10 ms·
NYU Prof Vows Never to Probe Cheating Again—and Faces a Backlash
- ilamont 15y agoEarlier HN discussion, before the blog post was deleted: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2774254 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2774254
- timf 15y agoAnd previous discussion of the post removal: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2784002 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2784002
- jdp23 15y agoI can certainly see why NYU wouldn't want to defend a professor who quoted a student's email without permission.
- culled 15y agoSince when can you not anonymously quote part of an email that was sent to you?
- jdp23 15y agoWhen you've got some kind of duty [in the legal sense] towards the person sending the mail. For example a doctor quoting a patient's email would be problematic. Just to be clear, I don't know the law in this area and I'm not saying what he did was illegal (I have no idea), I'm just saying that I can certainly see why NYU wouldn't want to step up to defend him on this issue if something came up.
- jrockway 15y agoI'm not sure how you can consider doctor/patient and professor/cheating student the same type of relationship. Hell, this was a 100-level class; it's surprising it even had a professor.
- jdp23 15y agoI'm not saying it's the same kind of relationship. But educational institutions and professors certainly have some duties to students.
- Panos 15y agoThe student admitted that the whole email was total BS. I took excerpts of the email and posted them here, not the full message. Come on, could you really believe that this email contained a single element of truth?
- specialist 15y agoAside: I saw a geek news bit about you withdrawing (removing) your post and the heat you're getting. Dude, I'm so sorry. For future, I have two bits of advice. #1 Don't bury the lead. Like myself, the geek news bit also didn't get the point of your post. #2 Focus on the positive. Meaning that all negatives can be stated as a positive. So, were I to have written your blog post, I would have lead with your "future" section (peer reviews, competitions, contemporary projects), enthused about all the positives, and underplayed (or flat out omitted) the back story, the bullshit plagiarism software, the complicity of the administration (shocker!), the cheating students, etc. I definitely would not have responded directly to any personal criticism, especially not in public. That's always a trap. In conclusion, I think you did the right thing, are on the right track, and got burned by being the internet's chew toy of the moment. Lesson learned, move on.
- Panos 15y agoYes, in retrospect, we can easily agree that you are correct. I will just give here the answer that I posted in another thread http://hackerne.ws/item?id=2797371 http://hackerne.ws/item?id=2797371 the post was supposed to be "a story with the twist." Had I known that I was going to have hundreds of thousands of people reading the post, I would have followed the standard journalistic practice of writing a summary at the very first section. (See http://t.co/2kJEkJW http://t.co/2kJEkJW for a copy of the post. Note: I asked the post to be taken down until I repost the original article but the journalist is really playing childish games.) I kind of felt this a few hours after the post went out, so I added two clarification points early on in the article: 1. I am not giving up the fight, I will just fight differently, please see the conclusions (link), 2. This was not about NYU and people cheating in business schools; people cheat everywhere: the story gives an explanation why they remain undetected. Oh well, people could not even read these two points. But I want to write stories in my blog, not papers with an abstract, executive summary and table of contents.
- Sukotto 15y agoComments from someone claiming to be Prof. Panos Ipeirotis and attempting to clarify some points. http://www.businessinsider.com/nyu-professor-class-cheating-2011-7#comment-4e273a85cadcbb434e020000 http://www.businessinsider.com/nyu-professor-class-cheating-...
- jrockway 15y agoThis prevents them from effectively getting into a law school, or being hired by an investment bank. My guess is that this is bullshit. I work at an investment bank and I've never given anyone any official transcripts.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoSome banks do demand transcripts for fresh grads, as do a number of consulting firms.
- roel_v 15y agoBut are you a trader or a quant? I think they were only talking about traders/analysts.
- sgk284 15y agoSo my question is, what if TurnItIn quoted a student's paper instead of the teacher quoting an email? I ask because these university's are effectively giving these student's papers to TurnItIn to use and make a profit on however they please. The students have no say in the matter, and that doesn't seem to be very protective of their privacy.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoUniversities typically have all rights to their students' papers. I'm not sure that I'd expect privacy for college essays either, although it's a bit odd that you are technically not usually allowed to, say, post them to your blog.
- wisesage5001 15y agoDo you have any sources for the claim that universities typically have all rights to a student's papers? I can say for certain that I never signed any intellectual property agreement with the university I attended and would expect to retain all rights to any work I completed there as a student. The work I created did have an implied license allowing for grading the papers and such, but any use beyond that would upset me unless I the university had obtained my permission.
- oniTony 15y agoNot sure on what's typical, but my University uses a "you get to keep your IP" as a selling point; so presumably there must be enough of other institutions where this is not the case. UMissouri's attempt to claim royalties for student's in-class developed iPhone app (although later backing down and changing policies) is an interesting example of the other extreme.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoFrom some random Googling: Duke University does not claim any rights, unless more-than-normal assistance was given (http://www.du.edu/intellectualproperty/iprop.html http://www.du.edu/intellectualproperty/iprop.html); Coventry does claim all rights (http://wwwm.coventry.ac.uk/ipr/students/Pages/FAQstudents.aspx http://wwwm.coventry.ac.uk/ipr/students/Pages/FAQstudents.as...); Waterloo does not (http://secretariat.uwaterloo.ca/Policies/policy73.htm http://secretariat.uwaterloo.ca/Policies/policy73.htm); Leeds does (http://www.leeds.ac.uk/research/hbook/ipr3.htm http://www.leeds.ac.uk/research/hbook/ipr3.htm); Glasgow does not (http://www.gla.ac.uk/services/datamanagement/creatingyourdata/intellectualpropertyrights/ http://www.gla.ac.uk/services/datamanagement/creatingyourdat...). Etc. My old university (Utrecht) did claim all rights. (Note that, where appropriate, I have considered undergraduates; PhD students are typically staff, with the attendant work-for-hire provisions.) Still, it seems that I should amend my statement to "Universities often have..." (Note that this is based on a very quick skimming, and IANAL.)
- drivebyacct2 15y agoDisappointing, it's mostly a recap of the original post. I can understand NYU being worried about the unauthorized quoting of a student's email, but the entire blog post? Surely, I/we are not the only ones finding it ironic, not just that he was negatively impacted (intentionally or not) by doing his job and pursuing the cheaters... but is now at some sort of risk for talking about the problem? Are we going to get into trouble for discussing this case. Jeesh.
- uvdiv 15y agoThis reminds me of a case in Europe, where a PhD chemist was found to have faked/fabricated large parts of his graduate work, including his thesis. (It was on Derek Lowe's blog, pipeline.corante.com, and other places). He used Switzerland's ridiculous privacy laws to C&D journals, papers not to disclose his name in connection with the university investigation. (Or something like that, I'm not a lawyer). So he got off scot-free, and now he works in investment banking. edit: Here's the story http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2009/09/25/faked_data_at_the_eth.php http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2009/09/25/faked_data_a... primaries, http://pubs.acs.org/cen/news/87/i39/8739news4.html http://pubs.acs.org/cen/news/87/i39/8739news4.html http://news.sciencemag.org/scienceinsider/2009/09/fake-data-alleg.html http://news.sciencemag.org/scienceinsider/2009/09/fake-data-...
- sedev 15y ago"and now he works in investment banking." That's one hell of a punchline. Is that serious, or is that just a grim joke? Because sadly it's right smack in the middle of Poe's Law territory.
- uvdiv 15y agoNo, it's extremely funny but it's true. The Ph.D. student at the time left research after receiving his degree and now works as an analyst for an international bank. http://news.sciencemag.org/scienceinsider/2009/09/fake-data-alleg.html http://news.sciencemag.org/scienceinsider/2009/09/fake-data-... The Swiss newspaper Tages Anzeiger reports that the doctoral student has left chemical research to become a financial analyst with the bank UBS. C&EN was unable to reach the former student at press time. http://pubs.acs.org/cen/news/87/i39/8739news4.html http://pubs.acs.org/cen/news/87/i39/8739news4.html
- w1ntermute 15y agoSo no one knows his name? What about newspapers outside Switzerland? > this person's lab notebooks have turned up missing, and are the only primary sources for the whole affair that can't be found Not to condone what he did, but this is one of the reasons I don't keep any physical lab notebooks (scan, encrypt, and shred). Don't want people accessing/confiscating them without my consent.
- g123g 15y agoAgain, instead of trying to some how address the genuine issues raised by the original blog post, people are going to create unnecessary controversy around it till the issue is forgotten. People can't see the forest for the trees. The main issue is that there is rampant cheating going on in the educational institutions. That's where the focus of the universities should be not on issuing these cease and desist letters.
- darksaga 15y agoAgreed. I had the same reaction. The guy outs the problem and the blatant use of cheating by his students and all he gets in return is a kick in the teeth by doing so. I'm glad I never stayed in academia.
- Vivtek 15y agoOh, this so reminds me of all the ass coverage at my wife's last place of work (also in academia).
- jcc80 15y agoyes, so pathetic
- kylemaxwell 15y agoI need to check my web cache. I have no problems hosting a copy of the essay.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- marshray 15y agoI guess the only logical policy for a professor is "don't ask, don't tell, don't talk about it". You there, academic! Back into the closet!
- Caballera 15y agoThat's pretty much how it is. My wife teaches in a NYC public school and has a big issue with plagiarism, although there she can report it all she wants and no one would do anything. Additionally if she tried to assign homework like this professor suggest they would not do it. They would simply take a zero then to have to do a presentation. And then it becomes an issue where the students fail and the teachers passing average drops severely.
- burgerbrain 15y agoI wonder why Marc Parry chose to call him "Mr." instead of the correct "Dr."... a total of 12 whole times.
- williamdix 15y agoPeople with Ph.D.s are not that frequently called Dr. Also, if there is one source that I am pretty sure would know how to refer to professors and Ph.D.s, it would be the Chronicle of Higher Education.
- burgerbrain 15y agohttps://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Doctor_%28title%29#United_States https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Doctor_%28tit... This wikipedia entry seems to indicate that it is common to address someone of his stature as "Dr.", with the possible exception of perhaps in social settings where doing so might cause confusion (with MD).
- vacri 15y agoThat being said, it's also uncommon to specifically use Mr. (except for male surgeons, of course) - not unknown, but uncommon. I'd have less of a problem if the article was about, say, his dog having a funny coat pattern or him complaining about parking restrictions at the local council, but it is weird that in an article about his professional conduct and capacity, that the lesser title should be used.
- mbreese 15y agoMr. is still not the correct formal title for someone with a PhD, Dr. is. The only exception of this is when dealing with patients in a medical setting where the degree could be confused with an MD. (I'm still having flashbacks to addressing wedding invitations 7 years after the fact). Chronicles of higher education might have a different publishing standard, but I'm not sure why they would.
- Estragon 15y agoFunny, people call me and my colleagues "doctor" all the time...
- jcc80 15y agoI think we all saw this coming. Reading his blog post I had that weird feeling of, "How is he actually writing this?" I guess it was cathartic for him but of course NYU would want it taken down.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JadeNB 15y agoFrom the vice dean of faculty, quoted in the article: > Stern faculty members are obligated to support the University and Stern honor codes and are never sanctioned in any way for doing so. Ha! Nothing wrong with that, except that I thought he meant "faculty members who are stern". Here's the interesting bit: > Moreover, the course evaluation input of any student who has an honor code infraction is removed from consideration when evaluating teaching performance. How in the world can you do that, when student evaluations are anonymous? (Maybe they've switched to online evaluations, which would allow this while preserving anonymity.)
- lwat 15y ago> How in the world can you do that, when student evaluations are anonymous? I understand that those students simply don't get to fill in evaluations.
- nigelsampson 15y agoThis also doesn't take into account the impact that being stricter on cheating had on the non-cheating members of the class.
- sunspeck 15y ago“We are also trying to satisfy ourselves that Stern graduates know what they are talking about when they represent themselves to practitioners and in the world of stiff competition with graduates of other top schools.” Wait... is he actually admitting here that NYU wants the post removed because it reveals that >1/5 of its grads are cheaters?
- dfc 15y agoI take it your school did not have a critical reasoning requirement and/or you cheated in class. The post stated that in one class 1/5 of the students had cheated. Even if we pretend that one introductory class is a representative sample of the current enrolled student body you still can not jump from enrolled to graduated. It is entirely possible that a lot of the people who cheat in a 101 level class do not make it to graduation. Please refrain from making silly posts in the future.
- badclient 15y agoWow, I think the professor may be the winner here. I felt that post hurt him more than help him.
- AndrewHampton 15y agoIt seems to me the best solution would be to have a few student workers at the university that are the plagiarism "police". They would review the TurnItIn reports for all student papers and refer offenders to honor boards for punishment. This would leave the professor free to teach and not have to a) spend time policing the student and b) be seen as the bad guy when students get caught and punished.
- charliepark 15y agoThis. There should be an automatic filter, with manual review of violations, that all papers are submitted through. If it fails the filter, it's returned to the student, and the professor hasn't even seen it. The student can redo it, or protest the automated decision, and a human reviewer (an anonymous TA on-campuse) can consider the case (and see the offending text). The reviewer would then pass it on to the professor, who can grade it, or return it to the student to improve. This removes the burden and the penalty from the professor, whose job isn't supposed to be policing plagiarism infractions.
- hncommenter13 15y agoThis is ridiculous. 1. The C&D letter came from "a faculty member at another institution." It could have come from me, or from a guy at the coffee shop down the block. A letter from a faculty member at another institution has about as much weight--considering that he has no claim in the supposed privacy of the material--as the paper it's printed on. NYU should grow a backbone and tell him to pound sand. If that's all it takes for them to turn tail, I wouldn't take their policies on academic freedom very seriously. 2. I'm guessing that the ever-so-helpful faculty member from another institution sent some sort of warning regarding FERPA, the Family Education Rights and Privacy Act of 1974, which generally governs how academic institutions must handle student records. This act has been interpreted in such odd ways that there was a Supreme Court case over whether allowing students in elementary school to grade each other's homework was a violation of federal law (Owasso v. Falvo). My understanding is that FERPA generally applies only to student records with some sort of personally identifiable information on them (i.e., posting grades with ID numbers, publishing contact info on the internet without permission, etc.). If I couldn't possibly identify the student from the portion of the email quoted, it's hard to understand how FERPA could rationally apply. If it were applicable, then any single quotation of any size from any communication with a student would be potentially banned from being repeated. Otherwse, it would be a violation of federal law for a professor to post a sentence of the sort: "A student asked me a very intriguing question today, which went as follows..." 3. If NYU or the professor just don't want the hassle of being at the center of a public debate, then fine. They are free to say or to not say whatever they like. But to scurry away from a debate and blame it on some imagined violation of a student "right" (see Gonzaga v. Doe for how far that "right" goes) is just silly.
- dougws 15y agoAnd of course NYU does nothing to back him up. The spirit of openness and intellectual honesty that universities should be promoting falls by the wayside when it involves a little risk and a little conflict. He did some real research into an interesting and relevant topic, and got the shaft from the university because it uncovered uncomfortable truths. I'd put this on with the sex class incident a few months ago at Northwestern as far as disappointing moves by institutions I'd like to respect.
- URSpider94 15y agoI had the experience of getting my graduate degree from an undergraduate institution with a strict honor code, and my graduate degree from a school without an honor code. Under the honor code, a student caught cheating would, at minimum, fail the course, and at maximum, be expelled. At the other school (theoretically more prestigious), the typical sanction for cheating was to receive an "F" on the suspect assignment. Not surprisingly, in my experience, cheating was far, far more common at the second university than at the first ...
- billmcneale 15y agotl;dr: He faces a backlash because his post violated a federal law protecting student privacy. The takedown had nothing to do with cheating.
- politician 15y ago> He faces a backlash because his post allegedly violated a federal law protecting student privacy. ftfy
- to_jon 15y agoShocking, absolutely shocking to read that MBA students would engage in such behavior. One might imagine, with great difficulty of course, that their sole purpose in entering business school was the pursuit of personal and financial gain by any means.
- tlrobinson 15y ago"We are teaching the next generation of business leaders, and it is important that they think about the consequences of their actions," Exactly. You're not just there to learn the course material. Maybe cheaters don't even know what they're doing is wrong, and by ignoring it you're doing them a disservice. Regarding the "poisoned class environment" issue, it seems like there's a better way to go about it discretely. 1. Include your plagiarism policy clearly on the course syllabus. Be clear about what constitutes plagiarism, how they should cite passages taken from other material, etc. 2. Don't tell students you're using Turnitin, just have them submit papers electronically somehow and run the papers through Turnitin yourself. 3. The first time you catch someone plagiarizing give them a zero on the paper (depending on the severity) and tell them if it happens again they'll be kicked out of the class (or whatever your university's policy is)
- furyg3 15y agoThe problem this particular teacher ran into was that kicking someone out of a class for plagarism / reporting to the university (as per the policy) is a big process, not just a print screen of Turnitin's report... That means that the teacher is spending hours and hours and hours on cheating...
- nickolai 15y agoIf cheating one's way out of doing real work is so pervasive in the institutions training our political and business leaders, i guess the current cirsis situation is not very surprising. What kind of people would you expect at the top of a system that encourages cheating vs doing your homework ?
- vash_stampy 15y agoTo me, the stance that this professor is taking is absurd. He's not helping anyone but himself giving up on efforts to prevent cheating. I really thought he would have made a compelling argument to resolve this, but it seems more like he's become so frustrated with cheating that he's resigned himself from that aspect of education. With that said, I do disagree with the stance that universities take on cheating. The system of punishment is too focused on catching cheaters and punishing them so harshly as scare others to never consider it. I think this prevents many students from being more creative or exploring their own ideas based on previous work. I believe cheating is not something a student commits because of inability, cheating is a crime of laziness. Therefore, rather than trying to catch cheating, schools should just making cheating pointless. Papers and assigments should be completely open and encourage students to look at any previous work and allow them to include it in their own work simply with a citation. To add, professors seem to focused on their students finding credible sources to cite rather than allowing students to form their own ideas. Credible ideas can be founded from less credible sources and that is what should really matter.
- xom 15y agoAs stated, the professor is preventing cheating by modifying the nature of the assignments.
- maeon3 15y agoHe removed his content from his blog, I don't blame him at all, I would have deleted it too, lucky the internet has an un-delete button. "Why I will never pursue cheating again" mirror: https://plus.google.com/106021114396508944027/posts/jgQmKTsWpXP https://plus.google.com/106021114396508944027/posts/jgQmKTsW... ""Why I will never pursue cheating again" word doc copy paste of content: http://machinesentience.com/miscvideos/nyu_professor__why_i_will_never_pursue_cheating_again.doc http://machinesentience.com/miscvideos/nyu_professor__why_i_...