7 ms·
NYC mental health response teams show better results than police
- fisherjeff 5y agoNot super surprising – no response at all is often much better than police response in mental health crisis situations.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI think it's a rhetorical and political mistake to tie this effort to police violence and systemic racism. If you say "We're going to have a special mental health response team to deal with suicidal people and the non-violent mentally ill." Who would oppose that? That seems a very reasonable thing to try. On the other hand, if you begin by saying "Because the police are racist murderers..." It just seems like begging for a fight that doesn't need to happen. People who might support the effort will resist it. I think it's the same mistake some people make by saying "Defund the police" rather than "Let's respond to the non-violent mentally ill with trained mental health responders."
- Fogest 5y agoThis is exactly it. People in Canada I often see blindly pushing for this stuff but they don't realize a lot of police departments here already have had these kinds of resources they utilize and have been having success with them before the BLM stuff got popular. But now the BLM stuff surrounding it makes it focused on the wrong goals and creates controversy and drama and it's rather annoying.
- alisonkisk 5y agoIt's a shame that propopents of good ideas need to mollycoddle fragile egos before the ideas can be approved on their merits. Why is "stop killing Black people" the wrong goal?
- Fogest 5y ago> Why is "stop killing Black people" the wrong goal? Because it perpetuates a false narrative that police are killing black people en-masse which is not true. It also creates a narrative that other races, including white people could not also benefit from mental health specific support. It focuses on one specific group rather than focusing on the fact that everybody has the problem. It creates an unneeded divide in people when really it is uncalled for. It could just as easily be focused on everybody. This is why I still think it is silly to focus on one race when it comes to things like these. Because at the end of the day it is all lives that matter when it comes to mental health, not one specific group. When we focus on support for one specific group that is discriminatory. And that is complete crap. Progress should be focused on benefitting everybody, not giving certain groups advantages based on historical disadvantages. We should be moving forward as a society together, not trying to make up for past issues that the majority of the population weren't even alive for.
- LeonB 5y ago> We're going to have a special mental health response team to deal with suicidal people and the non-violent mentally ill." Who would oppose that? When it diverts funding away from mainstream policing then it would be very strongly opposed by police unions. And it does not need simply a lack of opposition. It needs people to actively support it, and be motivated to support it as it requires funding. And there’s a bunch of straw manning in your arguments that is quite distasteful.
- roenxi 5y agoWikipedia suggests [0] that the majority of NYPD officers come from minority backgrounds. Whites are slightly overrepresented in leadership vs. the demographic backdrop of New York. Though that is probably inertia, as they used to be a majority instead of just the largest minority back in the 90s. It seems to be a stretch to say the NYPD could be a hotbed of racism in particular. They look rather diverse. I suppose possibly the argument could be made that black NYPD officers are racist against whites, whites against latinos and latinos against blacks. But from what I've understood that isn't the accusation being made at them. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Police_Department#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Police_Departmen...
- aaron-santos 5y agoThis would be a very good time to break out the systems-level thinking and apply it to racism in policing. In particular, the idea that if individual racism is low implies that racism is also low the composition of those individuals is a fallacy of composition.
- roenxi 5y agoSo, the NYPD is hiring a most of their workforce from minorities, who are then banding together to support systemic racism, because I am making the fallacy of composition? I'll admit my argument here isn't proven with academic rigour, but the NYPD isn't the racist actor in the current narrative.
- 5y ago
- akomtu 5y agoI've been thinking why media and politicians use so radical language. My guess is that moderate language will be seen by their voters as a conspiracy of some sort. You say "mental health responders" but the radical voters read it as "hmm.. by not demanding to defund police he must be secretly supporting police, so he must be a republican and we don't want any of those here". There was an HN post explaining this idea better, why there are no moderate centrists these days: those would be ousted by both hard left and hard right.
- temp8964 5y ago> non-violent mentally ill Is this true though? Many cases involved violent mentally ill.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danielheath 5y agoPolice frequently get called to suicide threats. While threatening to commit suicide is a horrible thing to do, it doesn’t warrant an armed response. Instead of arguing over the edge cases, I suggest pushing for the part of the proposal that’s unambiguously helpful (eg: no armed response without a plausible threat of violence).
- accurrent 5y agoI'm not American. But I used to be firefighter for 2 years. Where I live both firefighters and police respond to suicides. In the 2 years I have attended over 100 suicide calls of various forms (in various stages). In none of them have we ever used an "armed response" unless you consider a bolt cutter/saw a weapon. It does seem to puzzle me why one would want to use weapons in a suicide case.
- throwawaysea 5y agoThe language used by the parent comment is ambiguous. By armed response they mean that the responding police officers carry a gun. I don’t see that as a problem, because you never know what kind of situation they will encounter and what the needs might be.
- danielheath 5y agoI don’t know about you but when someone with a gun shows up, my motivation begins and ends at “get rid of this person”. I am not going to have a productive conversation, because I don’t know what kind of situation I will encounter.
- geofft 5y ago> If you say "We're going to have a special mental health response team to deal with suicidal people and the non-violent mentally ill." Who would oppose that? A lot of people! One of the standard arguments is, mentally ill people are by definition unpredictable, so you can't classify then as "non-violent," so all responders must be armed and trained in the use of force for at least their own protection if not the protection of others. Note that this is the actual argument as to why traffic cops are armed in the US. Erratic drivers are considered unpredictable, and anyone in the US could easily have a gun, so there isn't a special team for handling "non-violent" traffic offenders. It's the regular cops with their regular authorization to use deadly force. Or put another way - if it were such an obviously good idea to the whole political spectrum, why hasn't it happened before? "The police are racist murderers" is, first of all, objectively true and facts don't care about your feelings, but more importantly, it's objectively better rhetoric. Problems with inappropriate police responses have been around for a long while - and, unsurprisingly, they affect whites too (Ryan Whitaker was killed by officers investigating a noise complaint, and six-year-old Jeremy Mardis was killed by officers after chasing the car he was in the back seat of). But there hasn't been any real movement to change things. Meanwhile, a whole lot of local governments are making good and meaningful changes thanks to people saying things like "The police are racist murderers" and "Defund the police." So while you may not like the slogans, they definitely seem to be working.
- betwixthewires 5y agoYour definition of objectivity on both counts seems to be subjective. If someone said "black people kill each other for crack corners, facts don't care about your feelings" you'd at the very least say they were painting with a broad brush. I'd agree with you. There's a difference between a race and a profession, sure, but you're generalizing a diverse group of people. And is it objectively better rhetoric? Objectively? Empirically I see it has a very divisive effect, much more prominent than any positive effect you can find examples of. But say it is effective, that's more important to you than it's truthfulness? Do you want to live in a world where we pretend to believe lies because they're effective at achieving some end? I'm all about reigning in the police, cutting budgets, cutting staff, whatever, not because they're racist (as a group they're not) but because they're goons for the state, it is their job to go sniff your butthole and ask you what you've been doing under implied threat of violence. That's objectively better rhetoric because it's true, and it's all inclusive because they do this to all of us equally.
- endisneigh 5y agoThis comment is very strange when you consider that the only reason there's even traction in switching to mental health professionals is specifically because of the injustices inflicted on specific groups and the ensuing protests. I also find it amusing that the tone of your post is that you rightly don't want there to be pointless fights and denounce said pointless fights, but also lament poor language (e.g. "...racist murders"...) while simultaneously using it yourself. Seems pointless given the article in question doesn't use the language you are using nor does it make the claims you're hypothesizing.
- Fogest 5y ago> switching to mental health professionals is specifically because of the injustices inflicted on specific groups and the ensuing protests. That is completely untrue. As I said in my comment there are many countries who have police departments who have enacted special mental health professionals prior to BLM being a thing as they saw a general need for it in their community. Not because one specific minority group called for it. Instead it is because everybody benefited from it.
- endisneigh 5y agoWe’re talking about the United States so your mention of other countries is completely irrelevant. The police forces of other countries are run completely differently nor do they necessarily suffer from the same issues as the ones in the USA.
- Fogest 5y ago> The police forces of other countries are run completely differently No they are not. That's like saying you're not allowed to compare between other American states because different states run their police departments completely differently. You're just making up arbitrary rules to stipple discussion.
- endisneigh 5y ago
- asaddhamani 5y agoThis is not surprising. The police are not really interested in helping people, rather just blindly enforcing the law, and let's not even talk about prejudices. If we tried to help people instead of chastise them, we would be a much more utopian civilisation. Happy to see experiments being done by governments in this regard.
- temp8964 5y ago> The police are not really interested in helping people, rather just blindly enforcing the law This general assertion is not true. It really depends on where do you live. In safe neighborhoods/towns, Police are usually very nice and helpful. In some bad inner city neighborhoods, Police are more aggressive.
- FredPret 5y agoI suppose their mood is affected by how likely it is people in the area will shoot at them
- vlunkr 5y ago> just blindly enforcing the law They are law enforcers after all, you don't get mad at coders for writing the code they were assigned. Snark aside, broad generalizations like this don't help the conversation. I would guess most cops do want to help people, and they do in many ways. Of course it's not a perfect system, and I'm also happy to see experiments like this.
- sam345 5y ago>The police are not really interested in helping people, rather just blindly enforcing the law, and let's not even talk about prejudices. Broad generalization based on a few bad apples is the definition of prejudice and fueling more prejudice is not exactly helpful. Many police choose that career because they have been victims of crime or known victims. I've personally witnessed police help young, old, black and white in situations that have nothing to do with enforcing the law. And when enforcing the law the vast majority of times the enforcement protects others from further robbery, assault, domestic abuse, rape, murder, property destruction, car accidents, etc. Good police far outnumber the bad actors.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoSpeaking of mental health. Many of the people that have been arrested for Jan 6th, are currently held in 23 hour solitary confinement and likely will be there until 2022, since so many cases will be delayed due to how many people have been arrested. The UNs Mandela rules dictate that being in solitary for more than 15 days is torture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement Since those arrested are political prisoners, they fall under the UN umbrella. The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners https://www.unodc.org/documents/justice-and-prison-reform/Nelson_Mandela_Rules-E-ebook.pdf https://www.unodc.org/documents/justice-and-prison-reform/Ne...
- betwixthewires 5y agoOf course it is. Cops are people who's job it is to begin criminal prosecution. "Protect and serve" it says on the side of a vehicle with a built in cage.
- TimTheTinker 5y ago... which is very helpful to have when someone is committing violent crime. I for one am glad there's police presence in my mid size town (61k).
- void_mint 5y agoIn this thread we aren't talking about violent crime though. We're talking about mental health.
- TimTheTinker 5y agoWe're talking about police and their usefulness as well. Preventing and prosecuting violent crime is where police are most indispensable.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoIt would be much more helpful if they were obligated to either protect or serve. As it is, they have no obligation to do either one. "To protect and serve" is literally nothing more than a marketing slogan, originally used by the LAPD. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia https://www.lapdonline.org/history_of_the_lapd/content_basic_view/1128 https://www.lapdonline.org/history_of_the_lapd/content_basic...
- TimTheTinker 5y agoI think that's partly a false dichotomy. They serve primarily by protecting.
- 5y ago
- subroutine 5y ago> In the first month of the pilot: 911 operators routed approximately 25% of mental health emergency calls (138 calls) to B-HEARD teams. In the coming months, this number is projected to grow to approximately 50% of all 911 mental health calls. The remaining calls will either involve suspected violence or imminent harm, or an individual who requires transport to a hospital for physical or mental healthcare. > A New York City pilot program that dispatches mental health specialists and paramedics instead of police for certain nonviolent emergency calls has resulted in more people accepting assistance and fewer people sent to the hospital Are fewer people being sent to the hospital overall, or do B-HEARD calls result in fewer people sent to the hospital than police calls? The later would be unsurprising because of the particular calls they are being routed. Also B-HEARD only operates during daytime hours. I like the idea of this program but still would like to see an apples to apples comparison wrt. the stats. https://mentalhealth.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/B-HEARD-First-Month-Data.pdf https://mentalhealth.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/202...
- sam345 5y agoThis reads more like a PR piece for a particular viewpoint and attempt to influence the debate with very preliminary and shallow data. Very scant evidence to support the headline and no details on what's behind the percentages. They are basing the conclusion on one months data in one section of NYC. 95% accepted care from the new unit v. 82% for traditional 911 with police. Are the types of cases the same? Did both groups include violent incidents? If not, have the police numbers been adjusted to carve out the violent cases? Why is accepting care a measure of success, and are the incidents resolved or will they be repeated and/or escalate in the future? E.g.., if the alleged spouse batterer gets a counseling session rather than jail time will it prevent the incident from occurring again ?
- sloshnmosh 5y agoWe have a Crisis Response Team in my city and it has been blessing. I believe they are actually part of the fire department or under their leadership but I could be wrong. The most important thing about the crisis response team is time and patience. The team is trained in descalation and are able to spend hours with a person in crisis. They will sit and listen to the person, give them rides if need be and also make contact with people even if they aren’t in crisis to build trust and reliability. Most of the time that’s all that someone really needs is just someone that will take the time to really listen. I will also add that there is a definite need for a police presence in my city as well.