3 ms·
Can you please show me where in my comment above I say that "science is "opinion of experts"? If I haven't said that in my comment, would you say I'm obliged t
by YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago
Can you please show me where in my comment above I say that "science is "opinion
of experts"?
If I haven't said that in my comment, would you say I'm obliged to reply to your
comment and explain why I'm not, in fact, "doing it wrong"?
Do you agree that when having a conversation one should reply to what one's
interlocutor has actually said, and not what one thinks has been said?
>> Science isn't about authority or expertise. It's about evidence, critical
thinking, and the scientific process.
I disagree. "Science" means knowledge. What we call science is a process, like
you say, but it is the process of accumulating and organising the collective
knowledge of our civilisation. "Evidence, critical thinking and the scientific
process" are not the essence of science, but tools to acquire knowledge, and
this knowledge is the essence of science.
The people who have deep knowledge of a subject of scientific inquiry, we call
"experts". At least I do and that's what I mean by "expert" in my comment
above. To become an expert -to acquire deep knowledge in a subject- takes long
years of study and familiarity with the work of other experts. "Evidence,
critical thinking, and the scientific process" don't make anyone an expert. Hard
work and applying oneself to the task of learning is what does.
Yet, what I see on HN, time and again, is that it is the opinions of non-experts
that are supported by the majority of users. I say that because every time I see
a post like the one above, where some researchers announce the results of their
work, someone will always, always, jump in and dismiss the work of the
researchers, and that someone usually has no idea what they're talking about,
has spent a minimal amount of time thinking about or learning about what
they're talking about, and their comment will rise to the top of the
conversation, like a flag waving in the wind proclaiming "we do not care what
you know, we can do better with a quick google and some bungled logic". That
such comments rise to the top of conversations means that they are the ones most
other users agree with.
This, the preponderance of inexpert opinion found as the first comment in posts
about researchers' work, dismissing the researchers' work and supported by a
majority of HN readers, is what I think of as "anti-science".
- woofie11 5y ago> Can you please show me where in my comment above I say that "science is "opinion of experts"? Right here: "What's hasty is the easy dismissal of the *opinion of experts* on a subject ... When did HN become so anti-science?" > The people who have deep knowledge of a subject of scientific inquiry, we call "experts". Those "experts" said that Jews, Slavs, and African Americans were stupid and inferior to Anglo-Saxons, and ought to be enslaved or killed. Science is not a blind deference to "experts." > Hard work and applying oneself to the task of learning is what does. I have not found this to be the case. The harder work required is combing through evidence. People who apply hard work to learning generally come out as ideologues who can regurgitate opinions, from similar ideologues who came before. The way to become an expert involves looking at primary sources and understanding the evidence which went into a conclusion. In my domain, it involves working through a lot of math too. A lot of the scientific establishment is a game of telephone where Bob cites Sue who cites Jill who cites Jim, and by the time you get to the end, there is no trace of evidence left. Good science involves recognizing when that's the case. > This, the preponderance of inexpert opinion found as the first comment in posts about researchers' work, dismissing the researchers' work and supported by a majority of HN readers, is what I think of as "anti-science". Then you're wrong in your thinking. This is anti-scientific-establishment. I am a recognized "expert" in one domain of research. That's why I am anti-scientific-establishment. I see how the sausage gets made. I am pro-science. I think the scientific establishment would benefit from more diversity -- in all dimensions (liberals talk about race and socioeconomics, conservatives about ideology, and no one talks about culture), more transparency, broader engagement, and more, to be blunt, audits to make sure people didn't fabricate results.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> Right here: "What's hasty is the easy dismissal of the opinion of experts on a subject ... When did HN become so anti-science?" So you choose to misrepresent what I said? Disappointing.