4 ms·
> Sure you could, even though MS-DOS wasn't UNIX, and using pipelines meant writing temporary data into the current directory. Assuming you're commenting on th
by hnlmorg 5y ago
> Sure you could, even though MS-DOS wasn't UNIX, and using pipelines meant writing temporary data into the current directory.
Assuming you're commenting on the GP's point about UNIX pipelines, I think your comment here is a little disingenuous. Akin to that famous HN comment mocking the then start up Dropbox saying "you can just use FTP...." while completely missing the reason Dropbox would then go on to be successful for.
> In fact that was one of the reasons ARJ got more love than zip, given its flexibility and ability to split archives across floppies.
Did ARJ actually get more love than ZIP or is that just your anecdotal recall of the era. I seem to recall the opposite with ZIP being far more prevolent. Remember ZIP also supported splitting archives over multiple floppies.
Interestingly ARJ's website is still live and not been updated in 10 years[1]. It might be ugly by today's standards but man is it better designed for getting the core information out. We've definitely lost something when sites became more about presentation and less about information.
[1] http://www.arjsoftware.com/arj.htm http://www.arjsoftware.com/arj.htm
- tored 5y agoWhat I can remember from the 90s in Sweden the most common archive formats for spanning multiple 3 1/2 inch floppies was ARJ or RAR. ZIP existed but was uncommon in comparison. I think it wasn’t so much about the qualities about the zip format itself rather that WinZip software wasn’t as good compared to WinRAR. ARJ was command line, at least that is how I used it, it was well documented and easy to use. It may have been that the zip format was more common in the DOS 5 1/4 inch floppy days because zip (1989) existed prior to both both ARJ (1992) and RAR (1993)
- inglor_cz 5y agoSo was in Czechia during the DOS times. ARJ was almost synonymous with compression. Some people used RAR. The advent of Windows was when ZIP started to push them out.
- pjmlp 5y agoNot disingenuous at all, MS-DOS CLI was good enough for most pipeline use cases, and if you really wanted a more UNIX like experience you could always buy 4DOS, the Dropbox of MS-DOS shell utilities. Back in the MS-DOS days, you couldn't use zip across floppies unless you bought the commercial Pkzip version, the shareware one did not offer it. Whereas ARJ offered all what pkzip was capable of, for free, and every high school kid with PC at home got it on their floppies collection.
- jhgb 5y ago> the Dropbox of MS-DOS shell utilities I'm not sure I understand the Dropbox analogy. In what way was 4DOS "the Dropbox of MS-DOS shell utilities"?
- hnlmorg 5y ago> Not disingenuous at all, MS-DOS CLI was good enough for most pipeline use cases, and if you really wanted a more UNIX like experience you could always buy 4DOS, the Dropbox of MS-DOS shell utilities. It literally is disingenuous for the reasons I'd already outlined. And then saying "but you could always install this other lesser known DOS-like command shell" doesn't exactly help your claim. Sure, with a little effort pretty much anything is possible in IT (that's a large part of the reason I was inspired to work in IT growing up). But my point was if MS-DOS requires a new command shell or other hacks then your whole argument of it supporting pipelines is rather stretched. Literally the whole point of pipelines is as a quick and common way of passing information between programs and nothing you've details is quick nor common. But you'll come along and find some other tedious argument because that is what you do.... > Back in the MS-DOS days, you couldn't use zip across floppies unless you bought the commercial Pkzip version, the shareware one did not offer it. But the file format did. > Whereas ARJ offered all what pkzip was capable of, for free, and every high school kid with PC at home got it on their floppies collection. Every high school kid would have had the commercial version of pkzip too -- albeit not legally. The amount of pirated software that would get swapped around in the 80s and 90s was pretty ridiculous. In fairness to you though, I guess the preference of ARJ vs ZIP is always going to be an unprovable subjective point. I can't go back in time to prove your community of friends used one over the other any more than your anecdotal evidence being proof of my group's, or any others, preferences. And to be fair, it was a long time ago now and memory is fallible. I remember using pkzip a lot to package software I was writing but I might just have forgotten about all those times I used ARJ.