4 ms·
"the WTP at birth for the initial 1-year increase in remaining LE from 78.9 to 79.9 years via rectangularization is US$118,100, the WTP at age 60 for the first
by giantg2 5y ago
"the WTP at birth for the initial 1-year increase in remaining LE from 78.9 to 79.9 years via rectangularization is US$118,100, the WTP at age 60 for the first 1-year increase in remaining LE from 21.7 to 22.7 years through lifespan improvement is US$257,700."
Who the fuck did they get to determine willingness? Most people don't have the money to spend. If it takes you years of extra work to pay for a one year life extension, why not just retire years earlier and enjoy that time? After all, you could still die from an accident after paying the sum at birth/60. It seems highly inappropriate to use a population based metric like life expectancy to have individuals decide if they want a one year increase (likely the individuals don't understand life expectancy as well as).
- ben_w 5y agoAt a guess, old people have a house or something they can sell for that much.
- giantg2 5y agoGiven the massive gap between what people should have for retirement and the little they actually save, they probably need that money for necessities. That's what most people using reverse mortgages use it for today.
- maerF0x0 5y agoBack when I was _really_ into longevity stuff, aubrey de gret etc... I seem to recall that even if we removed all forms of aging people would have an expected lifespan of roughly 1000 years due to trauma death (eg: getting hit by a bus) . So that could serve as a rough rule of thumb for how to think about risk/reward on increasing health in later years. That is it generally has a good EROI for how safe (accident wise) our society actually is.
- wpasc 5y agoIf you don't mind me asking (off-topic), are you less into longevity stuff now? if yes, what made you less into it/possibly more skeptical of it?
- giantg2 5y agoNot the same person, but it used to excite me when I was younger. Now I realize that life is mostly full of bullshit outside our control. I hate my job, so why would I want to live significantly longer when it means working longer? Political and cultural changes could be difficult to handle too.
- epicureanideal 5y agoI sometimes have similar thoughts, but then I wonder, if I were to live to 300, maybe some of the bullshit would go away some time in my 100s and everything might be more enjoyable? Let's hope we don't need to deal with critical race theory / unconscious bias trainings at work and open derogatory statements against non-minorities for more than another 5-10 years, for example... I have to say it's making work a lot less pleasant than it used to be. And maybe if we're extremely lucky some of the VC money will become more widely available to people based on competence rather than connections and personal wealth.
- giantg2 5y agoIf other people are living to 300 too, then I would think it's likely they will bring their bullshit with them, right? I feel like dying isn't just about making physical space for then next generation but also allowing space for cultural changes.
- retzkek 5y agoClimate change is also going to make the world increasingly less pleasant to live in over the next couple decades, directly (weather, flooding, drought, famine, etc) and indirectly (instability, social unrest, war). Unless you can extend your life long enough (and otherwise have the means) to see the other side of this epoch, suffering through more of it is probably not desirable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoSure, it's generally safe. The point I was trying make is why work extra years to pay for a single year when it's not guaranteed. I'd rather quit at 60 and die at 78 than pay $200k, quit at 64, and die at 79.
- maerF0x0 5y agoah, that makes sense. Basically guaranteed vs less than guaranteed. But some percent of the population makes a lot more than that. And much like all things in the economy as they start to consume the products it gets cheaper and moves down classes until it becomes ubiquitous kinda like food is today.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoWhen I did construction, many conversations were about the generous retirement benefits. It was always, "When I retiree I will be able to do this, and that, in comfort." There was always the big decision of shouid I retire at 25 years (25 year old working 25 years), or get a few hundred more if I wait until 65? I knew a person who worked accounting at the union. She told me the average retire whom waits for the bigger pay day, cashed 3 checks. 3 checks----dead. (I was so shocked by this I never told anyone including my father.) The wives did get 1/2 of the retirement, and lived off that for 10-20 years. (I guess I should have been content with any work that offered a retirement?)
- giantg2 5y agoYeah, I've seen some studies that link early retirement to earlier death, but also some that show retirement can trigger underlying issues like stroke and heart attack from the changes.
- maerF0x0 5y agoAnecdotally similar happened to my step-father. He was working extra shifts, overtime etc. Died 6months before full pension. He never cashed a single check and my mom only got about 1/2 of what the full pension would have been worth (discounted value) because he passed "before retirement" . This is part of why I'm so adamant that I think pensions and the like are scams. I want to run my portfolio and my next of kin can have every cent (less taxes)
- somesortofthing 5y agoI'm willing to bet that we're also going to get significantly better at treating trauma within that thousand years though. The numbers aren't great now, sure, but what about in something like 500 years when we can begin doing complex tissue engineering and replacing parts of the CNS? There are certain things that no amount of medical advances will solve, sure(Not really much to replace after your liner to Mars explodes), but I think that if we found a way to cure aging tomorrow, most people would live well beyond 1000.