2 ms·
> Musk has said in an interview that the marginal cost of a reused Falcon 9 launch is $15 million. Musk has said many things in interviews that have little to
by tsimionescu 5y ago
> Musk has said in an interview that the marginal cost of a reused Falcon 9 launch is $15 million.
Musk has said many things in interviews that have little to do with reality. Even if that number is true launch costs are more than the rocket itself. Even if we accepted the number, to make economic sense, they would have to get more value from 60 satellites than the $35M of profit they would make on each launch if they were launching commercialy.
> But the goal for starship is $2m per launch. Let's assume that is bullshit and go for $10M instead, and only 300 satellites per launch.
Prices for rockets similar to Starship are in the $150-200M range, so that is more the ballpark I expect from Starship, if it does fly. Perhaps it can go down to as low as 75-100M range, half the current cost of similar rockets! $10M is fantasy.
Not to mention, they are already being accused of breaking environmental regulations and other problems, so it wouldn't be surprising if launch costs actually go up if they are to maintain compliance.
- tigershark 5y agoThere is no other fully reusable rocket similar to starship (or even different, it doesn’t simply exist). Please stop inventing numbers and lying. And for your information starship already fled and landed and there is an orbital launch attempt likely in the next 2-4 months.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI'm talking about the costs for launching a rocket of similar size. And note that for Falcon 9, the difference in price for new rockets VS reused boosters is 62M -> 50M, not an almost hundred fold decrease.
- tsimionescu 5y agoReply, because I can't edit: so far, only the second stage stage of Starship has been flown. The SuperHeavy booster has not yet been flown at all,nevermind successfully landing, and ditto for the two-stage system.
- ricardobeat 5y ago> Prices for rockets similar to Starship are in the $150-200M range, so that is more the ballpark I expect from Starship Why would they even develop this new vehicle if it turns out more expensive than Falcon 9, or Falcon 9 Heavy? That would not make any sense. Plus those rockets are not reusable. They have already achieved a reduction in price/kg by at least 10x with Falcon, see page 11 here: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20170009968/downloads/20170009968.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20170009968/downloads/20... > $10M is fantasy $2M is the fantasy, I already added 400% to account for skepticism. Starship is not a conventional launch vehicle, it's designed for full reusability with a turnaround time measured in hours (vs the current 14-50 days for a Falcon 9 refurb), like an airplane. Land, refuel, safety checks, fly again.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Why would they even develop this new vehicle if it turns out more expensive than Falcon 9, or Falcon 9 Heavy? That would not make any sense. Plus those rockets are not reusable. They are making a bigger rocket and making it reusable. The bigger the rocket, the more expensive the launch. For Starship the price per ton should be smaller than for Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy, but that doesn't mean it should be expected to be cheaper in absolute terms than much smaller rockets. > $2M is the fantasy, I already added 400% to account for skepticism. You're still talking about a price that would be a hundred times better per ton than any other rocket in history. Allow me to be extremely skeptical, please. Musk's arbitrary promises do not set a benchmark for me - he has been known to lie through his teeth about things like hyperloop, FSD, Neuralink, Starship earth to earth, and timelines in general. And on the same note, what Starship is theoretically designed to do and what it will actually do when it is actually deployed may be significantly different things.