4 ms·
It’s obvious that healthy people that live shorter are better for the ‘economy’ but clearly humanity doesn’t live to optimize for the economy. If we did, we wo
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
It’s obvious that healthy people that live shorter are better for the ‘economy’ but clearly humanity doesn’t live to optimize for the economy. If we did, we would be fighting obesity with 10x the seriousness of how we fight COVID.
- maerF0x0 5y agobasically anything that wasnt a long term compounding investment would be illegal... Obvious things like smoking and vaping, but maybe even time wasters like social media (you could be learning something...) Luckily human life is more than just economy (as expressed in GDP) optimization.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ohazi 5y agoThere is no cohesive "humanity" with any sort of desire or ability to optimize for "the economy." Individuals optimize for their own (often short-term) economic benefit. That's it. The corporate overlords at ACME don't care about fighting obesity, because there are more than enough non-obese workers for them to exploit, and they don't want to cannibalize their highly profitable line of products that obese people need (i.e. insulin). Governments are composed of individuals, and the structures we have to hold these individuals accountable to their constituents are weak, so they still end up using their levers of power for their own gain, and for the gain of their corporate sponsors (also often short-term). Despite ~70 year lifespans, it seems that most of the population can't even be bothered to optimize for medium-term outcomes. This isn't going to change just because we invent a magic pill that lets you live youthfully till ~150. The problem isn't lifespan, the problem is that humanity is innately selfish and short-sighted. If this can't be fixed, we are completely fucked.
- Ericson2314 5y ago> Individuals optimize for their own (often short-term) economic benefit. That's it. Don't go to too far with this sort of atomistic analysis. Large firms are better at enforcing coordination than "society at-large" or other groupings. The fact that at different scales the coordination is markedly different has a huge affect. We're not an "economy of households" as the orthodox macro might have one model.
- ohazi 5y ago> Large firms are better at enforcing coordination than "society at-large" or other groupings. The "large firms" that I'm familiar with are cesspools of political infighting, gamesmanship, and backstabbing. People in positions of power at these firms use their influence to achieve their own goals, often at the expense of the firm and its employees. The counterexamples to this are so singularly rare that they are the exception that proves the rule.
- WalterBright 5y agoThis is why larger companies tend to fail rather than growing to take over the world. There's another recent HN topic about how IBM's size prevented it from competing successfully in the PC market: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27912138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27912138
- Ericson2314 5y agoIt's still miles above the e.g. non-interaction of neighbors in the same cookie cutter subdivision. The fact that people fight over how to divy up a budget vs have completely separate revenue and accounts says a lot, despite all the stuff you talk about.
- WalterBright 5y ago> humanity is innately selfish and short-sighted. If this can't be fixed, we are completely fucked. The communists tried pretty hard to do that, and just made things much worse.
- eitland 5y agoThis is an incredibly important fact that is often downplayed. We remember the Inquisition and the Vikings but they are small fry compared to Communists (and Nazis). I'm not saying Communists are inherently evil - most of them are well meaning I think - but almost every single time it has been tried it has ended in genocide! The one single exception I am aware of is the Israeli Kibbutz system. Edit: communism has killed more people than nazism, probably because most people realize nazism is more or less pure evil while communism looks nice (edit:) on paper.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe Kibbutzen don't work, either. The Israeli government taxes the capitalist businesses in order to subsidize the deficits of the Kibbutzen.
- nwatson 5y agoWhat's the cost burden to Israel of the Kibbutzen vs the cost of supporting the ultra-conservative religious groups that don't serve in the military and rely (presumably) more heavily on welfare and other social subsidies?
- eitland 5y agoYou are probably right. And that is a good point too, it fails economically too. My original point was only that the Kibbutzen didn't end up massacring their inhabitants like almost every other communist experiment.
- CRConrad 5y agoOnly their neighbours.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- majormajor 5y agoThe linked abstract claims the opposite: "We show that a slowdown in aging that increases life expectancy by 1 year is worth US$38 trillion, and by 10 years, US$367 trillion." Is saying the opposite is just "obvious" enough of a rebuttal?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 5y agoA slowdown in aging is a ‘healthy person’ being given more time.
- epicureanideal 5y agoI'm not sure that's true. We invest a lot of money in making people productive at their jobs, basically 0-25, and then they only work another 40 years after that. If they could work another 60-80 years instead, the return on investment is much better.
- cptaj 5y agoI think he means under the current life expectancy and quality of life in the final decades. He probably means those final decades are completely unproductive and taxing on the whole economy, so a productive person dying just before becoming unproductive would be optimal. Naturally, if you give people more productive years then it changes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwkeep 5y agoIt's strange. Obesity is our biggest preventable health problem, and it gets almost no attention in the media or by public officials. We heard endlessly from health officials and news media personalities to wash our hands, stay indoors, wear a mask, get vaccinated, but nothing about eating healthier, eating less, exercising more? "Obesity steals more years than diabetes, tobacco, high blood pressure and high cholesterol -- the other top preventable health problems that cut Americans' lives short, according to researchers who analyzed 2014 data." https://www.webmd.com/diabetes/news/20170424/the-top-5-conditions-that-shorten-americans-lives----and-are-preventable https://www.webmd.com/diabetes/news/20170424/the-top-5-condi... "Obesity is associated with nearly 1 in 5 US deaths, according to a study published online August 15 in the American Journal of Public Health." https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/809516 https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/809516 It should also be part of the climate change discussion: "Overall, being obese is associated with about 20% more greenhouse gas emissions (carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide) than being a normal weight" https://www.webmd.com/diet/obesity/news/20191220/growing-obesity-rates-may-contribute-to-climate-change https://www.webmd.com/diet/obesity/news/20191220/growing-obe...
- kiba 5y agoIt's strange. Obesity is our biggest preventable health problem, and it gets almost no attention in the media or by public officials. We heard endlessly from health officials and news media personalities to wash our hands, stay indoors, wear a mask, get vaccinated, but nothing about eating healthier, eating less, exercising more? Because it's been going on in the background so long, that it became part of the background. Also, it's not like it's not noticed by public officials. You hear all the time in recommendations and guidelines we should lose weight and get more exercise. That said, I would also note that current public health policy is basically a failure in that we largely failed to move the needle regarding the obesity pandemic or getting the recommended exercise dose.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> recommendations and guidelines we should lose weight and get more exercise We also don't understand it, not well at least. You can't go to Walgreens, get a shot and be cured of obesity.