5 ms·
You are being downvoted, but you are right that on the margin paying people _not_ to work does have an impact. But I say on the margin, because it's not 100% o
by eru 5y ago
You are being downvoted, but you are right that on the margin paying people _not_ to work does have an impact.
But I say on the margin, because it's not 100% of the story.
It's not easy to design a system that provides for the needy, doesn't cost too much, and doesn't give undue incentives to become/stay needy.
- alex_young 5y agoMaybe the downvotes are from some of the 12 million people the OP said ‘chose’ to be unemployed
- PhileinSophia 5y agoI'm not saying this to be funny, I fully intend this to be taken seriously, the solution is to follow the principle of justice. The "needy" have no claim on the output of the productive. There is no free lunch, there is no claim to the unearned. The solution is to get rid of welfare entirely, on principle. Anything less leads to this mess eventually.
- hug 5y agoWhat is "the principle of justice", exactly? If you're talking about Rawls' principles of justice, you've completely misunderstood the source text. If you're talking about something else... well, I'd be interested in hearing what it is, although I'm not holding my breath for it to be any good. As to the latter half of your comment, society has a claim on the output of the members of that society, given that the entire operation is built that way. Society presents you with opportunities that you may not otherwise have. Stated conversely, the expectation is that the opportunities that one might not otherwise have are given to them -- the very definition of welfare. To do otherwise is merely to try to pull the ladder up behind you, not some great moral ideal.
- PhileinSophia 5y agoNo I don't mean Rawls. Justice, in this context, means giving to each man what he deserves. This includes not punishing men who don't deserve to be punished. "Society" has no claim on the output of the members of society. Actually, there is no such thing as society above and beyond "the members of society." What you're claiming is that "the members of society" have a claim on "the members of society," but obviously it doesn't manifest itself in a just way otherwise you could only claim what you deserve, or in other words you wouldn't claim anything from anyone else without mutual agreement. What your statement really means is that one group of people in society "the needy" have a claim on another group "the productive." As a productive "member of society" you are forced at the point of a gun (don't pay your taxes, then defend yourself from being arrested) to support the most worthless scum on earth as long as he has the social grace of being "needy." Need does not produce food, need does not build houses -- those are productive efforts -- but need is the ultimate claim on the life and labor of all the productive members of society. If you want to help the needy so much, I will not stop you, please feel free to spend every last penny you have supporting them -- but leave me out of it. I have a right to live my life as much as they have a right to squander theirs.
- lovich 5y ago> No I don't mean Rawls. Justice, in this context, means giving to each man what he deserves. Yo, we took an informal vote and it looks like everyone agrees that businesses don’t “deserve” cheap labor.
- hug 5y agoWith regards to the "principles of justice", your definition of justice is awful: It doesn't line up with any accepted dictionary or academic definition of the term. It lines up really nicely with the objectivist movement, though, which is pretty widely derided as hot garbage. Anyhow, even if I agreed with your concept of "justice", your definition of society is also wonky, if you imagine that it can only be defined by the sum of its current constituents. Society does not consist of only your contemporaries, and is not made up only of the efforts of those who are currently contributing. You, as a member of whatever society you are member of, benefit from the contributions of the members of society who have come before you. To some degree, you also suffer from the mistakes of those before you as well. The society you are a member of gives you a great many affordances, some of which you are able to benefit from more than others due to your circumstance, and some of which you do not benefit from at all. If you believe that you have not benefited from the society you live in, at the expense of others, you need to think on it a little longer.
- Frost1x 5y ago>The "needy" have no claim on the output of the productive. Then the needy have no need to participate in, support, and follow the rules of society and might as well support principles of anarchy. Why should they bother with this system they have no chance of succeeding in? When we decided to form societies and governments, we already decided we were going to work together to help each other out--all this social contract stuff. The increasingly extreme stages of capitalism we see now has instead recreated an abstract form of survival of the fittest in economics. This has slowly broken the social contract that gave rise to people agreeing to join and participate in societies to begin with. Many are struggling for basic needs, not just wants. Everything is about how much money and capital you can roll up. If this gets too extreme, for the bulk of the population who aren't doing well (those who have no claim on the "productive") in this abstracted form of survivalism, why not just push for anarchy and revert back to lawlessness and the non-abstracted survival of the fittest? What do the needy have to gain to follow this arbitrary abstract system they've lost in? They might have a chance of becoming a king in a different structure so they will support other options. If you get enough people who think like this, you will see major changes in government or perhaps complete collapses of societial structures. Welfare needs to exist, we need to provide for those who can't provide for themselves. If we don't, we risk massive social instability because only the winners will have any sort of incentive to participate. Plus there's, I don't know, being human mixed in there too (maybe it's just me but I feel everyone should have some basic support). Capitalism can only exist if you can provide the stable societal structure for it to exist within, for property to accumulate, for property rights to be granted, honored, and enforced. For that to happen you need to make sure the poorest participants have some interest in participating in your society and not rejecting it outright. I suppose force is another option if you like authoritarian systems.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoI think you grossly overestimate how much money unemployment insurance schemes actually pay out. It's certainly far from anything that creates an "incentive" to avoid work or creating a moral-hazard as you suggest. It's also very time-limited, you can't make claims for more than a few consecutive months at a time (depending on your state). Unemployment insurance serves a valuable role in giving people (barely enough) means to look for new employment - which can consume a lot of time - without needing to immediately seek new employment outside of their area of expertise and thus damage their chances of getting a new job in a field that suits them, and if a job suits someone then it suits everyone because it means someone is capitalising on their potential. Wage-slavery is not how any employment system should work.
- PhileinSophia 5y ago"wage-slavery" is not a rational idea at all. By the very nature of your existence you have to eat, drink, sleep somewhere, etc. What's "forcing" you into "slavery" is your own life as a human being. That's obviously not a proper way to describe the situation. The employer that's giving you a wage is giving you a means of survival, you are free to refuse it and pay the consequences. They have no moral obligation to take the shirt off their back to cover yours.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThe abolitionist and former slave Frederick Douglass had this to say on the subject[1]: > experience demonstrates that there may be a slavery of wages only a little less galling and crushing in its effects than chattel slavery, and that this slavery of wages must go down with the other According to Wikipedia[1]: > Douglass went on to speak about these conditions as arising from the unequal bargaining power between the ownership/capitalist class and the non-ownership/laborer class within a compulsory monetary market: "No more crafty and effective devise for defrauding the southern laborers could be adopted than the one that substitutes orders upon shopkeepers for currency in payment of wages. It has the merit of a show of honesty, while it puts the laborer completely at the mercy of the land-owner and the shopkeeper" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_slavery#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_slavery#History
- azth 5y agoCheck out Islam's Zakat laws, they're exactly that.
- eru 5y agoCould you elaborate? According to Wikipedia Zakat is basically a tax on wealth (not income!); the funds are supposed to go to various needy / worthy people, but it doesn't mention anything about unemployment. Anything I'm missing that you want to point out?
- azth 5y agoSure. Zakat is a form of "wealth tax" if you will. For money above a certain minimum amount held for a lunar year, 2.5% of it is to be given to certain individuals (there are several categories of such people mentioned in the Quran and Hadith). It's superior to an income tax model, which many people today are complaining about. Taxation in the US and Europe is 40% or more, crazy. Zakat on produce (fruits and veggies), and cattle each have a different way of calculation. As far as unemployment goes, if the unemployed individual falls into one of the categories of people that deserve Zakat, then he will get it, it's quite straightforward and very fair. Actually, an individual may be employed and still deserve Zakat. This way, we ensure that the lower class of people are lifted up, while not overburdening society with insanely high tax rates.
- eru 5y agoThanks for explaining. Economists have also looked into the effects of wealth taxes. Taxes specifically on the value of land held enjoy broad academic support: land is hard to hide or smuggle out of the country, and its supply is fixed. > As far as unemployment goes, if the unemployed individual falls into one of the categories of people that deserve Zakat, then he will get it, it's quite straightforward and very fair. Actually, an individual may be employed and still deserve Zakat. Yes, that's what I alluded to: making unemployment the condition to get assistance, gives a certain (perhaps small) disincentive to employment. Of course, making being needy the condition instead of being unemployed, gives a certain incentive to staying needy. Traditionally communities regulated this via social mores and standards.