4 ms·
> what the USSR did between their revolution in 1917 and, oh, somewhere around 1975 was completely amazing Tens of millions died of starvation, more died in wa
by wolverine876 5y ago
> what the USSR did between their revolution in 1917 and, oh, somewhere around 1975 was completely amazing
Tens of millions died of starvation, more died in wars, more suffered brutal oppression, forced relocation, and had no freedom to live their lives or even speak their mind, not to mention widespread poverty. What was accomplished for those people?
We're not talking about 'methods', but outcomes. The outcome is all those people dying and suffering. You found a silver lining? Wow. Democracies provided much more prosperity (how about just a reliable food supply) without the nightmarish horrors. 'Much of my family died, ended up in brutal prisons, were forced to relocate, suffered brutal oppression - but it's all good because I have some material goods I didn't have 60 years ago.'
The former USSR is still well behind the democracies.
> you could try to argue that they only succeeded at immense cost to both human lives and political freedom - I might not even disagree
These are the justifications of people who want power over others, it's well-worn propaganda: - 'I am needed to solve the problem, and my self-serving sadism is necessary'. You have examples, worldwide, of countries doing more economically, without the horrors, through freedom. Government leaders, chosen by the people, who do things without killing their population or oppressing them. What a joke.
If these brutal dictators are so good for the population, why not hold elections? Who decides that they are good?
> China over the last 35 years is likely a similar example.
China did it through liberalization, economic and (until somewhat recently) political, starting under Deng Xiaoping.
And Taiwan and Hong Kong, which embraced true freedom, did far more.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI don't disagree with any of your description of the negatives about what the USSR did. I regret that the way I worded this definitely appears that I was somehow giving the USSR a pass on all this. The question is whether or not those aspects of the USSR's "development" were critical/integral to their industrialization and modernization or not. If they were, then I think that makes the price of those changes in the USSR clearly too high. If they were not, then they are terrible, terrible things, happening alongside something quite remarkable. I don't know enough about the details of the USSR during that time period to know how integral they may have been. I also don't know enough about the history of South Korea to know if their development is comparable to what happened in the USSR or not. My vague impression is that they were starting from a much better (non-Tsarist) place, but I could have that wrong.