3 ms·
It, in fact, is their money. There was a time in American history when income taxes were not a thing and still we got along. It’s not a bad thing to pool money
by mc32 5y ago
It, in fact, is their money. There was a time in American history when income taxes were not a thing and still we got along.
It’s not a bad thing to pool money for common causes, but to claim it isn’t their or our money is kind of odd.
- nicoburns 5y agoIt's only their money because the economic system assigns it to them. If the economic system was different then it wouldn't be theirs.
- mc32 5y agoThat's like saying it's only their house because we allow them to own a house. Or, those are their children because we allow them to keep their children and not assign them to the state. It's as if in lawless lands with tribal warfare suddenly people don't earn a living.
- nicoburns 5y agoChildren are a bit different because they are actually created by the parents (and the personal relationship is of course super-important for the child's development). But generic economic resources: yes. Ownership of pretty much anything including houses relies on social acceptance of the rules of private property ownership and market value. And that social acceptance can be conditional on things like taxes to fund social goods. If you don't want to play by the democratically determined rules, then you shouldn't expect the state to defend your property.
- mc32 5y agoI think that property-children is on a continuum. When you have raiding parties and tribal warfare, children were taken as slaves. From that PoV then children are in the same basket where they are protected by the norms of society, same as property. Saying you only own your money or house because we allow you to is like saying the only reason you don't get raped or killed is because we have a structure of laws against it. Yes?
- jes5199 5y agoyes true. property, especially real estate, is a legal construct created by the state. In older eras this was more explicit, property existed “at the pleasure of the Queen” or whatever. Now we rely on a nebulous social consensus reinforced by the courts and legislature. Money is only a token within this game - it has no reality other than the rules. The rules are whatever society decides they are. There is not a “real” ownership that the rules are interfering with.
- mc32 5y agoBut that's true for any rights. The right to feel safe, the right to safety and not be harmed, raped or killed. Without society, sure, real-estate, personal safety are out the window and we could expect expropriation, rape and death.
- frockington1 5y agoIn the US property is also governed by ones rights to defend your property. We have castle doctrine for a reason
- defaultname 5y agoYou have "Castle doctrine" because it was deemed politically beneficial to a politician at some point. That same politician that would happily turn your neighborhood into a strip mall through eminent domain if that was beneficial for them. You have banks literally foreclosing on the wrong homes, or through simple errors, making people homeless in the process, and those same politicians are "so sad". If you're in a Western nation and you "make" money, it is very much a partnership with the state, and your ability to "make" money would very likely disappear without the state. For someone to go on about "their" money has no correlation with actual reality, and I'd encourage them to ply their trade in Somalia. I'm sure the income tax rates are great.
- mc32 5y agoThis is kind of circular reasoning. You might as well say you are only alive because the state lets you live. It's my life as much as money is my money. Yes, they can be taken away.
- minikites 5y agoThe first US income tax was in 1861, I find it hard to believe "we got along" when we held a significant portion of the population as literal slaves.
- mc32 5y agoThat's very true for the south. Yet, the north still got on and did even better than the south. Never the less, you can go to any other place which didn't have slaves and they still got on without income taxes. And, if you go to parts of the middle east where slavery exists today, income taxes have not prevented it, so it's beside the point.
- titzer 5y agoIt's your money like it's your water and your oxygen. Build some big tanks on your "property" and put machine gun nests around it to defend it. Everything in modern society is part of a social contract that includes thousands of people working to keep it from devolving into anarchist chaos of violence and subjugation.
- mc32 5y agoThat's understood. But I have as much right to my money as I have a right not to be raped. Society provides for all this in our social contract. We can choose to include income taxes in that, but we don't have to. We didn't have them initially as a republic.
- titzer 5y agoWe can "choose to include them" until we discover that it is unviable to fund the necessary services and find out society is completely dysfunctional without them. As expat returning to the US after 7 years, it's clear that US is headed in the wrong direction because it has made decades of poor choices, particularly w.r.t. taxation and long-term investments, and is sliding rapidly into dysfunction. And the confusion that has led to those poor choices seems pretty well-summarized in your first comment.
- mc32 5y agoI'm not against taxes. There are things that can only be executed as a group. What I am against is the notion that it's not mine. That by default it belongs to the government and it's only out of the goodness of their heart they allow me to keep some. It's the other way around. We form a government and we decide what we want to contribute to it with taxes. We decide we need a school, a road, engage in war, etc., and we contribute to those efforts via tax contributions. I don't want to contribute to never ending wars, I don't want to contribute to subsidizing companies that export jobs, etc. I want money to train inner city kids, rural kids, not some reconstruction in some place that has much less immediate effect on us.