6 ms·
That's probably because you're just used to it. To any professional type designer, it's a terribly balanced font aesthetically, basically every letterform. It
by crazygringo 5y ago
That's probably because you're just used to it.
To any professional type designer, it's a terribly balanced font aesthetically, basically every letterform. It looks like a font designed by an engineer, not a designer who knows how to create and balance shapes and lines that are pleasing and easy to the eye. Which, of course, is exactly what it is.
- hosteur 5y agoI hear that a lot. What are examples of good fonts that are free alternatives? And available in latex?
- jjgreen 5y agoMinion Pro is gorgeous (but commercial, but worth it).
- benrbray 5y agoDo you have any examples of math / engineering texts written with Minion Pro? I can mostly find it used for title fonts, or with a ton of line spacing.
- jjgreen 5y agoA slide deck I did a few years ago: http://soliton.vm.bytemark.co.uk/pub/jjg/pdf/vfplot-GUM11.pdf http://soliton.vm.bytemark.co.uk/pub/jjg/pdf/vfplot-GUM11.pd... Oh God, 10 years ago ...
- leephillips 5y agoI took a look to see the font, which I agree is beautiful. But I stayed for the content. Interesting! And what a great presentation! I have so many questions. What happened to this in the intervening decade? Is the idea incorporated into any other plotting packages? Did you purchase this font to use in your talks? > Oh God, 10 years ago ... I know that feeling.
- jjgreen 5y agoToo kind :-) The package vfplot [1] is still available and still under development, it's rather hard to use in that there are lots of parameters to adjust to get decent looking output. There's also an issue in that the "dimension climbing" approach means putting an ellipse at each boundary corner and then as many as you can fit on the line-segment between them, there are lots of ways that this can fail for complex boundaries (coastlines, for example). I think I've fixed this using the fact that "a line segment is a degenerate ellipse", so one can actually calculate a "distance" between a line-segment and an ellipse in almost the same way as one calculates the distance between ellipses. The code for this is in a branch on GitLab [2], but there is still quite a bit of work to do for the 2.0 release (later this year?). [1] http://soliton.vm.bytemark.co.uk/pub/jjg/en/code/vfplot/ http://soliton.vm.bytemark.co.uk/pub/jjg/en/code/vfplot/ [2] https://gitlab.com/jjg/vfplot https://gitlab.com/jjg/vfplot
- ska 5y agoThe equation layout in that doesn't look great, but they are pretty simple so hard to tell details.
- bluenose69 5y agoThis seems like a great method for showing direction fields. And it's in the Gerris context -- double win!
- adiM 5y agoMotion Mountain book: https://www.motionmountain.eu/index.html https://www.motionmountain.eu/index.html (their certificate seems to have expired). PDF copies also available on scribd: https://www.scribd.com/lists/2705622/Motion-Mountain-Collection-English-Translations https://www.scribd.com/lists/2705622/Motion-Mountain-Collect...
- benrbray 5y agoThanks for the example! I think the scribd pdf viewer has some layout issues, but I can now recall that I've seen this font in quite a few places before. It doesn't look bad, but I still don't think it quite works for dense paragraphs of text compared to Latin Modern. I do really like how it looks on the slideshow in a sibling comment, though.
- adiM 5y agoAesthetics of a fonts is such a personal feeling. And fonts feel different on screen vs print.
- PrettyPebble 5y agoThe correct link is https://www.motionmountain.net/index.html https://www.motionmountain.net/index.html
- arnarbi 5y agoHere's an old thesis (of mine) in CS, with a bunch of inference rules, proofs, etc. (Ignore the standardized front matter of ~5 pages) https://skemman.is/bitstream/1946/7418/1/MSc_Arnar-Birgisson.pdf https://skemman.is/bitstream/1946/7418/1/MSc_Arnar-Birgisson...
- lottin 5y agoHorses for courses. A single font will never be adequate for every purpose.
- carlinmack 5y agoCharter is decent
- GiovanniP 5y agoTex Gyre Termes could be. For an example, please look at https://www.texmacs.org/joris/zcomp/zcomp-abs.html https://www.texmacs.org/joris/zcomp/zcomp-abs.html (you can download both a pdf and the TeXmacs source---note that TeXmacs is not based on TeX, you need to use the TeXmacs program to edit it comfortably and to obtain a pdf).
- the-mitr 5y agoLinux Libertine family is good.
- cnity 5y agoEvery criticism I've seen of Computer Modern is an appeal to authority. > not a designer who knows how to create and balance shapes and lines that are pleasing and easy to the eye "Your subjective opinion of the font is wrong, because you're not an expert." If OP and GP (and honestly, most people I know) like the font, how is it not pleasing to the eye? What does it mean for the "aesthetics" to be "_terribly_" balanced?
- crazygringo 5y agoIt's not an appeal to authority, but rather to shared taste. It's true there's no reference manual for the equations for pleasing shapes, because however our preferences are expressed in our brain, we haven't been able to decode. But to give one example to your question: the serifs in Computer Modern are thicker than the thin stems of letterforms. That's ugly, full stop. It's not balanced -- the proportions of thicknesses is backwards. The entire function of serifs is to taper and/or finish, never to add weight. Or another: the loop (lower part) of the double-story lowercase "g" simply extends way too far to the right. It makes the letter feel like it's going to tilt and fall over to the left. It's not balanced, period. So these are just two examples of terrible balance. Does that hopefully answer your question in a way that isn't an appeal to authority? Edit: curious why I'm being downvoted for this comment, when I'm just trying to answer the parent comment with actual examples.
- corty 5y agoThe slight unbalance and the not-totally-uniform looks make cmr much more readable. The breaking with the typesetting tradition makes it better, because it is unhindered by such useless flourishes as "must taper" or "must look like any other letter fitting into a uniform box of equal greying when smudged". cmr does this while still looking good and pleasing when viewed in whole paragraphs as opposed to single letters. And where cmr absolutely excels is the accompanying greek, math symbols and typesetting. Nothing else comes even close in getting it readable, pleasing and uniform.
- crazygringo 5y ago
- benrbray 5y ago> It looks like a font designed by an engineer, not a designer This is exactly why I like it. Designed by an engineer for the purpose of typesetting engineering articles and books. Most of the other alternative fonts feel like they were designed by a designer with all the unnecessary flairs that would make a great title/heading font to pad the portfolio but are needlessly distracting in a paragraph of dense technical text interspersed with equations. Keep in mind that Google / Facebook / Twitter / Apple / Microsoft / etc hire hordes of professional designers and the result is a horrible user experience for everyone. I much prefer Wikipedia and Hacker News to most "modern" web design by professionals.
- hocuspocus 5y ago> Most of the other alternative fonts feel like they were designed by a designer with all the unnecessary flairs that would make a great title/heading font to pad the portfolio but are needlessly distracting in a paragraph of dense technical text interspersed with equations. Serious alternatives were designed by foundries decades or even centuries ago.
- crazygringo 5y agoI don't know where you're getting "unnecessary flair" from. What unnecessary flair do fonts like Times New Roman or Baskerville or Bodoni have? (Obviously I'm comparing with other similar fonts traditionally used for body text typesetting with equations.) I'm talking about good sense of aesthetic proportion and balance, not "flair". And what exactly is the horrible user experience that Google has created with Roboto, or Apple with San Francisco, or Microsoft with Calibri? They're actually quite excellently balanced and pleasing fonts for their purposes.
- leephillips 5y agoYou’re both wrong. It was designed by a mathematician, for use in printing mathematical books.
- SeanLuke 5y agoComputer Modern is largely a copy of Monotype Modern, which dates from 1896. Monotype Modern was, I assure you, not designed by a mathematician nor was designed for use in printing math books. However many math books had lately been printed using typefaces similar to Modern, and Knuth liked how it looked.
- jgon 5y agoWasn't Computer Modern created with input from Herman Zapf, and Matthew Carter among other titans of typography? I don't think Knuth just whipped it up in isolation without any feedback, so this whole "it looks like a font designed by an engineer" seems both incorrect and needlessly arrogant?
- dhosek 5y agoI don't think Carter had any input. There was some (minimal) input from Zapf, mostly with respect to the calligraphic capitals. Mostly, Knuth was trying to replicate the Monotype Modern. Some of the fonts like cmr17 are especially bad (the extrapolation of parameters to larger design sizes was not correct). That said, I do think that cmtt is a superior typeface for monospace typesetting.
- ska 5y ago> To any professional type designer, it's a terribly balanced font aesthetically, basically every letterform. It works pretty well balanced in print on systems it was originally targeted to. The main problem with using other fonts in TeX/LaTeX (or anything in, say, Word) is making it so complex equations lay out reasonably. Admittedly a niche problem, but one one that was the original purpose of TeX - and CM works well for it. There are a small number of other options that don't screw it up.
- jhanschoo 5y agoIt doesn't work well in print. It's less legible than more common typefaces in comparable sizes on account of its lightness, for certain printing technologies
- ska 5y agoIt works well in print if tuned to the printing technology, as originally designed. You should be able to adjust it (again, as designed) for the print technology you are using. Most common typefaces are useless for mathematics, so it's a bit of an oranges and apples comparison anyway.