3 ms·

So she lower the contrast and then gave a component a shadow where as none of the others have any 3D effect and are completely flat? It feels widely inconsisten

So she lower the contrast and then gave a component a shadow where as none of the others have any 3D effect and are completely flat? It feels widely inconsistent to me and the message doesn’t hit right with me. There are people who train in graphic design that eventually become UI/YX designers… which isn’t to say an artist couldn’t go that route, but this doesn’t seem like a particularly compelling example.

Xevi 5y ago
As a frontend dev I would probably stick to the original design if presented with the new one. The new one is inconsistent and looks slightly outdated. Not saying that the original design is perfect though, or that the new one is crap. On top of that, it has some other weird stuff going on, which might be beside the point, but it still caught my attention. For example, why is every input field now a dropdown? Are you really going to select colors and pixels in a dropdown? It just makes it feel sloppy.