risks I may face on race day.