3 ms·
> If someone views a modern electrical utility in a Western country as unreliable then they either have no idea what they are talking about or have unreasonable
by epistasis 5y ago
> If someone views a modern electrical utility in a Western country as unreliable then they either have no idea what they are talking about or have unreasonable expectations.
This is making the error of substituting average performance for the actual performance of a particular grid. The PG&E grid shuts down large amounts of transmission during high wind events:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_California_power_shutoffs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_California_power_shutof...
> Solar and batteries aren't a substitute for grid transmission infrastructure
This is proving to be very wrong. Transmission is extremely expensive, it can be one of the most expensive parts of the grid, and, both batteries and distributed solar are being used as a substitute for transmission.
The term in the industry is "non-wires alternatives," and it was a way for early lithium ion batteries to be used profitably on the grid, even before their recent price drops. (That and frequency regulation in the PJM market).
- eldaisfish 5y agoFor posterity - NERC's report addresses fires specifically and even breaks out individual fires. Yes, people losing power in California happened for extended periods but many more people did not lose power and PG&E was not the only utility implicated there. Besides, natural disasters happen yearly and if you read NERC's report, you'll see that there are far more outages due to storms than wildfires. My only gripe here is that this by itself, does not quality PG&E's grid as "unreliable". As for non-wires alternatives, I can point to several reports, some from NERC, some NREL and others private companies that have found - over and over again - that the path towards more grid reliability involves better transmission and stronger distribution. Batteries and solar can delay the investment needed, not substitute them altogether.